Back to basics: does decentralization improve health system performance? Evidence from Ceará in north-east Brazil

Atkinson, Sarah; Haran, Dave
November 2004
Bulletin of the World Health Organization;Nov2004, Vol. 82 Issue 11, p822
Academic Journal
Objective To examine whether decentralization has improved health system performance in the State of Ceará, north-east Brazil. Methods Ceará is strongly committed to decentralization. A survey across 45 local ( município) health systems collected data on performance and formal organization, including decentralization, informal management and local political culture. The indicators for informal management and local political culture were based on prior ethnographic research. Data were analysed using analysis of variance, Duncan's post-hoc test and multiple regression. Findings Decentralization was associated with improved performance, but only for 5 of our 22 performance indicators. Moreover, in the multiple regression, decentralization explained the variance in only one performance indicator; indicators for informal management and political culture appeared to be more important influences. However, some indicators for informal management were themselves associated with decentralization but not any of the political culture indicators. Conclusion Good management practices in the study led to decentralized local health systems rather than vice versa. Any apparent association between decentralization and performance seems to be an artefact of the informal management, and the wider political culture in which a local health system is embedded strongly influences the performance of local health systems.


Related Articles

  • DECENTRALIZATION OF HEALTH SERVICES IN ROMANIA. PÎRVU, Daniela; DIDEA, Ionel // Scientific Bulletin - Economic Sciences / Buletin Stiintific - S;Jul2013, Vol. 12 Issue 2, p11 

    This paper aims to provide an analytical framework for decentralization of health services in Romania. Decentralization, intended as a measure to increase quality of health services provided to the population, and to a better functioning of these some health units far not led to the expected...

  • Building a bigger lifeboat. Pinkham, Julie // Massachusetts Nurse Advocate;Apr2010, Vol. 81 Issue 3, p3 

    The article focuses on the author's perspectives on the health care reform and the health care financing crisis in Massachusetts. She is critical on the measures taken by the government to address the issue of the transition of health care from small business models to health care corporations....

  • Vivenciando o processo de municipalização do SUS no município de Juazeiro do Norte (CE). de Lavor Coriolano, Maria Wanderleya; Albuquerque, Grayce Alencar; de Sousa Araújo, Natércia; de Oliveira, Marcelo Alves; de Moraes Lima, Marinus // Revista Ciência & Saúde Coletiva;2010, Vol. 15 Issue 5, p2447 

    The reorganization of the Brazilian health system, the principle of the decentralization and municipalization of the health services has demanded a deeper knowledge about its reality for people's quality of life. The aim of this study is to observe the organizational strategies of the health...

  • SAÄžLIK HÄ°ZMETÄ° KRÄ°ZÄ°: REFORMLAR VE KRÄ°ZÄ° AÅžMA YAKLAÅžIMLARI. GÜNAYDIN, Davuthan // Uludag Journal of Economy & Society;2012, Vol. 31 Issue 2, p195 

    Since the beginnig of 1980, we have seen lots of developed and developing countries' going about rooted reforms on health service. Although it is claimed that the reasons for these reformsa re to increase the quality or to set universal coverage of health service, the real aim is to participate...

  • Poland—an “experimental range” for health care system changes. Two reforms: decentralization and centralization and their consequences. Krajewski-Siuda, Krzysztof; Romaniuk, Piotr // Journal of Public Health (09431853);Feb2008, Vol. 16 Issue 1, p61 

    In Poland, the new regulations establishing a decentralized system based on the regional sickness funds were implemented in 1999. However, the inconsequence of central government policy in Poland caused a significant reorganization of the model in 2001 towards the opposite direction. The...

  • Paradoxos das políticas de descentralização de saúde no Brasil. Pasche, Dário Frederico; Righi, Liane Beatriz; Thomé, Henrique Inácio; Stolz, Eveline Dischkaln // Revista Panamericana de Salud Publica;Dec2006, Vol. 20 Issue 6, p416 

    The constitution of Brazil directs that the country's health system, the Unified Health System (Sistema Unico de Saúde), be politically and administratively decentralized. Nevertheless, handing over competencies, responsibilities, and resources to subnational levels, especially to municipal...

  • Las reformas colombianas a la Seguridad Social en Salud y su impacto sobre la equidad. Patiño, B. Gonzalo Alberto; Falla, Óscar Herrán // Reflexión Politica;Jun2009, Vol. 11 Issue 21, p126 

    After decades of reform in the health system in Colombia, that includes a deep reform in many sector of national economy, we have some advances both in equity and also in poorer people. The decentralization, the market and his legislation have been developed indeed, but can't resolve the...

  • National health reform and the Queensland Health workforce.  // Queensland Nurse;Aug2011, Vol. 30 Issue 4, p29 

    The article focuses on the National Health Reform Agreement between the Commonwealth of Australia and all the states and territories in Australia, and the legislative bill Health and Hospitals Network 2011 in Queensland. It mentions that under the agreement released in August 2, 2011, states...

  • Myths of health care decentralization. Costa-i-Font, Joan // Journal of Health Services Research & Policy;Oct2012, Vol. 17 Issue 4, p252 

    There are several myths about the impact of decentralization of health care governance. These include a worsening of regional inequalities, greater privatization of health care, greater inefficiency resulting from duplication of managerial activities such as human resource policies, and lower...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics