Understanding the Moral Phenomenology of the Third Reich

Scarre, Geoffrey
December 1998
Ethical Theory & Moral Practice;Dec1998, Vol. 1 Issue 4, p423
Academic Journal
This paper discusses the issue of German moral responsibility for the Holocaust in the light of the thesis of Daniel Goldhagen and others that inherited negative stereotypes of Jews and Jewishness were prime causal factors contributing to the genocide. It is argued that in so far as the Germans of the Third Reich were dupes of an ‘hallucinatory ideology,‘ they strikingly exemplify the ‘paradox of moral luck‘ outlined by Thomas Nagel, that people are not morally responsible for what they are and are not responsible for. The implications of this paradox for the appraisal of German guilt are explored in relation to the views of a number of recent writers on the Holocaust.


Related Articles

  • Bearing Witness: Teaching the Holocaust from a Victim-Centered Perspective. Blutinger, Jeffrey C. // History Teacher;May2009, Vol. 42 Issue 3, p269 

    The article focuses on methods of teaching the Holocaust from a victim-centered perspective and from a perpetrator-based perspective. It relates that both methods are important to give students a fuller understanding of the issues that surround the event. It notes that teaching the subject from...

  • A Plate of Controversy. Mnookin, Seth // Newsweek;3/10/2003, Vol. 141 Issue 10, p10 

    Reports on a campaign, The Holocaust on Your Plate, by People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals (PETA), a group that uses outrageous advertising to get attention. Reference to a book, 'Eternal Treblinka,' that draws parallels between human genocides and the treatment of animals; Reaction of...

  • Recently Published Works in Holocaust and Genocide Studies.  // Holocaust & Genocide Studies;Winter2009, Vol. 23 Issue 3, p511 

    A list of recently published books about genocide and holocaust studies as of December 2009 is presented, including "From Auschwitz to Ambleside," edited by Trevor Avery, "Cristina's History," by Mikael Levin and Jean-Franç Chevrier and "Po Jedwahnem," by Zofia Lipecka and Hann...

  • Act and Idea in the Nazi Genocide: Reflections on the Polish Edition. Lang, Berel // Judaism;Summer/Fall2004, Vol. 53 Issue 3/4, p253 

    Introduces the Polish edition of the book "Act and Idea in the Nazi Genocide." Estimates on population of Poland during Germany's invasion on September 1, 1939; Background on the Nazi genocide that began in 1941; Analysis of the concept and practice of genocide; Details of the Kielce pogrom in...

  • Fear and Consequences: Healing from Jewish Historical Trauma. Somerson, Wendy Elisheva // Tikkun;Jan/Feb2011, Vol. 26 Issue 1, p68 

    In this article the author discusses how Jews can come out from their historical trauma. It suggests that one should move through 1939 holocaust with other Jews by finding strength to fight the Israeli occupation of Palestine. It mentions that by doing so, Jews can create a space to love...

  • THE FUTURE OF HOLOCAUST STUDIES. Houwink ten Cate, Johannes // Jewish Political Studies Review;Spring2010, Vol. 22 Issue 1/2, p33 

    Holocaust awareness has become a worldwide phenomenon, and an international free republic of Holocaust researchers has emerged. Among long-term trends in the field of Holocaust studies are the universalization of victimhood and the extension of the circle of perpetrators. Present trends include...

  • Op-Ed: What's wrong with March of the Living. Lang, Jessica // Jewish Telegraphic Agency: 1922 to present;4/14/2015, p1 

    NEW YORK (JTA) - The evening before we visited Auschwitz, over pizza with a group of young people in Oswiecim, the town on whose outskirts lies that infamous symbol, one of my students approached me with tears in her eyes.

  • Genocide. Arthur, Mikaila Mariel Lemonik // Genocide -- Research Starters Sociology;4/1/2018, p1 

    This article is an overview of the history and the concept of genocide. It reviews several episodes of genocide in modern world history, including the Holocaust as well as genocides in Bosnia, Rwanda, Armenia, and Darfur. The article then considers several controversies in Holocaust and Genocide...

  • East West Street: On the Origins of “Genocide” and “Crimes Against Humanity”. Heller, Margaret // Library Journal;3/1/2016, Vol. 141 Issue 4, p110 

    No abstract available.


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics