Reasoning About Competitive Reactions: Evidence from Executives

Montgomery, David B.; Moore, Marian Chapman; Urbany, Joel E.
January 2005
Marketing Science;Winter2005, Vol. 24 Issue 1, p138
Academic Journal
Much of the empirical research on competitive reactions describes how or why rivals react to a firm's past actions, but stops short of examining whether managers attempt to predict such reactions, which we call strategic competitive reasoning. In three exploratory studies, we find evidence of managers' thinking about competitors' past and future behavior, but little incidence of strategic competitive reasoning. Competitive intelligence experts and other experienced managers' assessment of the results suggests that the relatively low incidence of strategic competitor reasoning is due to perceptions of low returns from anticipating competitor reactions more than to the high cost of doing so. Both the difficulty of obtaining competitive information and the uncertainty associated with predicting competitor behavior contribute to these perceptions. The paper suggests both a need for research on competitive behavior and an opportunity to influence and improve managerial judgment and decision making.


Related Articles

  • It just might work. Rigby, Rhymer // Management Today;May2000, p22 

    Features Jack Welch's three-day `Work-Out' sessions, which focused on how, and how fast, executives can decide on whether or not to give their subordinates' ideas the green light.

  • HOW TO INNOVATE WHEN YOU'RE NOT THE BIG BOSS. Beeson, John // Finweek;3/1/2012, p45 

    The article focuses on how business executives can innovate and make change within the company on their own simple ways through decision making or revision of management process.

  • Make a decision! It's a matter of survival. Lim, Gary // Business Journal (Central New York);03/26/99, Vol. 13 Issue 12, p24 

    Stresses the importance of decision-making to business viability. Illustration of the detrimental effects of indecision; Account on the author's experiences with managers having decision-making problems; Impact of poor management decision-making on small businesses.

  • Judgment: The result of experience. Fagiano, David // Management Review;Jan97, Vol. 86 Issue 1, p5 

    Opinion. Presents the author's view on the intellectual understanding of a business that is simply no substitute for living a business. How the sum of one's experiences in a company becomes the instinct needed for tough judgments; Need for an organization's leader to connect with his...

  • Does Anyone Listen to the Boss? Mikalachki, Alexander // Business Horizons;Jan/Feb83, Vol. 26 Issue 1, p18 

    What should a top executive do when his managers don't see the problems he sees? In such a case, involving employee morale, a consultant and a president worked together to convince managers that a problem did exist. Here are suggestions on how to help your managers recognize and deal with...

  • BUDGET DECISION MAKING AT THE GRASS-ROOT'S LEVEL. Giannatasio, Nicholas A. // Journal of Public Budgeting, Accounting & Financial Management;Spring2001, Vol. 13 Issue 1, p48 

    Focuses on a study which examined the utility and applicability of relevant decision models presented in the literature to explore which models are valuable to managers. Research problem; Paradigms of decision making; Methodology; Results; Conclusion.

  • Whose decision is it, anyway? Stead, Jerre L. // Management Review;Jan99, Vol. 88 Issue 1, p13 

    Presents information on effective decision making in business management. Significance of executive's decision; Significance of policy manuals of companies; Components of decision making support framework.

  • Location Decisions: the Role of Uncertainty About Consumer Tastes. Casado-Izaga, F. Javier // Journal of Economics;2000, Vol. 71 Issue 1, p31 

    Analyzes to what extent firms make decisions about location based on uncertainty about consumer tastes. Effect of uncertainty about consumer tastes on the degree of product differentiation and price competition; Specific class of transportation costs or sellers' competition; Difference between...

  • Data: Efficiency, Storage, Security, Responsibility.  // International Journal of Micrographics & Optical Technology;2006, Vol. 24 Issue 2/3, p5 

    The article discusses the findings of a research which indicated that British managers are being given inadequate and out of date information, leading to poor decisions which affect competitiveness and profitability. Most of the managers blamed information bottleneck on limited technical...


Read the Article


Sign out of this library

Other Topics