How physicians face ethical difficulties: a qualitative analysis

Hurst, S. A.; Hull, S. C.; DuVal, G.; Danis, M.
January 2005
Journal of Medical Ethics;Jan2005, Vol. 31 Issue 1, p7
Academic Journal
Background: Physicians face ethical difficulties daily, yet they seek ethics consultation infrequently. To date, no systematic data have been collected on the strategies they use to resolve such difficulties when they do so without the help of ethics consultation. Thus, our understanding of ethical decision making in day to day medical practice is poor. We report findings from the qualitative analysis of 310 ethically difficult situations described to us by physicians who encountered them in their practice. When facing such situations, the physicians sought to avoid conflict, obtain assistance, and protect the integrity of their conscience and reputation, as well as the integrity of the group of people who participated in the decisions. These goals could conflict with each other, or with ethical goals, in problematic ways. Being aware of these potentially conflicting goals may help physicians to resolve ethical difficulties more effectively. This awareness should also contribute to informing the practice of ethics consultation. Objective: To identify strategies used by physicians in dealing with ethical difficulties in their practice. Design, setting, and participants: National survey of internists, oncologists, and intensive care specialists by computer assisted telephone interviews (n = 344, response rate = 64%). As part of this survey, we asked physicians to tell us about a recent ethical dilemma they had encountered in their medical practice. Transcripts of their open-ended responses were analysed using coding and analytical elements of the grounded theory approach. Main measurements: Strategies and approaches reported by respondents as part of their account of a recent ethical difficulty they had encountered in their practice. Results: When faced with ethical difficulties, the physicians avoided conflict and looked for assistance, which contributed to protecting, or attempting to protect, the integrity of their conscience and reputation, as well as the ...


Related Articles

  • Ethics in nursing. Taylor, Carol // Australian Nursing Journal;Dec2004/Jan2005, Vol. 12 Issue 6, p11 

    Discusses the work ethics in nursing. Reason behind the importance of the promotion of individual and institutional ethics in nursing; Influence of nurses to facilitate ethical decisions in medical care; Capability of a nurse to initiate ethics consult.

  • Curbside Consultation Re-imagined: Borrowing from the Conflict Management Toolkit. Edelstein, Lauren; Lynch, John; Mokwunye, Nneka; DeRenzo, Evan // HEC Forum;Mar2010, Vol. 22 Issue 1, p41 

    Curbside ethics consultations occur when an ethics consultant provides guidance to a party who seeks assistance over ethical concerns in a case, without the consultant involving other stakeholders, conducting his or her own comprehensive review of the case, or writing a chart note. Some have...

  • Use of the Medical Ethics Consultation Service in a Busy Level I Trauma Center: Impact on Decision-Making and Patient Care. Johnson, Laura S.; Lesandrini, Jason; Rozycki, Grace S. // American Surgeon;Jul2012, Vol. 78 Issue 7, p735 

    The purposes of this study were to assess reasons for consultation of the Ethics Consultation Service for trauma patients and how consultations impacted care. We conducted a review of ethics consultations at a Level I trauma center from 2001 to 2010. Data included patient demographics, etiology...

  • Rethinking ward rounds. Sokol, Daniel K. // BMJ: British Medical Journal (Overseas & Retired Doctors Edition;3/7/2009, p571 

    The author discusses the need for an additional section to be added to patients' notes gathered during medical rounds called "ethical issues." The section would consists of a short list of headings, such as 'patient refuses treatment,' 'disagreement involving relatives,' and 'confidentiality...

  • Ethics and Economics. Daly, Gail // Nursing Economic$;Jul/Aug2000, Vol. 18 Issue 4, p194 

    Studies effective ways in managing costs in acute care settings in the United States. Improvement of patient care via ethics case consultations and end-of-life support from ethics team; Appropriate use of health care resources; Facilitation of meaningful communication and decision making...

  • Assessing the Ethics of Ethics Research: A Case Study. Miller, Franklin G.; Wendler, David // IRB: Ethics & Human Research;Mar/Apr2004, Vol. 26 Issue 2, p9 

    The article examines the ethics of ethics research in medicine by evaluating a specific study that was designed to assess individuals' decisions to enroll in clinical research. Although most ethics research poses essentially no risk of physical harm, this deceptive study of informed patients...

  • Am I my brother's gatekeeper? Professional ethics and the prioritisation of healthcare. Hunter, David // Journal of Medical Ethics;Sep2007, Vol. 33 Issue 9, p522 

    At the 5th International Conference on Priorities in Health Care in Wellington, New Zealand, 2004, one resonating theme was that for priority setting to be effective, it has to include clinicians in both decision making and the enforcement of those decisions. There was, however, a disturbing...

  • The role of the family in patient care. Slowther, Anne-Marie // Clinical Ethics;2006, Vol. 1 Issue 4, p191 

    The article reports on the significant role played by the family in patient care. It mentions that some of the source of ethical concern are the conflict between clinicians and families, and between family members. In determining what is in the best interests of a patient who lacks capacity to...

  • The ethical physician encounters international medical travel. Crozier, G. K. D.; Baylis, Françoise // Journal of Medical Ethics;May2010, Vol. 36 Issue 5, p11 

    International medical travel occurs when patients cross national borders to purchase medical goods and services. On occasion, physicians in home countries will be the last point of domestic contact for patients seeking healthcare information before they travel abroad for care. When this is the...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics