Rationality in the Statements of President Bush? An Assessment of Whether the Kyoto Protocol is Fatally Flawed

Matsuo, Naoki
June 2001
International Review for Environmental Strategies;Summer2001, Vol. 2 Issue 1, p173
Academic Journal
The paper assessed the rationality of the "official" reasons why the Bush Administration opposes the Kyoto Protocol and judges the Kyoto Protocol to be "fatally flawed". Most of the reasons why the Bush Administration made this judgment--lack of long-term goals, exclusion of developing countries and lack of linkages between the scientific base and policy--can be dealt with in the process of the development of the Kyoto Protocol much more easily than through the establishment of an alternative from scratch. We find some rationality in the Bush Administration's opposition to the ratification of the Protocol by the United States based on recognition of increases in US greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions above the "payable" level, in addition to security concerns involved in purchasing permits from EIT countries. Other stances of the Bush administration, such as devaluing or neglecting the existing international framework which the international community has achieved through a decade of intense negotiations, e.g. the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change and the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, may cause delays in addressing climate change issues.


Related Articles

  • The Kyoto Treaty Deserved to Die. DeMuth, Christopher // American Enterprise;Sep2001, Vol. 12 Issue 6, p43 

    Reports on the collapse and rejection of the Kyoto Protocol on Climate Change by United States President George W. Bush. Amount that the U.S. government spends on climate-change research; Approaches to the control of carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gases; Primary cause of the protocol's...

  • President Announces Initiatives to Address Climate Change.  // Occupational Hazards;Mar2003, Vol. 65 Issue 3, p24 

    Reports on the initiative of U.S. President George W. Bush to address issues on climate change, as of March 2003. Effort of the government to reduce greenhouse gas emissions; Details of the initiative called Climate VISION (Voluntary Innovative Sector Initiatives: Opportunities Now); Challenge...

  • Bush climate-change plan gets cool response. Powell, Kendall // Nature;12/12/2002, Vol. 420 Issue 6916, p595 

    Looks at the response of scientists on the plan proposed by the administration of U.S. President George W. Bush on climate change. Plan's lack of clear priorities and detailed objectives; Concern on the administration's lack of real interest in supporting research on global climate change.

  • The Kyoto Placebo. Bell, Ruth Greenspan // Issues in Science & Technology;Winter2006, Vol. 22 Issue 2, p28 

    The article looks at issues surrounding the 1997 Protocol to the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change that was negotiated in Kyoto, Japan. The Kyoto Protocol has set in place the foundations of a workable plan for combating the certainty of global warming, in the form of...

  • Bush Outlines New Climate-Change Goal. Hunter, Pam // ENR: Engineering News-Record;4/28/2008, Vol. 260 Issue 14, p9 

    This article reports on a goal for a curb in the growth of greenhouse gases announced by the administration of U.S. President George W. Bush in 2008. The announcement was derided by Democrats and environmental groups, but some industry sources said it is a signal that the administration wants to...

  • Is Bush warming to global warming?  // New Scientist;9/4/2004, Vol. 183 Issue 2463, p3 

    A report for the U.S. Congress describing activities and plans for the national Climate Change Science Program states in clear terms that increases in global temperature over the past 50 years are "unlikely to be due only to natural climate variations". And it lays the blame for some of the...

  • Remarks Following Discussions With Prime Minister Tony Blair of the United Kingdom and an Exchange With Reporters in Heiligendamm. Bush, George W. // Weekly Compilation of Presidential Documents;6/11/2007, Vol. 43 Issue 23, p760 

    The article presents the remarks of U.S. President George W. Bush on climate change, following discussions with British Prime Minister Tony Blair at the Kempinski Grand Hotel in Heiligendamm, Germany on June 7, 2007. Blair emphasizes the need for the Kyoto deal to command broad agreement across...

  • US to develop knowledge in ten-year strategic plan. Harries-Rees, Karen // European Chemical News;8/4/2003, Vol. 79 Issue 2064, p28 

    Reports on the issuance of a strategic plan by the Climate Change Science Program in the U.S. in 2003 to address issues around climate variability and change. Appeal from President George W. Bush on the management of greenhouse gases; Budget for the deployment of satellite-based global...

  • Bush as global steward. Gergen, David // U.S. News & World Report;02/05/2001, Vol. 130 Issue 5, p64 

    Argues the United States President George W. Bush needs to develop environmental policies as well as energy policies. How the U.S. is the largest producer of greenhouse gases; Suggestion that other countries look to the U.S. for leadership in environmental issues; Discussion of former...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics