Precedent Autonomy and Subsequent Consent

Davis, John K.
June 2004
Ethical Theory & Moral Practice;Jun2004, Vol. 7 Issue 3, p267
Academic Journal
Honoring a living will typically involves treating an incompetent patient in accord with preferences she once had, but whose objects she can no longer understand. How do we respect her “precedent autonomy” by giving her what she used to want? There is a similar problem with “subsequent consent”: How can we justify interfering with someone's autonomy on the grounds that she will later consent to the interference, if she refuses now? Both problems arise on the assumption that, to respect someone's autonomy, any preferences we respect must be among that person's current preferences. I argue that this is not always true. Just as we can celebrate an event long after it happens, so can we respect someone's wishes long before or after she has that wish. In the contexts of precedent autonomy and subsequent consent, the wishes are often preferences about which of two other, conflicting preferences to satisfy. When someone has two conflicting preferences, and a third preference on how to resolve that conflict, to respect his autonomy we must respect that third preference. People with declining competence may have a resolution preference earlier, favoring the earlier conflicting preference (precedent autonomy), whereas those with rising competence may have it later, favoring the later conflicting preference (subsequent consent). To respect autonomy in such cases we must respect not a current, but a former or later preference.


Related Articles

  • The hazard: Conflicts of interest. Eichenhorn, Emily J. // ABA Journal;Mar1998, Vol. 84 Issue 3, p56 

    Examines the effect of the lawyer's failure to recognize the conflicts that may arise from business relationships such as corporations and partnerships. Parameters which lawyers should addressed to avoid conflicts of interest; Importance of proper communication; Anticipation of misunderstanding...

  • Starting Out. Short, Cristina // Nursing Standard;1/14/2004, Vol. 18 Issue 18, p25 

    Shares lessons learned by a nurse from her patient with Alzheimer's disease. Effect on her attitude and behavior toward patients; Practical means of showing respect to the patient; Effect of negative attitudes on the care given.

  • Conflict of interest. Balls, Ashley // NZ Business;Oct2004, Vol. 18 Issue 9, p48 

    Examines the attitude of New Zealand towards conflict of interest. Incidents which showed conflict of interest; Impact of conflict of interest on small and medium enterprises; Method used to manage conflict of interest.

  • Religious attitudes toward prescriptions, medicines, and doctors in France. Fainzang, Sylvie // Culture, Medicine & Psychiatry;Dec2005, Vol. 29 Issue 4, p457 

    Although the social sciences have studied the influence of social environment on individual behaviors regarding medication, very little research has been done on the variations that exist between patients in equivalent social contexts but with diverse religious backgrounds. This article presents...

  • Tolerance: A Concept Analysis. Moore, Hilary Kyle; Walker, Charles Alan // Journal of Theory Construction & Testing;Fall/Winter2011, Vol. 15 Issue 2, p48 

    The concept of tolerance is analyzed using a method outlined by Walker and Avant. This analysis clarifies the meaning of tolerance in such diverse disciplines as nursing, medicine, social science, and theological education. Although tolerance subsumes respect, empathy, and acceptance, it implies...

  • 'A servant cannot serve two masters'. Milas, Robert W. // Linacre Quarterly;Aug2013, Vol. 80 Issue 3, p196 

    A letter to the editor on the topic related to indulgence of physicians in non-medical issues of their patients leading to conflict of interest.

  • R-E-S-P-E-C-T? Hutchinson, Linda // PN;Aug2013, Vol. 67 Issue 8, p11 

    A letter to the editor is presented in response to the article "Happy Feet" in the June 2013 issue focusing on the U.S. Transportation Security Agency's (TSA) rules for people with disabilities who cannot readily remove their shoes.

  • INCULCATING RESPECT FOR LAW IN THE SCHOOLS. Chambers, M. M. // Education;Feb1932, Vol. 52 Issue 6, p356 

    The author, who is a social science teacher, argues against the indoctrination of school pupils with civic attitudes, such as respect for law in the schools. The author believes that most boys and girls are naturally decent and have integrity while being self-reliant and independent. He feels...

  • Combat Your Co-workers' Chronic Negativity.  // MDS Alert;Dec2012, Vol. 10 Issue 12, pp139 

    The article offers suggestions on helping co-workers to develop a more positive attitude. Suggestions are offered to be compassionate and also ask for help. It is stated that accommodating occasional bad mood can help in doing wonders and thus help to avoid conflict and also maintain team...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics