Blame and Responsibility

Williams, Garrath
December 2003
Ethical Theory & Moral Practice;Dec2003, Vol. 6 Issue 4, p427
Academic Journal
This paper looks at judgments of guilt in the face of alleged wrong-doing, be it in public or in private discourse. Its concern is not the truth of such judgments, although the complexity and contestability of such claims will be stressed. The topic, instead, is what sort of activities we are engaged in, when we make our judgments on others' conduct. To examine judging as an activity it focuses on a series of problems that can occur when we blame others. On analysis, we see that these problems take the form of performative contradictions, so that the ostensible purposes of assigning guilt to others are undermined. There is clear evidence from social psychology that blame is especially frequently and inappropriately attributed to individuals in modern Western societies. On the other hand, it has often been observed how suspicious we are about the activity of judging – thus a widespread perception that a ‘refusal to judge’ is somehow virtuous. My suggestion is that the sheer difficulty of attributions of responsibility, in the face of a complex and often arbitrary moral reality, frequently defeats us. This leads to a characteristic set of distortions when we blame, so that it is no surprise that we have become suspicious of all blaming activities. Yet, the paper argues, these problems need not arise when we hold others responsible. This paper therefore investigates what, exactly, can be questionable about attempts to assign guilt, and the structural logic that lies behind these problems – what will be called, adapting a term from social psychology, a “belief in a just world.” Such a belief takes for granted what needs to be worked for through human activity, and therefore tends to be counter-productive in dealing with misdeeds and adverse outcomes.


Related Articles

  • Got guilt? Carrell, Susan // Alive: Canada's Natural Health & Wellness Magazine;May2009, Issue 319, p56 

    The article discusses the signs of toxic guilt and how to overcome toxic guilt. It states that people who suffer from toxic guilt tend to overly giving, hyper-responsible, devoted to pleasing others and inclined to rescue. The author said that establishing good boundaries or emotional fences is...

  • FORGIVENESS IS AN INSIDE JOB. Phillips, Barbara Ashley // Edmontonians;Dec2011, Vol. 22 Issue 4, p23 

    In this article the author discusses how forgiveness can bring a change in a relationship. According to the author, when someone forgives another, he means to say that the other person is guilty, and he raises himself above that person and degrades the other person. The author says that spoken...

  • RELATIONSHIPS.  // Youth Studies Australia;Jun2008, Vol. 27 Issue 2, p9 

    The article presents research concerning the romantic relationships among Australian teenagers in Australia and Hong Kong, China. Researchers found that one-third of young Australians have been unfaithful in a romantic relationship at least once. A study shows that around 80% of them experienced...

  • if you're sorry say it slowly. Patz, Aviva // Health (Time Inc. Health);Apr2005, Vol. 19 Issue 3, p116 

    Presents tips on apologizing based on the findings of studies published in the "Journal of Experimental Social Psychology." Indications of the readiness of a person to accept an apology.

  • The Dance of Selves in Relationship. Kent, John // Positive Health;Feb2010, Issue 167, p1 

    The article explores the reasons why opposite often attract and why people in a relationship tend to repeat the same patterns of interaction with different partners. It cites several factors that can strain relationships, such as sickness, financial problems and work issues. The lessons that can...

  • Guilt -- who needs it? MacMillan, Alissa // Redbook;Dec98, Vol. 192 Issue 2, p87 

    Focuses on how to deal with guilt in interpersonal relationships. Use of apology; Being regretful; Putting a stop to manipulators; Physiological effects of guilt.

  • Get over your gift guilt. Maran, Meredith // Health (Time Inc.);Dec2006, Vol. 20 Issue 10, p113 

    The author explains that experts assert people are increasingly using gift giving as a substitute for human interaction in relationships. Several different questions are presented for readers to ask of themselves in order to determine if they are giving gifts out of guilt or out of generosity....

  • THE EFFECTS OF PSYCHOLOGICAL CLOSENESS AND TYPE EXCHANGE SITUATION ON PERCEIVED INEQUITY. Campbell, Donald J. // Academy of Management Journal;Jun78, Vol. 21 Issue 2, p307 

    In this article the author discusses research he conducted that examined the effects that psychological closeness has one one's perceptions of inequity. The aim of this study is to examine if feelings of inequity are a function of the perceived closeness of the comparison person examined. He...

  • GUILT AND HELPING. Miller, Christian // International Journal of Ethics;2008, Vol. 6 Issue 2/3, p231 

    A wealth of research in social psychology over the past twenty years has examined the role that guilt plays in our mental lives. In this paper, I examine just one aspect of this vast literature, namely the relationship between guilt and prosocial behavior. Researchers have typically found a...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics