Savoring time: desire, pleasure and wholehearted activity

Brewer, Talbot
June 2003
Ethical Theory & Moral Practice;Jun2003, Vol. 6 Issue 2, p143
Academic Journal
There is considerable appeal to the Aristotelian idea that taking pleasure in an activity is sometimes simply a matter of attending to it in such a way as to render it wholehearted. However, the proponents of this idea have not made adequately clear what kind of attention it is that can perform the surprising feat of transforming otherwise indifferent activities into pleasurable ones. I build upon Gilbert Ryle's suggestion that taking pleasure in an activity is tantamount to engaging in the activity while fervently desiring to do it and it alone. More specifically, I draw upon insights into the sort of evaluative attention involved in having a desire to generate corollary insights into the sort of attention that makes activity pleasurable. My aim is to offer a compelling account of a certain class of pleasures, and to shed light on their relation to reasons. I argue that prospective pleasures in this class are not always reasons for action, and that even when they are reasons they have this status only derivatively, as vivid apprehensions of an independent realm of values. This does not mean that such pleasures are never good. They are good provided that they track real values, for then they constitute a proper savoring of one's activities and/or circumstances, and provide a valuable respite from the distractions and unwarranted doubts that so often leave us at odds with ourselves and alienated from our own doings.


Related Articles

  • The reduction of sensory pleasure to desire. Heathwood, Chris // Philosophical Studies;Mar2007, Vol. 133 Issue 1, p23 

    One of the leading approaches to the nature of sensory pleasure reduces it to desire: roughly, a sensation qualifies as a sensation of pleasure just in case its subject wants to be feeling it. This approach is, in my view, correct, but it has never been formulated quite right; and it needs to...

  • Is wetenskap moontlik in die afwesigheid van gees? Roux, Braam // Tydskrif vir Geesteswetenskappe;Mar2012, Vol. 52 Issue 1, p19 

    This article is a response to Fanie de Beer's lament on the absence of spirit (soul) in scientific endeavours which raises questions about meaning and validity. To get clarity on these matters re-visiting the ideas of the Oxford philosopher, Gilbert Ryle (1900-1976), was deemed necessary. In his...

  • THE CONFLICTING ASPECTS OF HUGH McCANN'S THEORY OF ACTION. Čičić, Damir // Filozofia;2011, Vol. 66 Issue 9, p918 

    The paper focuses on two aspects of Hugh McCann's theory of action and shows that they stand in conflict. The first of them is McCann's defense of the claim that all overt actions are grounded in a special kinds of mental action -- volitions (from the Gilbert Ryle's famous 'dilemma' argument)....

  • Sense, Category, Questions: Reading Deleuze with Ryle. Kügler, Peter // Deleuze Studies;2011, Vol. 5 Issue 3, p324 

    Gilles Deleuze's notion of sense, as developed in Difference and Repetition and The Logic of Sense, is meant to be a fourth dimension of the proposition besides denotation, manifestation and signification. While Deleuze explains signification in inferentialist terms, he ascribes to sense some...

  • The Structure of Practical Expertise. Tsai, Cheng-hung // Philosophia;Jun2014, Vol. 42 Issue 2, p539 

    Anti-intellectualists in epistemology argue for the thesis that knowing-how is not a species of knowing-that, and most of them tend to avoid any use of the notion 'knowing-that' in their explanation of intelligent action on pain of inconsistency. Intellectualists tend to disprove...

  • HEDONISM. Lefka, Aikaterini // Continuum Encyclopedia of British Philosophy;2006, Vol. 2, p1422 

    An encyclopedia entry about hedonism is presented. Hedonism was derived from the Greek word "hedone" which means pleasure. Its central thesis states that the natural objective of human life is to gain pleasure and avoid pleasure. In British philosophy, hedonism is associated with utilitarianism....

  • Aristotle on Pleasure and the Worst Form of Akrasia. Henry, Devin // Ethical Theory & Moral Practice;Sep2002, Vol. 5 Issue 3, p255 

    The focus of this paper is Aristotle's solution to the problem inherited from Socrates: How could a man fail to restrain himself when he believes that what he desires is wrong? In NE 7 Aristotle attempts to reconcile the Socratic denial of akrasia with the commonly held opinion that people act...

  • category mistake Philosophy.  // Dictionary of Theories;2002, p79 

    Definition of the term "category mistake," is presented. The concept was developed by English philosopher Gilbert Ryle for cases where people talk of something which is appropriate only to something of a radically different kind. According to Ryle, the mind and body cannot be spoken of in...

  • RYLE, Gilbert (1900-76). Sprague, Elmer // Continuum Encyclopedia of British Philosophy;2006, Vol. 4, p2799 

    An encyclopedia entry for British philosopher Gilbert Ryle is presented. It offers information on his educational and career background. His contributions to philosophy are highlighted, including his efforts in instituting the degree of Bachelor of Philosophy at Oxford and arranging joint...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics