A Comparison of Continuous Renal Replacement Therapy to Intermittent Dialysis in the Management of Renal Insufficiency in the Acutely III Surgical Patient

Waldrop, Jimmy; Ciraulo, David L.; Milner, Timothy P.; Gregori, Douglas; Kendrick, Aaron S.; Richart, Charles M.; Maxwell, Robert A.; Barker, Donald E.
January 2005
American Surgeon;Jan2005, Vol. 71 Issue 1, p36
Academic Journal
Acute renal failure (ARF) occurs in 10 per cent to 23 per cent of intensive care unit patients with mortality ranging from 50 per cent to 90 per cent. ARF is characterized by an acute decline in renal function as measured by urine output (UOP), serum creatinine, and blood urea nitrogen (BUN). Causes may be prerenal, intrarenal, or postrenal. Treatment consists of renal replacement therapy (RRT), either intermittent (ID) or continuous (CRRT). Indications for initiation of dialysis include oliguria, acidemia, azotemia, hyperkalemia, uremic complications, or significant edema. Overall, the literature comparing CRRT to ID is poor. No studies of only surgical/trauma patients have been published. We hypothesize that renal function and hemodynamic stability in trauma/ surgical critical care patients are better preserved by CRRT than by ID. We performed a retrospective review of trauma/surgical critical care patients requiring renal supportive therapy. Thirty patients received CRRT and 27 patients received ID. The study was controlled for severity of illness and demographics. Outcomes assessed were survival, renal function, acid-base balance, hemodynamic stability, and oxygenation/ventilation parameters. Populations were similar across demographics and severity of illness. Renal function, measured by creatinine clearance, was statistically greater with CRRT (P = 0.035). There was better control of azotemia with CRRT: BUN was lower (P = 0.000) and creatinine was lower (P = 0.000). Mean arterial blood pressure was greater (P = 0.021) with CRRT. No difference in oxygenation/ventilation parameters or pH was found between groups. CRRT results in an enhancement of renal function with improved creatinine clearance at the time of dialysis discontinuation. CRRT provides better control of azotemia while preserving hemodynamic stability in patients undergoing renal replacement therapy. Prospective randomized controlled studies and larger sample sizes are needed to further evaluate...


Related Articles

  • Renal replacement therapy among disadvantaged populations in Mexico: A report from the Jalisco Dialysis and Transplant Registry (REDTJAL). Garcia-Garcia, Guillermo; Monteon-Ramos, J. Francisco; Garcia-Bejarano, Hector; Gomez-Navarro, Benjamin; Reyes, Imelda Hernandez; Lomeli, Ana Maria; Palomeque, Miguel; Cortes-Sanabria, Laura; Breien-Alcaraz, Hugo; Ruiz-Morales, Norma M. // Kidney International Supplement;Aug2005, Issue 97, pS58 

    Renal replacement therapy among disadvantaged populations in Mexico: A report from the Jalisco Dialysis and Transplant Registry (REDTJAL). Background. End-stage renal disease represents a serious public health problem in Jalisco, Mexico. It is reported among the 10 leading causes of death, with...

  • Atherosclerosis in patients undergoing maintenance hemodialysis. Bagdade, John D. // Kidney International;Feb1975, Vol. 7 Issue 2, pS-370 

    The article discusses the acceleration of atherogenesis, which involves the coronary, cerebral, and peripheral circulation, experienced by patients who are undergoing chronic dialysis treatment for renal failure. The atherosclerotic lesions appear to come from the proliferation of smooth muscles...

  • Solute transport in continuous hemodialysis: A new treatment for acute renal failure. Sigler, Miles H.; Teehan, Brendan P.; Van Valkenburgh, Denise // Kidney International;Oct1987, Vol. 32 Issue 4, p562 

    A pumpless dialysis technique which combines continuous convection and diffusion was studied in 15 critically ill acute renal failure patients. Fluid identical in composition and purity to that used in peritoneal dialysis was continuously circulated (single-pass) at 16.6 cc/min through the...

  • Defining and classifying acute renal failure: from advocacy to consensus and validation of the RIFLE criteria. Bellomo, Rinaldo; Kellum, John A.; Ronco, Claudio // Intensive Care Medicine;Mar2007, Vol. 33 Issue 3, p409 

    Until recently, more than 30 different definitions of acute renal failure (ARF) had been used in the literature. This lack of a common reference point created confusion and made comparisons difficult. It also led to strong advocacy of a consensus definition. In response to the need for a common...

  • Abstracts.  // Kidney International;Apr1977, Vol. 11 Issue 4, p284 

    Discusses abstracts of papers presented before the South African Renal Society in Bloemfontein in October 1976. "Composition of hemodialysate," by N.D. Burman; "Acute renal failure during magnesium-potassium depletion cancer therapy," by N.D. Burman; "Maintenance dialysis and renal...

  • The timing of dialysis initiation affects the incidence of renal replacement therapy. Couchoud, Cȳcile; Guihenneuc, Chantal; Bayer, Florian; Stengel, Bȳnédicte // Nephrology Dialysis Transplantation;May2010, Vol. 25 Issue 5, p1576 

    Background. Variations in the timing of dialysis initiation may explain some geographical variations in renal replacement therapy (RRT) incidence, but this effect has never been quantified.

  • Kidney Failure. Stevens, Lise M.; Lynm, Cassio; Glass, Richard M. // JAMA: Journal of the American Medical Association;12/12/2001, Vol. 286 Issue 22, p2898 

    Provides information on kidney failure. Types, specifically acute kidney failure, chronic kidney failure, and end-stage kidney disease; Treatments of dialysis and transplantation; Symptoms; Prevention strategies.

  • Anti-GBM antibody disease sans crescents with thrombotic microangiopathy. Gowrishankar, Swarnalata; Patro, Anil; Maitra, Sanjay // NDT Plus;Aug2009, Vol. 2 Issue 4, p282 

    We report a case of a 38-year-old male with acute renal failure, elevated anti-glomerular basement membrane (anti-GBM) antibody titres, bilateral nodular lung opacities and hypertension. In the renal biopsy examination, whereas direct immunofluorescence revealed significant peripheral linear...

  • An overview of chronic kidney disease in older people. Lewis, Robert // Nursing Older People;Dec2013, Vol. 25 Issue 10, p31 

    There is a lack of consensus about how early chronic kidney disease (CKD) should be diagnosed and managed in older people. Some believe that reduced renal function in older age is usually benign and that identifying it as a condition requiring medical intervention is inappropriate, whereas...

  • Acute Kidney Injury: Controversies Revisited. Yong, Kenneth; Dogra, Gursharan; Boudville, Neil; Pinder, Mary; Wai Lim // International Journal of Nephrology;2011, p1 

    This paper addresses the epidemiology of AKI specifically in relation to recent changes in AKI classification and revisits the controversies regarding the timing of initiation of dialysis and the use of peritoneal dialysis as a renal replacement therapy for AKI. In summary, the new RIFLE/AKIN...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics