Why Response-Dependence Theories of Morality are False

Randel Koons, Jeremy
September 2003
Ethical Theory & Moral Practice;Sep2003, Vol. 6 Issue 3, p275
Academic Journal
Many response-dependence theorists equate moral truth with the generation of some affective psychological response: what makes this action wrong, as opposed to right, is that it would cause (or merit) affective response of type R (perhaps under ideal conditions). Since our affective nature is purely contingent, and not necessarily shared by all rational creatures (or even by all humans), response-dependence threatens to lead to relativism. In this paper, I will argue that emotional responses and moral features do not align in the way predicted by the response-dependence theorist who wishes to tie morality to emotional affect. I further argue that since response-dependence accounts that tie morality to any sort of affect (be it an emotion, a desire, a desire to desire, or so on) cannot explain the objectivity and universality of morality; and since we do not need a psychological response to play a truth-constituting role in morality in order to explain the normativity or content of morality, we should reject such response-dependence accounts.


Related Articles

  • Ethical Theory, Completeness & Consistency. Moore, Andrew // Ethical Theory & Moral Practice;Jun2007, Vol. 10 Issue 3, p297 

    This paper argues that many leading ethical theories are incomplete, in that they fail to account for both right and wrong. It also argues that some leading ethical theories are inconsistent, in that they allow that an act can be both right and wrong. The paper also considers responses on behalf...

  • Comment comprendre les émotions morales. Clavien, Christine // Dialogue: Canadian Philosophical Review;Sep2009, Vol. 48 Issue 3, p601 

    The two main goals of this paper are to question the possibility of the existence of moral emotions and to decipher the notion of moral emotion. I start with a brief critical analysis of various philosophical understandings of moral emotions before setting out an evolutionary line of approach...

  • Dispositional Essentialism and the Possibility of a Law-Abiding Miracle. Handfield, Toby // Philosophical Quarterly;Oct2001, Vol. 51 Issue 205, p484 

    Dispositional essentialists assert that at least some of the dispositions associated with a natural property are essential to that property.¹ On this view, for example, it might be a necessary truth that being positively charged entails having the disposition to attract negatively charged...

  • From relative truth to Finean non-factualism. Jackson, Alexander // Synthese;Mar2016, Vol. 193 Issue 3, p971 

    This paper compares two 'relativist' theories about deliciousness: truth-relativism, and Kit Fine's non-factualism about a subject-matter. Contemporary truth-relativism is presented as a linguistic thesis; its metaphysical underpinning is often neglected. I distinguish three views about the...

  • Beyond Ethical Codes: A Call For Critical Thinking In Religious Culture. Talavera, Isidoro // Forum on Public Policy: A Journal of the Oxford Round Table;2011, Vol. 2011 Issue 3, Special section p1 

    A salient matter feeding many longstanding world conflicts along religious fault lines is the mistaken idea that what is right (or wrong) may be found in a code of values. Religious groups aspiring to promote their respective notions of what is right (or wrong) have historically made one of...

  • GREEN EYES INTO THE SOUL. Rossi, Carey // Joe Weider's Muscle & Fitness;Apr2004, Vol. 65 Issue 4, p244 

    Discusses the concept of envy and jealousy and their impact on a person's personality and disposition. Emotions that define envy and jealousy; Influence of social comparison on one's position in life; Difference between envy and jealousy.

  • Mindfields: What science can tell us about good and bad. Grayling, A. C. // New Scientist;5/3/2008, Vol. 198 Issue 2654, p50 

    The author reflects on the function of mirror neurons in the human brain. He denotes that the neurons activate sympathy with the experience of others such as smiling, weeping and yawning. He states that mirror neurons undermine the concept of moral relativism, the idea which claims that there...

  • Colors without circles? Kathrin Glüer // Erkenntnis;Mar2007, Vol. 66 Issue 1/2, p107 

    Abstract  Realists about color, be they dispositionalists or physicalists, agree on the truth of the following claim: (R)xis red iffxis disposed to look red under standard conditions. The disagreement is only about whether to identify the colors with the relevant dispositions, or with...

  • Religiosity, Ethical Ideology, and Intentions to Report a Peer's Wrongdoing. Barnett, Tim; Bass, Ken; Brown, Gene // Journal of Business Ethics;Nov96, Vol. 15 Issue 11, p1161 

    Peer reporting is a specific form of whistleblowing in which an individual discloses the wrongdoing of a peer. Previous studies have examined situational variables thought to influence a person's decision to report the wrongdoing of a peer. The present study looked at peer reporting from the...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics