Towards a Sociological turn in Contextualist Moral Philosophy

Van Der Stoep, Jan
April 2004
Ethical Theory & Moral Practice;Apr2004, Vol. 7 Issue 2, p133
Academic Journal
Contextualist moral philosophers criticise hands-off liberal theories of justice for abstracting from the cultural context in which people make choices. Will Kymlicka and Joseph Carens, for example, demonstrate that these theories are disadvantageous to cultural minorities who want to pursue their own way of life. I argue that Pierre Bourdieu's critique of moral reason radicalises contextualist moral philosophy by giving it a sociological turn. In Bourdieu's view it is not enough to provide marginalised groups or subgroups with equal access to public institutions and specific cultural rights—in some cases this may in fact be detrimental. He contends that scientists, politicians and other intellectuals have a duty to take seriously the social presuppositions of free deliberate choice and public opinion and to support cultural minorities with instruments to liberate themselves from their often precarious situation.


Related Articles

  • Portrayal and betrayal: Bourdieu, photography and sociological life. Back, Les // Sociological Review;Aug2009, Vol. 57 Issue 3, p471 

    Through an examination of Bourdieu's Algerian fieldwork the article raises general questions regarding the place of photography in sociological research. In the midst of a colonial war Bourdieu used photography to make visual fieldnotes and record the mixed realities of Algeria under...

  • Comparative Sociology of Law: Legal Fields, Legal Scholarships, and Social Sciences in Europe and the United States. García-Villegas, Mauricio // Law & Social Inquiry;Spring2006, Vol. 31 Issue 2, p343 

    This article attempts to gain a better understanding of the sociology(ies) of law in a comparative perspective through a structural and comparative explanation of the American and the French legal fields. It is argued that comparative sociology of law will not be able to explain the difference...

  • Reworking Moral Regulation: Metaphorical Capital and the Field of Disinterest. Curtis, Bruce // Canadian Journal of Sociology;Summer1997, Vol. 22 Issue 3, p303 

    Can we follow Pierre Bourdieu's work to develop a "society-centered" analysis of moral regulation? Probably not, but his analysis of a field of disinterest may be helpful.

  • Pierre Bourdieu and Literature. Dubois, Jacques; Emery, Meaghan // Substance: A Review of Theory & Literary Criticism;2000, Vol. 29 Issue 3, p84 

    Examines the literary approach in the sociology of French intellectual Pierre Bourdieu. Description of Bourdieu's sociological thought; Reason for the sociologist's interest in the system of literary production; Foundations of Bourdieu's literary research; Overview of the social history of...

  • Bourdieu's Uneasy Psychoanalysis. Fourny, Jean-François // Substance: A Review of Theory & Literary Criticism;2000, Vol. 29 Issue 3, p103 

    Examines the role of psychoanalysis in the sociology of French intellectual Pierre Bourdieu. Analysis of the relationship between sociology and psychoanalysis in Bourdieu's book `Questions de sociologie'; Concept of socioanalysis.

  • Generative Schema and Reflexivity: On Pierre Bourdieu's Sociology of knowledge. Zhao Wanli; Zhao Chao // Society: Chinese Journal of Sociology / Shehui;2012, Vol. 32 Issue 2, p33 

    Bourdieu ' s sociology of knowledge makes an integral part of his sociological theory and is a critical clue for understanding his entire sociological research. This article takes his sociology of knowledge as a unique approach to systematically review Bourdieu's theory in the areas of knowledge...

  • Resúmenes.  // Estudios Sociológicos;may-ago2010, Vol. 28 Issue 83, p611 

    Spanish abstracts are presented for the articles published in this journal including "La sociología poscolonial. Estado del arte y perspectivas" by Sergio Costa y Manuela Boatcă, "Niklas Luhmann y Pierre Bourdieu: claves teóricas para la interpretación del clientélisme-...

  • Abstracts.  // Estudios Sociológicos;may-ago2010, Vol. 28 Issue 83, p617 

    English abstracts are presented for the articles published in this journal including Postcolonial sociology: a research agenda" by Sergio Costa y Manuela Boatcă, "Niklas Luhmann and Pierre Bourdieu: theoretical keys for interpreting political clientage in Argentina" by Magdalena Tosoni and...

  • Pierre Bourdieu and Populism: The Everyday Politics of Outrageous Resistance. GRATTAN, LAURA // Good Society Journal;2012, Vol. 21 Issue 2, p194 

    An essay is presented on the contemporary populism. It explores the theory of habitus by populist Pierre Bourdieu. It analyzes methodological approaches to understand contemporary populism. It discusses the need for the democratizing impulse of populist politics to be cultivated in the...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics