On criticism of the nature of objectivity in classical continuum physics

Murdoch, A.
May 2005
Continuum Mechanics & Thermodynamics;May2005, Vol. 17 Issue 2, p135
Academic Journal
Murdoch (J. Elasticity 60, 233-242, 2000) showed that restrictions imposed upon response functions by material frame-indifference are the consequences of five distinct aspects of observer agreement (that is, of ‘objectivity’) and involve only proper orthogonal tensors. Accordingly it is unnecessary to invoke the ‘principle of invariance under superposed rigid motions’ (in the sense of ‘one observer, two motions’), which imposes a restriction upon nature. Liu (Continuum Mech. Thermodyn. 16, 177-183, 2003, and Continuum Mech. Thermodyn. 17, 125-133, 2005) has challenged, misinterpreted and misrepresented the content of both Murdoch’s work and this work. Here all criticisms of Liu are answered, his ‘counter-examples’ are used to amplify the tenets of Murdoch’s work, and a key modelling issue in the controversy is indicated. Further, the response function restrictions for a given observer, derived on the basis of considering other observers, are shown to be independent of possible differences in the scales of mass, length, and time employed by other observers.


Related Articles

  • Stress solutions to the three-dimensional problem of elasticity. Borodachev, N. // International Applied Mechanics;Aug2006, Vol. 42 Issue 8, p849 

    New representations of the stress tensor in the linear theory of elasticity and thermoelasticity are proposed. These representations satisfy the equilibrium equations and the strain compatibility equation. The stress tensor is expressed in terms of a harmonic tensor or a harmonic vector. The...

  • Tachyon solution in a cubic Neveu-Schwarz string field theory. Arefeva, I.; Gorbachev, P.; Medvedev, P. // Theoretical & Mathematical Physics;Mar2009, Vol. 158 Issue 3, p320 

    We find a class of analytic solutions in a modified cubic theory of fermionic strings that includes the GSO(−) sector. This class contains a solution that involves a tachyon field from the GSO(−) sector and reproduces the correct value of the non-BPS D-brane tension.

  • From discrete particles to continuum fields in mixtures. Weinhart, T.; Luding, S.; Thornton, A. R. // AIP Conference Proceedings;Jun2013, Vol. 1542 Issue 1, p1202 

    We present a novel way to extract continuum fields from discrete particle systems that is applicable to flowing mixtures as well as boundaries and interfaces. The mass and momentum balance equations for mixed flows are expressed in terms of the partial densities, velocities, stresses and...

  • Shear Database for Prestressed Concrete Members. Nakamura, Eisuke; Avendaño, Alejandro R.; Bayrak, Oguzhan // ACI Structural Journal;Nov/Dec2013, Vol. 110 Issue 6, p909 

    The University of Texas Prestressed Concrete Shear Database (UTPCSDB) was developed and expanded to include 1696 tests reported in North America, Japan, and Europe from 1954 to 2010. The UTPCSDB was subsequently used to examine the accuracy and conservativeness of shear design procedures based...

  • Eshelby's formula for an ellipsoidal elastic inclusion in anisotropic poroelasticity and thermoelasticity. Levin, Valery M.; Alvarez-Tostado, Juan M. // International Journal of Fracture;Mar2003, Vol. 119 Issue 4, pL79 

    Eshelby's formula that relates the strain inside of an ellipsoidal inclusion in an unbounded elastic medium to the uniform strain imposed at infinity is generalized to the cases of poroelastic and thermoelastic materials. This result holds for an arbitrary anisotropy of the inclusion and of the...

  • The effect of strain rate on the character of σ–ℇ diagrams. Grinyaev, Yu. V.; Chertova, N. V.; Chertov, M. A. // Journal of Applied Mechanics & Technical Physics;Jul/Aug2002, Vol. 43 Issue 4, p612 

    An equation governing the evolution of elastic strains (stresses) for a given strain rate is obtained using the field theory of defects under the assumption of uniform defect distribution. Strain diagrams are constructed by numerical solution of this equation and qualitative analysis of the...

  • Strong surface effect on direct bulk flexoelectric response in solids. Yurkov, A. S.; Tagantsev, A. K. // Applied Physics Letters;1/11/2016, Vol. 108 Issue 2, p1 

    In the framework of a continuum theory, it is shown that the direct bulk flexoelectric response of a finite sample essentially depends on the surface polarization energy, even in the thermodynamic limit where the body size tends to infinity. It is found that a modification of the surface energy...

  • Research on the Impact between Balls and Re-circulating Mechanism of Ball Screws. Zuo-Ying ZHANG; Wan-Li ZHANG; Chi XU // Applied Mechanics & Materials;2014, Issue 551, p370 

    A Mechanical model of impact and contact between the ball and re-circulating mechanism in ball screw was brought forward according to the Hertz contact model and classical impact theory, along with the joint relationship of re-circulating mechanism and nut taken into account. Then the formula of...

  • Surface stress-driven instabilities of a free film. Kornev, Konstantin G.; Srolovitz, David J. // Applied Physics Letters;9/27/2004, Vol. 85 Issue 13, p2487 

    We examine the effect of surface stress on the stability of free unconstrained solid films. We first determine the general thermodynamic criteria for film stability. Then, we show that two different morphological instabilities are possible, depending on the sign of the surface stress. The first...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics