The Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA): Its Broad Effect on Practice

Feld, Andrew D.
July 2005
American Journal of Gastroenterology;Jul2005, Vol. 100 Issue 7, p1440
Academic Journal
The Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA), and its final rule, raised fears among practitioners of new and complex regulations that might interfere with medical practice, lead to inadvertent liability and unwanted expense. It generated a dizzying set of health-care administrative activities and a new work for legal consultants. It has extensive scope, and includes most health plans and practitioners. It has regulated both privacy and security, including electronic, paper, and oral communications. However, after a HIPAA compliant office structure is established, and the privacy notice is reviewed and signed by the patient, disclosure of medical information for treatment, payment or “health-care operations” is permitted without recurrent consent forms, thus allowing substantially familiar patterns of doctor-to-doctor communication about treatment. Further, the initial approach to enforcement appears to some legal observers to be more likely corrective rather than punitive, although providers remain uneasy over the mere possibility of criminal penalties. As regards medical research, uncertainties about the application of HIPAA seem less resolved and more variably interpreted by different institutions, with ongoing fear in the research community that important public health and epidemiologic research activity may be compromised by well meaning IRBs using inconsistent, overly strict or erroneous interpretation of the intent of HIPAA regulations. (Am J Gastroenterol 2005;100;1440–1443)


Related Articles

  • Health Insurance In Mexico: Achieving Universal Coverage Through Structural Reform. Knaul, Felicia Marie; Frenk, Julio // Health Affairs;Nov/Dec2005, Vol. 24 Issue 6, p1467 

    Fairness in finance is an intrinsic and challenging goal of health systems. Mexico recently devised a structural reform that responds to this challenge. Through a new system of social protection in health that will offer public insurance to all citizens, the reform is expected to reduce...

  • Study: High-Deductible Health Plans May Have Pitfalls. Grier, Chris // Best's Review;Mar2005, Vol. 105 Issue 11, p54 

    Reports on the outcome of high-deductible health plans for quality health care according to a study in the U.S. Promotion of health savings accounts by the Republican Party; Discovery of medical debt on health plan holders; Reduction on the use of effective medical services with the...

  • Are all health plan networks the same? A recent survey says they aren't.  // Managed Healthcare Executive;Jun2004, Vol. 14 Issue 6, p38 

    Presents the results of a study showing that health plan networks accessibility varies sufficiently to influence health plan selection by benefits consultants and buyers in the United States. Percent of consumers with access to a minimum number of providers of various types within specified...

  • Consumer-Directed Health Plans.  // Health Management Technology;Nov2006, Vol. 27 Issue 11, p10 

    This article states that a Kaiser Family Foundation study has reconfirmed what many already know: Consumer-directed health plans are not exploding on the consumerism horizon, and the numbers of consumers taking advantage of health savings accounts (HSAs) are even smaller. The Foundation joined...

  • On The Road To Universal Coverage: Impacts Of Reform In Massachusetts At One Year. Long, Sharon K. // Health Affairs;Jul/Aug2008 Web Exclusives, Vol. 27, pw270 

    In April 2006, Massachusetts passed legislation intended to move the state to near-universal coverage within three years and, in conjunction with that expansion, to improve access to affordable, high-quality health care. In roughly the first year under reform, uninsurance among working-age...

  • Medicare Advantage: Déjà Vu All Over Again? Biles, Brian; Dallek, Geraldine; Nicholas, Lauren Hersch // Health Affairs;Jul-Dec2004 Supplement 2, Vol. 23, p586 

    The Medicare Prescription Drug, Improvement, and Modernization Act (MMA) of 2003 expands the role of private health plans in Medicare through prescription drug plans and a revised Medicare+Choice (M+C), renamed Medicare Advantage, program. This paper discusses the factors responsible for the...

  • Coordinated Care In A 'Consumer-Driven' Health System. Yegian, Jill Mathews // Health Affairs;2006 Web Exclusives, Vol. 25, pw531 

    High-deductible health plans—with and without spending accounts—are gaining ground. Will these evolving benefit designs complement or undermine the coordination of care for patients with chronic illnesses? Based on an October 2005 roundtable sponsored by the California HealthCare...

  • Looking Abroad for Answers about Universal Health.  // Research at Penn;2009, Vol. 7, p18 

    The article reports on the involvement of Arnold Rosoff, a senior fellow at the Leonard Davis Institute of Health Economics, to the ongoing study of the health care systems in five countries, namely in Argentina, France, Italy, Japan and Singapore. The study has identified some of the factors...

  • Whence And Whither Health Insurance? A Revisionist History. Moran, Donald W. // Health Affairs;Nov/Dec2005, Vol. 24 Issue 6, p1415 

    Throughout the postwar era in federal health policy, policymakers have sought to expand both public and private insurance coverage, while wrestling with the cost consequences of the demand generated by the insurance-financing mechanisms thus created. This essay advances the view that the limits...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics