Reason and Love: A Non-Reductive Analysis of the Normativity of Agent-Relative Reasons

Willigenburg, Theo
January 2005
Ethical Theory & Moral Practice;Jan2005, Vol. 8 Issue 1/2, p45
Academic Journal
Why do agent-relative reasons have authority over us, reflective creatures? Reductive accounts base the normativity of agent-relative reasons on agent-neutral considerations like ‘having parents caring especially for their own children serves best the interests of all children’. Such accounts, however, beg the question about the source of normativity of agent-relative ways of reason-giving. In this paper, I argue for a non-reductive account of the reflective necessity of agent-relative concerns. Such an account will reveal an important structural complexity of practical reasoning in general. Christine Korsgaard relates the rational binding force of practical reasons to the various identities or self-conceptions under which we value ourselves. The problem is that it is not clear why such self-conceptions would necessitate us rationally, given the fact that most of our identities are simply given. Perhaps, Harry Frankfurt is right in arguing that we are not only necessitated by reason, but also, and predominantly by what we love. I argue, however, that “the necessities of love” (in Frankfurt’s phrase) are not to be separated from, but should be seen as belonging to the necessities of reason. Our loves, concerns and related identities provide for a specific and important structure to practical reflection. They function on the background of reasoning, having a specific default role: they would lose their character as concerns, if there was a need for them to be cited on the foreground of deliberation or if there was a need to justify them. This does not mean that our deep concerns cannot be scrutinised. They can only be scrutinised in an indirect way, however, which explains their role in grounding the normativity of agent-relative reasons. It appears that this account can provide for a viable interpretation of Korsgaard’s argument about the foundational role of practical identities.


Related Articles

  • DELIBERATION, ACTION AND NORMATIVITY. Millán, Gustavo Ortiz // Tópicos. Revista de Filosofía;2009, Issue 36, p155 

    In this paper I comment on several aspects of Martin Seel's paper "The Ability to Deliberate", mainly on his claims that deliberation is a form of action, on his not very clear distinction between deliberation and thought, and on the relation between normativity and deliberation. There are also...

  • What is (Correct) Practical Reasoning? Fink, Julian // Acta Analytica;Dec2013, Vol. 28 Issue 4, p471 

    This paper argues that practical reasoning is a mental process which leads a person from a set of existent mental states to an intention. In Section 1, I defend this view against two other proposals according to which practical reasoning either concludes in an action itself or in a normative...

  • Desires as additional reasons? The case of tie-breaking. Tanyi, Attila // Philosophical Studies;Jan2011, Vol. 152 Issue 2, p209 

    ording to the Desire-Based Reasons Model reasons for action are provided by desires. Many, however, are critical about the Model holding an alternative view of practical reason, which is often called valued-based. In this paper I consider one particular attempt to refute the Model, which...

  • The special status of instrumental reasons. Beardman, Stephanie // Philosophical Studies;May2007, Vol. 134 Issue 2, p255 

    The rationality of means-end reasoning is the bedrock of the Humean account of practical reasons. But the normativity of such reasoning can not be taken for granted. I consider and reject the idea that the normativity of instrumental reasoning can be explained – either in terms of its...

  • On Miligram on Mill. Miller, Dale F. // Utilitas;Mar2004, Vol. 16 Issue 1, p96 

    In a recent article in Ethics, Elijah Millgram presents a novel reconstruction of J. S. Mill's ‘proof’ of the principle of utility. Millgram's larger purpose is to critique instrumentalist approaches to practical reasoning. His reading of the proof makes Mill out to be an...

  • Preconditions for Normative Argumentation in a Pluralist World. Graham, Keith // Argumentation;Nov2001, Vol. 15 Issue 4, p471 

    A problem arises, both for philosophy and for argumentation theory, in a pluralist world where people hold widely different beliefs about what to do. Some responses to this problem, including relativism, might settle but do not provide any criteria for resolving such differences. Alternative...

  • Moral Obligation and Everyday Advice. Brecher, Bob // South African Journal of Philosophy;2005, Vol. 24 Issue 2, p109 

    A major obstacle in the way of any rationalistic under standing of morality is that the moral ‘ought’ obliges action: and on the (neo-)Humean view, action is thought to require affect. If, however, one could show that ‘ordinary’ practical reasons are by them selves...

  • Elements of Natural Logic for the Study of Unnoticed Misunderstanding in a Communicative Approach to Learning. KOHLER, Alaric // Argumentum: Journal the Seminar of Discursive Logic, Argumentati;2015, Vol. 13 Issue 2, p80 

    This paper presents a methodology building on Grize's Natural Logic to study unnoticed misunderstanding in teaching and learning communication. The study of unnoticed misunderstanding is important for education, as misunderstanding has been pointed out as a candidate mechanism for the...

  • Does the Explanatory Constraint on Practical Reasons favour Naturalism about Practical Reasons? Roberts, Deborah // South African Journal of Philosophy;2005, Vol. 24 Issue 2, p97 

    There is an explanatory constraint on practical reasons: practical reasons have to be the kinds of things that we can act for. Some philosophers, notably Bernard Williams, have argued that the explanatory constraint favours internalism about reasons: for an agent to have a reason to Φ it is...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics