Improved Combination of Multiple Atmospheric GCM Ensembles for Seasonal Prediction

Robertson, Andrew W.; Lall, Upmanu; Zebiak, Stephen E.; Goddard, Lisa
December 2004
Monthly Weather Review;Dec2004, Vol. 132 Issue 12, p2732
Academic Journal
An improved Bayesian optimal weighting scheme is developed and used to combine six atmospheric general circulation model (GCM) seasonal hindcast ensembles. The approach is based on the prior belief that the forecast probabilities of tercile-category precipitation and near-surface temperature are equal to the climatological ones. The six GCMs are integrated over the 1950–97 period with observed monthly SST prescribed at the lower boundary, with 9–24 ensemble members. The weights of the individual models are determined by maximizing the log likelihood of the combination by season over the integration period. A key ingredient of the scheme is the climatological equal-odds forecast, which is included as one of the “models” in the multimodel combination. Simulation skill is quantified in terms of the cross-validated ranked probability skill score (RPSS) for the three-category probabilistic hindcasts. The individual GCM ensembles, simple poolings of three and six models, and the optimally combined multimodel ensemble are compared. The Bayesian optimal weighting scheme outperforms the pooled ensemble, which in turn outperforms the individual models. In the extratropics, its main benefit is to bring much of the large area of negative-precipitation RPSS values up to near-zero values. The skill of the optimal combination is almost always increased (in the large spatial averages considered) when the number of models in the combination is increased from three to six, regardless of which models are included in the three-model combination. Improvements are made to the original Bayesian scheme of Rajagopalan et al. by reducing the dimensionality of the numerical optimization, averaging across data subsamples, and including spatial smoothing of the likelihood function. These modifications are shown to yield increases in cross-validated RPSS skills. The revised scheme appears to be better suited to combining larger sets of models, and, in the future, it should be possible to include statistical models into the weighted ensemble without fundamental difficulty.


Related Articles

  • Mechanisms Supporting Long-Lived Episodes of Propagating Nocturnal Convection within a 7-Day WRF Model Simulation. Trier, S. B.; Davis, C. A.; Ahijevych, D. A.; Weisman, M. L.; Bryan, G. H. // Journal of the Atmospheric Sciences;Oct2006, Vol. 63 Issue 10, p2437 

    A large-domain explicit convection simulation is used to investigate the life cycle of nocturnal convection for a one-week period of successive zonally propagating heavy precipitation episodes occurring over the central United States. Similar to climatological studies of phase-coherent...

  • The influence of the circulation on surface temperature and precipitation patterns over Europe. Jones, P. D.; Lister, D. H. // Climate of the Past Discussions;2009, Vol. 5 Issue 1, p535 

    The atmospheric circulation clearly has an important influence on variations in surface temperature and precipitation. In this study we illustrate the spatial patterns of variation that occur for the principal circulation patterns across Europe in the standard four seasons. We use an existing...

  • The Contrasting Features of Winter Circulation During Surplus and Deficient Precipitation Over Western Himalayas. Dimri, A. P. // Pure & Applied Geophysics;Nov2005, Vol. 162 Issue 11, p2215 

    Contrasting features associated with surplus and deficient precipitation years are studied to examine atmospheric circulation characteristics during the winter season viz., December, January February and March (DJFM) to assess the wintertime synoptic weather system affecting the western...

  • Characterization of precipitation δ18O variation in Nagqu, central Tibetan Plateau and its climatic controls. Zhongfang Liu; Lide Tian; Tandong Yao; Wusheng Yu // Theoretical & Applied Climatology;2010, Vol. 99 Issue 1/2, p95 

    The stable isotopic composition of precipitation in different regions reflects climatic factors such as temperature, precipitation, moisture sources, and transport process. However, the isotopic variation in the region is usually much complicated due to the combined influences of these factors....

  • Evaporation and Precipitation Surface Effects in Local Mass Continuity Laws of Moist Air. Wacker, Ulrike; Frisius, Thomas; Herbert, Fritz // Journal of the Atmospheric Sciences;Oct2006, Vol. 63 Issue 10, p2642 

    The local mass balance equations of cloudy air are formulated for a model system composed of dry air, water vapor, and four categories of water condensate particles, as typically adopted for numerical weather prediction and climate models. The choice of the barycentric velocity as reference...

  • Snow Cover and Atmospheric Variability.  // American Scientist;Jan/Feb84, Vol. 72 Issue 1, p50 

    This article presents information on the snow covering and its effects on both daily weather and long-term climate. The largest changes that occur in the earth's surface over the period of several days to several months result from the variations of snow and ice cover. Snow is one of the most...

  • Relationships between circulation strength and the variability of growing-season and cold-season climate in northern and central Europe. Jones, Philip D.; Briffa, Keith R.; Osborn, Timothy J.; Moberg, Anders; Bergström, Hans // Holocene;Nov2002, Vol. 12 Issue 6, p643 

    This paper examines variability in surface climate and the relationship with two circulation indices using recently produced 200-250 year long European daily and monthly climatic series. Assessments are made of the influence of circulation indices (zonal over western Europe and average pressure...

  • The North American Monsoon Model Assessment Project: Integrating Numerical Modeling into a Field-based Process Study. Gutzler, D. S.; Kim, H.-K.; Higgins, R. W.; Juang, H.-M. H.; Kanamitsu, M.; Mitchell, K.; Mo, K.; Pegion, P.; Ritchie, E.; Schemm, J.-K.; Schubert, S.; Song, Y.; Yang, R. // Bulletin of the American Meteorological Society;Oct2005, Vol. 86 Issue 10, p1423 

    This article highlights the North American Monsoon Experiment's (NAME) monsoon model assessment project. NAME will need to improve numerical simulations of the monsoon circulation and its large-scale effects to achieve its goals. The project's activities over the next few years are aimed at...

  • Simulating the impact of the large-scale circulation on the 2-m temperature and precipitation climatology. Bowden, Jared; Nolte, Christopher; Otte, Tanya // Climate Dynamics;Apr2013, Vol. 40 Issue 7/8, p1903 

    The impact of the simulated large-scale atmospheric circulation on the regional climate is examined using the Weather Research and Forecasting (WRF) model as a regional climate model. The purpose is to understand the potential need for interior grid nudging for dynamical downscaling of global...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics