Reasons and Value - in Defence of the Buck-Passing Account

Suikkanen, Jussi
December 2004
Ethical Theory & Moral Practice;Dec2004, Vol. 7 Issue 5, p513
Academic Journal
In this article, I will defend the so-called �buck-passing� theory of value. According to this theory, claims about the value of an object refer to the reason-providing properties of the object. The concept of value can thus be analyzed in terms of reasons and the properties of objects that provide them for us. Reasons in this context are considerations that count in favour of certain attitudes. There are four other possibilities of how the connection between reasons and value might be formulated. For example, we can claim that value is a property that provides us with reasons to choose an option that has this property. I argue that none of these four other options can ultimately be defended, and therefore the buck-passing account is the one we ought to accept as the correct one. The case for the buck-passing account becomes even stronger, when we examine the weak points of the most pressing criticism against this account thus far.


Related Articles

  • What Are Possible Worlds? NOLT, JOHN E. // Mind;Oct1986, Vol. 95 Issue 380, p432 

    The article discusses the possible worlds and their possibility alongwith the literal meaning of such worlds. The author does not believe in the existence of the possible worlds, however, argues that they are possible and understanding their possibility is a way of understanding what they are....

  • Constructive Criticism. Johnson, Doug // Library Media Connection;Mar/Apr2009, Vol. 27 Issue 5, p98 

    The author offers ideas for dealing with criticism. He explains the importance of being able to deal effectively with criticism if one is to be a change agent. He shares types of criticism directed toward him regularly: venting, criticisms about a policy or product, and constructive criticism....

  • Set Theory: Key to the Understanding, of Kenneth Burke's Use of the Term "Identification" Rosenfeld, Lawrence B. // Western Speech;Summer1969, Vol. 33 Issue 3, p175 

    Analyzes author Kenneth Burke's use of the term “identification” from the perspective of set theory. Burke's reference to identification in Part Two of his book “A Rhetoric of Motives”; Features that make up Burke's definition of identification; Explanation of the term...

  • De la teoría de conjuntos, el género en disputa y la existencia de la pedagogía. Prieto, Cristián Cerón // Revista Latinoamericana de Etnomatemática;feb-abr2014, Vol. 7 Issue 1, p185 

    Through a literary examination, this study proposes a gender criticism on some pedagogical and discourse aspects of Set Theory – theory that lays the foundation of “mathematics” with widely accepted principles – that are found incorporated secretly in the axiomatic...

  • Responding unkind. Bowman, James // New Criterion;Apr2005, Vol. 23 Issue 8, p61 

    This article focuses on responding to criticism. The author says that sometimes he can understand why, given the choice between being summarily and angrily labeled a fool, a bomb-thrower, or a maniac and simply being ignored, some people would choose the former over the latter. It is a way of...

  • Mapping Moral Motivation. Garrard, Eve; McNaughton, David // Ethical Theory & Moral Practice;Mar1998, Vol. 1 Issue 1, p45 

    In this paper we defend a version of moral internalism and a cognitivist account of motivation against recent criticisms. The internalist thesis we espouse claims that, if an agent believes she has reason to A, then she is motivated to A. Discussion of counter-examples has been clouded by the...

  • Decision Making by Hybrid Probabilistic - Possibilistic Utility Theory. Pap, Endre // Panoeconomicus;Dec2009, Vol. 56 Issue 4, p421 

    It is presented an approach to decision theory based upon nonprobabilistic uncertainty. There is an axiomatization of the hybrid probabilisticpossibilistic mixtures based on a pair of triangular conorm and triangular norm satisfying restricted distributivity law, and the corresponding...

  • On the lemniscate components containing no critical points of a polynomial except for its zeros. Dubinin, V. // Journal of Mathematical Sciences;Oct2011, Vol. 178 Issue 2, p158 

    Let P be a complex polynomial of degree n and let E be a connected component of the set { z : | P( z)| = 1} containing no critical points of P different from its zeros. We prove the inequality |( z - a) P'( z)/ P( z)| = n for all z ? E \ { a}, where a is the zero of the polynomial P lying in...

  • Homology computation for a class of contact structures on $$T^3$$. Maalaoui, Ali; Martino, Vittorio // Calculus of Variations & Partial Differential Equations;Jul2014, Vol. 50 Issue 3/4, p599 

    We consider a family of tight contact forms on the three-dimensional torus and we compute the relative Contact Homology by using the variational theory of critical points at infinity. We will also show local stability.


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics