TITLE

A FIRST REVISIONIST REPLIES TO HER REVISIONISTS

AUTHOR(S)
Fishman, Nina
PUB. DATE
December 2004
SOURCE
Labour History Review (Maney Publishing);Dec2004, Vol. 69 Issue 3, p355
SOURCE TYPE
Academic Journal
DOC. TYPE
Article
ABSTRACT
This article presents a reply to the revision of the orthodoxy of communist historiography in Great Britain in 2004. Authors John McIlroy and Alan Campbell express support for the Labour orthodoxy in their editorial for the special issue of 'Labour History Review.' They also associate themselves with a third orthodoxy, appropriately described as pure revolutionary since its earlier exponents hold the Communist Party of Great Britain (CPGB) culpable for squandering the revolutionary will of the British proletariat. The purists differ about the conjuncture when the CPGB leadership betrayed the revolution. McIlroy and Campbell use the term Stalinism frequently, with declamatory emphasis, to describe CPGB history in the period with which their Histories of the British Communist Party mainly deals. Many historians of the Soviet Union, East Central Europe and western European communist parties use Stalinism and Stalinist as descriptors with no greater significance than historians of Britain and Germany deploy Victorian, Wilhelmine or Edwardian to invoke life and times. The authors also inform readers of their extra-historical dimension. A scholarly approach does not entail removing political and moral judgement from the writing of history.
ACCESSION #
15888173

 

Related Articles

  • IS CPGB HISTORY IMPORTANT? A REPLY TO HARRIET JONES. Campbell, Alan; McIlroy, John // Labour History Review (Maney Publishing);Dec2003, Vol. 68 Issue 3, p385 

    The article presents a reply to a paper by Harriet Jones, director of the Institute of Contemporary British History, which deals with the history of the Communist Party of Great Britain (CPGB). The basis of Jones's report is the propagation of categorizations of British Communist historiography...

  • COMMENT: THE INNER-PARTY CRITICS. Eaden, James; Renton, David // Labour History Review (Maney Publishing);Dec2004, Vol. 69 Issue 3, p349 

    This article discusses the history of the Communist Party in Great Britain. Communists sought at first to operate within a well-established labour movement, in a matrix of district and constituency Labour Parties, trade union braches and Co-operative societies. For much of the early period of...

  • ECHOES FROM THE DUSTBIN OF HISTORY: A REPLY TO ALAN CAMPBELL AND JOHN MCILROY. Worley, Matthew // Labour History Review (Maney Publishing);Dec2004, Vol. 69 Issue 3, p367 

    This article presents a reply to an editorial by Alan Campbell and John McIlroy on the history of the Communist Party of Great Britain (CPGB). Since the advent of Glasnost, the collapse of the Soviet Union and the dissolution of the CPGB, writing on British communism has emerged from beneath the...

  • A REPLY TO CRITICS. Campbell, Alan; McIlroy, John // Labour History Review (Maney Publishing);Dec2004, Vol. 69 Issue 3, p373 

    This article presents a reply to the comments made on an editorial about the history of the Communist Party of Great Britain (CPGB). Critic Nina Fishman states that the CPGB squandered the revolutionary will of British workers. Her citation provides no corroboration. Other critics provide...

  • CPGB HISTORY AT THE CENTRE OF CONTEMPORARY HISTORY: A REJOINDER TO ALAN CAMPBELL AND JOHN MCILROY. Fishman, Nina // Labour History Review (Maney Publishing);Dec2004, Vol. 69 Issue 3, p381 

    This article presents a reply to an editorial by Alan Campbell and John McIlroy on the history of the Communist Party of Great Britain (CPGB). Campbell and McIlroy have produced an arid scholasticist critique of the CPGB historiography. Notably, their commentary does not deal with the thoughtful...

  • The Taint of Communism: The Movement for Colonial Freedom, the Labour Party, and the Communist Party of Great Britain, 1954-70. Brownell, Josiah // Canadian Journal of History;Autumn2007, Vol. 42 Issue 2, p235 

    This article examines the three-way relationship between the Labour Party, the Movement for Colonial Freedom (MCF), and the Communist Party of Great Britain (CPGB), and describes their efforts to negotiate the delicate politics of decolonization. Decolonization had always been a politically...

  • Red flag to John Bull. Kiernan, V.G. // History Today;Dec95, Vol. 45 Issue 12, p53 

    Reviews the books `Enemy Within: The Rise and Fall of the British Communist Party,' by Francis Beckett and `Opening the Books: Essays on the Social and Cultural History of the British Communist Party,' edited by Geoff Andrews, Nina Fishman and Kevin Morgan.

  • CPGB HISTORY AT THE CENTRE OF CONTEMPORARY HISTORY 2002: A REJOINDER. Thorpe, Andrew // Labour History Review (Maney Publishing);Dec2004, Vol. 69 Issue 3, p385 

    This article presents a rejoinder to the reply of authors John McIlroy and Alan Campbell to Harriet Jones' Conference Report on the history of the Communist Party of Great Britain (CPGB), published in an issue of the 'Labor History Review.' A round-table panel at the Institute of Contemporary...

  • The left's bibliophilia in interwar Britain: assessing booksellers' role in the battle of ideas. Cocaign, Elen // Twentieth Century Communism;May2012, Issue 4, p218 

    The article examines the idea that books were widely considered to be the most important weapons in the battle of ideas in interwar Great Britain and focuses on the Communist Party of Great Britain's (CPGB) use of books for political education. A brief overview of bookselling and publishing in...

Share

Read the Article

Courtesy of VIRGINIA BEACH PUBLIC LIBRARY AND SYSTEM

Sign out of this library

Other Topics