Can Competition Ever be Fair? Challenging the Standard Prejudice

Arnsperger, Christian; Villé, Philippe
September 2004
Ethical Theory & Moral Practice;Sep2004, Vol. 7 Issue 4, p433
Academic Journal
In this paper, we challenge the usual argument which says that competition is a fair mechanism because it ranks individuals according to their relative preferences between effort and leisure. This argument, we claim, is very insufficient as a justification of fairness in competition, and we show that it does not stand up to scrutiny once various dynamic aspects of competition are taken into account. Once the sequential unfolding of competition is taken into account, competition turns out to be unfaireven ifthe usual fairness argument is upheld. We distinguish between two notions of fairness, which we call U-fairness, where ‘U’ stands for the ‘usual’ fairness notion, and S-fairness, where ‘S’ stands for the ‘sequential’ aspect of competition. The sequential unfairness of competition, we argue, comprises two usually neglected aspects connected with losses of freedom: first of all, there is an ‘eclipse’ of preferences in the sense that even perfectly calculating competitors do not carry out a trade-off between effort and ranking; and second, competitive dynamics leads to single-mindedness because the constraints on the competitors’ choicesalwaysoperate in the sense ofincreasedcompetitiveness and, therefore, in the direction of anincreasedeffort requirements. We argue (1) that competition is S-unfair even if it is U-fair, (2) that as S-unfairness increases, the ethical relevance of U-fairness itself vanishes, so that (3) by focusing as they usually do on U-fairness alone, economists neglect a deeper aspect of unfairness.


Related Articles

  • POVIJESNI PRIKAZ I PRAVNI KARAKTER NORMATIVNIH AKATA REPUBLIKE SRPSKE KRAJINE. Brekalo, Miljenko // Zbornik Pravnog Fakulteta Sveucilista u Rijeci;2012, Vol. 33 Issue 2, p551 

    No abstract available.

  • A Critical Perspective of Integrative Social Contracts Theory: Recurring Criticisms and Next Generation Research Topics. Dunfee, Thomas // Journal of Business Ethics;Oct2006, Vol. 68 Issue 3, p303 

    During the past ten years Integrative Social Contracts Theory (ISCT) has become part of the repertoire of specialized decision-oriented theories in the business ethics literature. The intention here is to provide a brief overview of the structure and strengths of ISCT; (2) identify recurring...

  • UNDERSTANDING THE SEPARATION THESIS: PRECISION AFTER THE DECIMAL POINT? Wempe, Ben // Business Ethics Quarterly;Oct2008, Vol. 18 Issue 4, p549 

    Sandberg documents with admirable precision nine rather diverging rendering of Freeman's call for the rejection of the separation thesis (ST). A more careful consideration of the proprietary of importing phrases such as "the rejection of ST" from more established academic disciplines so as to...

  • Ekonomia narodowa a etyka w ujÄ™ciu StanisÅ‚awa GÅ‚Ä…biÅ„skiego. Szymański, Zdzisław // Annales. Etyka w Zyciu Gospodarczym;2014, Vol. 17 Issue 1, p23 

    Stanisław Głąbiński (1862-1941), professor of Lviv University and the author of the two-volume 'National Economics ('Ekonomika narodowa'), was one of the main representatives of the historical-national approach in Polish economics. The study of national economics which he created...

  • BUSINESS ETHICS: A JAPANESE VIEW. Taka, Iwao // Business Ethics Quarterly;Jan1994, Vol. 4 Issue 1, p53 

    Although "fairness" and "social responsibilities" form part of the business ethics agenda of Japanese corporations, the meaning of these terms must be understood in the context of the distinctive Japanese approach to ethics. In Japan, ethics is inextricably bound up with religious dimension (two...

  • QUANTITATIVE AND QUALITATIVE RESULTS OF PRIVATIZATION IN LATVIA. Ozols, Edgars; Bisenieks, Janis // Bridges / Tiltai;2011, Vol. 54 Issue 1, p147 

    In this article is assessed the conception's course of development of normative and legal basis of privatization process, described the privatization process in circumstances of decentralization and centralization after the establishment of Privatization Agency, analyzed the number of privatized...

  • Toward a Theory of Stakeholder Salience in Family Firms. Mitchell, Ronald K.; Agle, Bradley R.; Chrisman, James J.; Spence, Laura J. // Business Ethics Quarterly;Apr2011, Vol. 21 Issue 2, p235 

    The notion of stakeholder salience based on attributes (e.g., power, legitimacy, urgency) is applied in the family business setting. We argue that where principal institutions intersect (i.e., family and business); managerial perceptions of stakeholder salience will be different and more complex...

  • A Comment on 'A Multidimensional Scale for Measuring Business Ethics: A Purification and Refinement'. Reidenbach, R. Eric; Robin, Donald P. // Journal of Business Ethics;Aug93, Vol. 12 Issue 8, p663 

    This comment is offered in response to Hansen's "A Multidimensional Scale for Measuring Business Ethics: A Purification and Refinement". Five issues arising from Hansen's purification and refinement efforts are addressed. These include the issues of parsimony, predictive validity, collinearity,...

  • COGNITIVE PATHOLOGY AND MORAL JUDGMENT IN MANAGERS. Curlo, Eleonora; Strudler, Alan // Business Ethics Quarterly;Oct97, Vol. 7 Issue 4, p27 

    We examine the moral and managerial significance of some empirical studies in cognitive psychology. We suggest that these results may plausibly be interpreted as expressing deontological commitments of experimental subjects, even though psychologists who discuss the results seem to suppose that...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics