Failures of the Burnett and super-Burnett equations in steady state processes

Struchtrup, H.
February 2005
Continuum Mechanics & Thermodynamics;Feb2005, Vol. 17 Issue 1, p43
Academic Journal
Linearized Burnett and super-Burnett equations are considered for steady state Couette flow. It is shown that the linear super-Burnett equations lead to periodic velocity and temperature curves, i.e. unphysical solutions. The problem is discussed as well for the so-called augmented Burnett equations by Zhong et al. (AIAA Journal31, 1036-1043 (1993)), and for the recently introduced regularized 13 moment equations (R13) of Struchtrup and Torrilhon (Phys. Fluids15(9), 2668-2680 (2003) ). It is shown that both theories exhibit proper Knudsen boundary layers for velocity and temperature. However, the heat flux parallel to the wall has different signs for the Burnett and the R13 equations, and a comparison with DSMC results shows that only the R13 equations predict the proper sign.


Related Articles

  • On the uniqueness of the solution of the flow problem with a given vortex. Weigant, W.; Papin, A. // Mathematical Notes;Nov2014, Vol. 96 Issue 5/6, p871 

    For the two-dimensional nonstationary Euler equations of an ideal incompressible fluid, the flow problem with a given vortex is considered. The uniqueness of the solution is proved.

  • Convection due to the selective absorption of radiation in a porous medium. Hill, A. A. // Continuum Mechanics & Thermodynamics;Jun2003, Vol. 15 Issue 3, p275 

    A model for convection due to the selective absorption of radiation in a fluid saturated porous medium is investigated. The model is based on a similar one introduced for a viscous fluid by Krishnamurti [8]. Employing this adapted model we show the growth rate for the linearised system is real....

  • Burgers equation with a passive scalar: Dissipation anomaly and Colombeau calculus. Ohkitani, Koji; Dowker, Mark // Journal of Mathematical Physics;Mar2010, Vol. 51 Issue 3, p033101 

    A connection between dissipation anomaly in fluid dynamics and Colombeau’s theory of products of distributions is exemplified by considering Burgers equation with a passive scalar. Besides the well-known viscosity-independent dissipation of energy in the steadily propagating shock wave...

  • Planar Pressure Field Deterinination in the Initial Merging Zone of an Annular Swirling Jet Based on Stereo-PIV Measurements. Vanierschot, Maarten; van den Bulck, Eric // Sensors (14248220);2008, Vol. 8 Issue 12, p7596 

    In this paper the static pressure field of an annular swirling jet is measured indirectly using stereo-PIV measurements. The pressure field is obtained from numerically solving the Poisson equation, taken into account the axisymmetry of the flow. At the boundaries no assumptions are made and the...

  • Grad’s equations and hydrodynamics for weakly inelastic granular flows. Bisi, M.; Spiga, G.; Toscani, G. // Physics of Fluids;Dec2004, Vol. 16 Issue 12, p4235 

    We introduce and discuss Grad’s moment equations for dilute granular systems of hard spheres with dissipative collisions and variable coefficient of restitution, under the assumption of weak inelasticity. An important by-product is that in this way we obtain the hydrodynamic description...

  • The Taylor-Culick profile with arbitrary headwall injection. Majdalani, Joseph; Saad, Tony // Physics of Fluids;Sep2007, Vol. 19 Issue 9, p093601 

    Taylor’s incompressible and rotational profile is extended to a porous cylinder with arbitrary headwall injection. This profile, often referred to as Culick’s mean flow, is now generalized to permit the imposition of reactive headwall conditions. Starting with Euler’s steady...

  • Calculation of Entrainment in Density Jumps. Regev, A.; Hassid, S.; Poreh, M. // Environmental Fluid Mechanics;Oct2006, Vol. 6 Issue 5, p407 

    The density jump in a two-layer channel flow of miscible fluids, in which one of the layers is infinitely deep and at rest, is analyzed using the momentum flux and mass flux conservation equations. The analysis yields simple equations relating the heights upstream and downstream of the jump with...

  • On the Stationary Invariant Configurations of the Ideal Plasma. Shapovalov, V. N.; Shapovalova, O. V. // Russian Physics Journal;Feb2003, Vol. 46 Issue 2, p186 

    A system of magnetohydrodynamics equations for the compressible plasma, invariant for the one-parameter group of motions in the space E3 is integrated.

  • Waves in Guinness. Robinson, Marguerite; Fowler, A. C.; Alexander, A. J.; O'Brien, S. B. G. // Physics of Fluids;Jun2008, Vol. 20 Issue 6, p067101 

    We describe a simple model of a bubbly two-phase flow which is able to explain why waves propagate downward when a pint of Guinness is poured, and also how the waves are generated. Our theory involves a physically based regularization of the basic equations of the two-phase flow, using...


Read the Article


Sign out of this library

Other Topics