The Incidence of Error in Young Children's Wh-Questions

Rowland, Caroline F.; Pine, Julian M.; Lieven, Elena V. M.; Theakston, Anna L.
April 2005
Journal of Speech, Language & Hearing Research;Apr2005, Vol. 48 Issue 2, p384
Academic Journal
Many current generativist theorists suggest that young children possess the grammatical principles of inversion required for question formation but make errors because they find it difficult to learn language-specific rules about how inversion applies. The present study analyzed longitudinal spontaneous sampled data from twelve 2-3-year-old English speaking children and the intensive diary data of 1 child (age 2;7 [years;months] to 2;11) in order to test some of these theories. The results indicated significantly different rates of error use across different auxiliaries. In particular, error rates differed across 2 forms of the same auxiliary subtype (e.g., auxiliary is vs. are), and auxiliary DO and modal auxiliaries attracted significantly higher rates of errors of inversion than other auxiliaries. The authors concluded that current generativist theories might have problems explaining the patterning of errors seen in children's questions, which might be more consistent with a constructivist account of development. However, constructivists need to devise more precise predictions in order to fully explain the acquisition of questions.


Related Articles

  • LES SUBORDONNÉES DITES INTERROGATIVES COMME COMPLÉMENTS DE DÉPENDANCE. DE CORNULIER, BENOÎT // Therapeutics, Pharmacology & Clinical Toxicology;Dec2013, Vol. 58 Issue 4, p131 

    In the present article, I argue that, not only in such explicit expressions as « Whether Q depends on whether P », but in a more general sense, a so-called « embedded question » or « subordinate interrogative clause » represents one pole in a distributive conditional relation...

  • Comparison of Two Methods for Selecting Minimum Stimulation Levels Used in Programming the... Skinner, Margaret W.; Holden, Laura K.; Holden, Timothy A.; Demorest, Marilyn E. // Journal of Speech, Language & Hearing Research;Aug1999, Vol. 42 Issue 4, p814 

    Minimum stimulation levels for active electrodes in a Nucleus 22 cochlear implant were set at threshold [clinical default value) and raised levels (M = +2.04 dB) to determine if raised levels would improve recipients' understanding of soft speech sounds with the SPEAK speech coding strategy....

  • RECALL FOR ANSWERS TO "CONDUCIVE" QUESTIONS. Fillenbaum, Samuel // Language & Speech;Jan-Mar68, Vol. 11 Issue 1, p46 

    Focuses on the effect of question format at time of recall test. Formulation of grammatical rules for questions; Transformation component of the grammar; Basis for expecting a comparable effect for positive questions.

  • Twelve (or So) Grumbles about American "English.". Jago, Michael // California English;Winter99, Vol. 5 Issue 2, p25 

    The article evaluates a sentence for grammatical errors and discusses the common errors Americans commit in writing and speech. The errors observed in the sentence include the overuse of commas, the incorrect use of adverbs, split infinitives and oxymorons, and the as/like dichotomy. Other...

  • Punctuation Categories: Question- Direct Question.  // Punctuation Thesaurus;1991, p237 

    The article focuses on the rules related to the use of direct questions in a sentence. A question mark should be inserted after a question when it stands alone. The question may even have missing, but implied, words. For instance, the one with the waggly tail? This question has "Are you talking...

  • THE QUIZ.  // Copyediting;Aug2010, p1 

    A quiz concerning the grammatical errors in a certain sentence is presented.

  • THE QUIZ.  // Copyediting;Dec2011, p1 

    A quiz concerning grammatical errors in a sentence is presented.

  • Funny FILL-IN. BOWMAN, BIANCA // National Geographic Kids;Dec2013, Issue 436, p35 

    A quiz about language and grammar is presented.

  • Grammar Cop: The Case of My Favorite Pet!  // Storyworks;Feb/Mar2010, Vol. 17 Issue 5, p5 

    A quiz related to grammar is presented.


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics