The 30 May 1998 Spencer, South Dakota, Storm. Part II: Comparison of Observed Damage and Radar-Derived Winds in the Tornadoes

Wurman, Joshua; Alexander, Curtis R.
January 2005
Monthly Weather Review;Jan2005, Vol. 133 Issue 1, p97
Academic Journal
A violent supercell tornado passed through the town of Spencer, South Dakota, on the evening of 30 May 1998 producing large gradients in damage severity. The tornado was rated at F4 intensity by damage survey teams. A Doppler On Wheels (DOW) mobile radar followed this tornado and observed the tornado at ranges between 1.7 and 8.0 km during various stages of the tornado's life. The DOW was deployed less than 4.0 km from the town of Spencer between 0134 and 0145 UTC, and during this time period, the tornado passed through Spencer, and peak Doppler velocity measurements exceeded 100 m s-1. Data gathered from the DOW during this time period contained high spatial resolution sample volumes of approximately 34 m × 34 m × 37 m along with frequent volume updates every 45–50 s. The high-resolution Doppler velocity data gathered from low-level elevation scans, when sample volumes are between 20 and 40 m AGL, are compared to extensive ground and aerial damage surveys performed by the National Weather Service (NWS) and the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST). Idealized radial profiles of tangential velocity are computed by fitting a model of an axisymmetric translating vortex to the Doppler radar observations, which compensates for velocity components perpendicular to the radar beam as well as the translational motion of the tornado vortex. Both the original single-Doppler velocity data and the interpolated velocity fields are compared with damage survey Fujita scale (F-scale) estimates throughout the town of Spencer. This comparison on a structure-by-structure basis revealed that radar-based estimates of the F-scale intensity usually exceeded the damage-survey-based F-scale both inside and outside the town of Spencer. In the town of Spencer, the radar-based wind field revealed two distinct velocity time series inside and outside the passage of the core-flow region. The center of the core-flow region tracked about 50 m farther north than the damage survey indicated because of the asymmetry induced by the 15 m s-1 translational motion of the tornado. The radar consistently measured the strongest winds in the lowest 200 m AGL with the most extreme Doppler velocities residing within 50 m AGL. Alternate measures of tornado wind field intensity that incorporated the effects of the duration of the extreme winds and debris were explored. It is suggested that damage may not be a simple function of peak wind gust and structural integrity, but that the duration of intense winds, directional changes, accelerations, and upwind debris loading may be critical factors.


Related Articles

  • Close-Range Observations of Tornadoes in Supercells Made with a Dual-Polarization, X-Band, Mobile Doppler Radar. Bluestein, Howard B.; French, Michael M.; Tanamachi, Robin L.; Frasier, Stephen; Hardwick, Kery; Junyent, Francesc; Pazmany, Andrew L. // Monthly Weather Review;Apr2007, Vol. 135 Issue 4, p1522 

    A mobile, dual-polarization, X-band, Doppler radar scanned tornadoes at close range in supercells on 12 and 29 May 2004 in Kansas and Oklahoma, respectively. In the former tornadoes, a visible circular debris ring detected as circular regions of low values of differential reflectivity and the...

  • Application of a Lightning Data Assimilation Technique in the WRF-ARW Model at Cloud-Resolving Scales for the Tornado Outbreak of 24 May 2011. Fierro, Alexandre O.; Mansell, Edward R.; Ziegler, Conrad L.; MacGorman, Donald R. // Monthly Weather Review;Aug2012, Vol. 140 Issue 8, p2609 

    This study presents the assimilation of total lightning data to help initiate convection at cloud-resolving scales within a numerical weather prediction model. The test case is the 24 May 2011 Oklahoma tornado outbreak, which was characterized by an exceptional synoptic/mesoscale setup for the...

  • Regional Comparison of GOES Cloud-Top Properties and Radar Characteristics in Advance of First-Flash Lightning Initiation. Mecikalski, John R.; Li, Xuanli; Carey, Lawrence D.; McCaul, Eugene W.; Coleman, Timothy A. // Monthly Weather Review;Jan2013, Vol. 141 Issue 1, p55 

    Lightning initiation (LI) events over Florida and Oklahoma are examined and statistically compared to understand the behavior of observed radar and infrared satellite interest fields (IFs) in the 75-min time frame surrounding LI. Lightning initiation is defined as the time of the first...

  • INSIDE A TORNADO ON THE ROAD, IN THE LAB.  // National Geographic;Apr2004, Vol. 205 Issue 4, p29 

    Like a bull, a tornado violently resists examination. It may come on suddenly from an unexpected place and last only a few minutes. Data from radar, weather balloons, and turtle probes can fill only part of the grid of information needed to comprehend tornado dynamics. So tornadoes remain the...

  • Dual-Doppler Analysis of Winds and Vorticity Budget Terms near a Tornado. Wurman, Joshua; Richardson, Yvette; Alexander, Curtis; Weygandt, Stephen; Zhang, Peng Fei // Monthly Weather Review;Jun2007, Vol. 135 Issue 6, p2392 

    Three-dimensional dual-Doppler observations with unprecedented finescale spatial and temporal resolution are used to characterize the vector wind field and vorticity generation terms in and near a weak, short-lived tornado. The beam widths of the two Doppler on Wheels (DOW) mobile radars, at the...

  • High Velocity. Rossman, Megan // Oklahoma Today;May/Jun2005, Vol. 55 Issue 3, p18 

    The article presents information about the documentary "Forces of Nature" showing at the OmniDome Theater in Oklahoma City. Viewers can ride alongside storm chasers as they use Doppler radar to pinpoint a massive twister. The film also includes footage of volcanos and earthquakes plus a cameo...

  • Insurers tally claims after Atlanta twister. Hofmann, Mark A. // Business Insurance;3/24/2008, Vol. 42 Issue 12, p1 

    The article reports on the claims of state officials in Georgia that storms that included a rare tornado that struck downtown Atlanta earlier in March 2008 could result in as much as $250 million in insured damage across the state. State-owned properties sustained much of the damage in Atlanta....

  • Twister of Fate.  // People;5/19/2003, Vol. 59 Issue 19, p88 

    The clocked stopped at 9:08 on Sunday evening May 4, 2003. That's when the tornado hit Martha Wampler's house in McCrory, Arkansas. Wampler was huddled with her granddaughter Anna, 3, in the hall as winds that reached 160 mph tore at the roof. Within seconds the ceilings began to collapse all...

  • The 19 April 1996 Illinois Tornado Outbreak. Part I: Cell Evolution and Supercell Isolation. Lee, Bruce D.; Jewett, Brian F.; Wilhelmson, Robert B. // Weather & Forecasting;Aug2006, Vol. 21 Issue 4, p433 

    In this study of the 19 April 1996 Illinois tornado outbreak, 109 cells were tracked using radar data to understand the transition of the cell configuration from a considerable number of initial cells to a small subset of supercells after several hours of evolution. Of these 109 cells, 85...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics