TITLE

Reasonable Partiality and the Agent’s Point of View

AUTHOR(S)
Thomas, Alan
PUB. DATE
January 2005
SOURCE
Ethical Theory & Moral Practice;Jan2005, Vol. 8 Issue 1/2, p25
SOURCE TYPE
Academic Journal
DOC. TYPE
Article
ABSTRACT
It is argued that reasonable partiality allows an agent to attach value to particular objects of attachment via recognition of the value of the holding of that relation between agent and object. The reasonableness of partiality is ensured by a background context set by the agent’s virtues, notably justice. It is argued that reasonable partiality is the only view that is compatible with our best account of the nature of self-knowledge. That account rules out any instrumental relationship between moral demands and moral character, but that familiar claim is given an unfamiliar explanation. Instrumentality depends on a prior objectification of the self and it is that kind of objectification that, in the ethical case, represents a form of ethical evasion. Self-knowledge is transparent, incomplete and essentially connected with first person endorsement. The transparency condition is that knowledge of one’s state of mind is “taken” transparently to its object. More specifically, ethical transparency is the feature that my virtues do not exhibit themselves to me in self-knowledge, but take me transparently to the way in which they saliently represent the world as containing evaluative properties calling for various forms of response. It is concluded that reasonable partiality grounded in the nature of the virtues is the only reflective account of morality compatible with the most plausible account of the nature of self-knowledge. The demands of impartiality are incompatible with a condition of having a personal point of view, namely, that a self can stand in a non-alienated relation to itself via its capacity for self-knowledge.
ACCESSION #
17090126

 

Related Articles

  • HYPOCRISY. Farrell, James J. // Clergy Journal;Oct2004, Vol. 81 Issue 1, p14 

    Discusses the pervasive practice of hypocrisy. Characteristics of hypocrisy; Alleged cultural value instead of moral virtue of hypocrisy; Human weakness involved in hypocrisy; Importance of public virtue recognized by hypocrites.

  • Living Well with End Stage Renal Disease: Patients' Narratives Interpreted from a Virtue Perspective. Dekkers, Wim; Uerz, Inez; Wils, Jean-Pierre // Ethical Theory & Moral Practice;Dec2005, Vol. 8 Issue 5, p485 

    Over the last few decades there has been a revival of interest in virtue ethics, with the emphasis on the virtuous caregiver. This paper deals with the ‘virtuous patient’, specifically the patient with End Stage Renal Disease (ESRD). We believe that a virtue approach provides...

  • The Hen or the Egg? McDonald, Irving T. // America;3/22/1930, Vol. 42 Issue 24, p568 

    The article focuses on various issues and topics related to a proper defense when imposing justice. Accordingly, a good defense must be made strong by much exercise. Much might be said about whether a new piece of indecency is only a quantitative increase of an already existing commodity, or a...

  • Vulnerability As Key To Sacramentality. CASIMER, Lisa A. // Theological Research Exchange Network (TREN): Theses & Dissertat;2002, p1 

    The article presents the thesis study "VULNERABILITY AS KEY TO SACRAMENTALITY," by Lisa A. Casimer. This study has hoped to demonstrate the ways in which vulnerability poses as an overloading value from the personal to the institutional level. The author of the study has concluded that the only...

  • Vulnerability As Key To Sacramentality. CASIMER, Lisa A. // Theological Research Exchange Network (TREN): Theses & Dissertat;2002, p1 

    The article presents the thesis study "VULNERABILITY AS KEY TO SACRAMENTALITY," by Lisa A. Casimer. This study has hoped to demonstrate the ways in which vulnerability poses as an overloading value from the personal to the institutional level. The author of the study has concluded that the only...

  • Patience is a virtue -- and a must when negotiating. Gitomer, Jeffrey // Long Island Business News (7/1993 to 5/2009);1/5/2007, Vol. 54 Issue 1, p22A 

    The author reflects on the virtue of patience, which is a must when negotiating. The author said that the thing he hates about negotiating is that when there is a tough one, no one ends up winning, unless there is a lawyer involved. His fatal flaw in negotiation is that when he is one, he tend...

  • Compassion and Beyond. Crisp, Roger // Ethical Theory & Moral Practice;Jun2008, Vol. 11 Issue 3, p233 

    This paper is a discussion of the emotion of compassion or pity, and the corresponding virtue. It begins by placing the emotion of compassion in the moral conceptual landscape, and then moves to reject the currently dominant view, a version of Aristotelianism developed by Martha Nussbaum, in...

  • THE RESPECTFUL NURSE. Gallagher, Ann // Nursing Ethics;May2007, Vol. 14 Issue 3, p360 

    Respect is much referred to in professional codes, in health policy documents and in everyday conversation. What respect means and what it requires in everyday contemporary nursing practice is less than clear. Prescriptions in professional codes are insufficient, given the complexity and...

  • On Treating Like Cases Alike. Winston, Kenneth I. // California Law Review;Jan1974, Vol. 62 Issue 1, p1 

    Comments on problems being posed by the fifth claim of H.L.A. Hart that a minimum of justice is necessarily realized whenever human conduct is governed by general rules publicly announced and judicially applied. Significance for the separation of law and morality; Confirmation of a suspicion...

Share

Read the Article

Courtesy of THE LIBRARY OF VIRGINIA

Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics