Does "Bait and Switch" Really Benefit Consumers? Advancing the Discussion�

Wilkie, William L.; Mela, Carl F.; Gundlach, Gregory T.
September 1998
Marketing Science;1998, Vol. 17 Issue 3, p290
Academic Journal
AbstractWe applaud the advances in this colloquy and the areas of convergence that are emerging. However, this reply points out that the purported benefits of "bait and switch" found in Hess and Gerstner (1998) are predicated upon (i) only a single component (availability) within the broader domain of bait and switch; (ii) the assumption that one of the parameters in the consumer utility function differs with the availability of advertised brands; and (iii) a further assumption that no other parameters in the model will change when the availability condition changes. After assessing these developments, we conclude that i) the legal status of bait-and-switch schemes is fine as it stands; ii) when understood in their true complexity, parameters in the consumer utility functions likely will not differ with regard to availability, thus obviating the finding of increased consumer welfare; and iii) even if it is believed that utility functions would differ, effects on other model parameters clearly suggest that consumers will be worse off with bait and switch. Despite these differences, however, we are pleased with the developments the dialogue has produced.(Pricing; Promotion; Public Policy; Bait and Switch)


Related Articles

  • Does "Bait and Switch" Really Benefit Consumers? Wilkie, William L.; Mela, Carl F.; Gundlach, Gregory T. // Marketing Science;1998, Vol. 17 Issue 3, p273 

    AbstractWhile the field of marketing science has long been interested in the effects of promotional efforts, public policy issues involving illegal marketer fraud and deception have generally not been addressed in this body of work. One key exception to this generalization is a Marketing Science...

  • Yes, "Bait and Switch" Really Benefits Consumers. Hess, James D.; Gerstner, Eitan // Marketing Science;1998, Vol. 17 Issue 3, p283 

    AbstractIn our 1990 Marketing Science paper we demonstrated that a law prohibiting bait and switch may have the surprising consequence of hurting the consumers it was designed to protect. Wilkie, Mela, and Gundlach (1998) postulate that this may be false if upselling is equally effective when...

  • An Empirical Analysis of Outcome Biases in Constituent Evaluations of Public Policy Decision Makers. Mowen, John C.; Stone, Thomas H. // Journal of Public Policy & Marketing;Spring92, Vol. 11 Issue 1, p24 

    This research empirically investigated a phenomenon that may influence the exchange relationship between public policy makers and consumers—the tendency of consumers to exhibit an outcome bias in their evaluations of a public policy maker who makes a decision under uncertainty. An outcome...

  • Criminal Receiving: The "Fence" as Marketer. Hill, Ronald Paul // Journal of Public Policy & Marketing;Fall92, Vol. 11 Issue 2, p126 

    The criminal receiver of stolen property has been described as an essential actor in property theft and a crucial figure in the support and preservation of thieves for more than 200 years. Today, the thief's ability to market stolen property through the "fence" still determines the success or...

  • The Regional Concept, Public Policy and Policy Spaces:The ARC and TVA. Gatrell, Jay D.; Hanham, Robert Q.; Worsham, Jeff; McDorman, Maureen // International Journal of Humanities & Social Sciences;2009, Vol. 3 Issue 3, p202 

    This paper examines two policy spaces�the ARC and TVA�and their spatialized politics. The research observes that the regional concept informs public policy and can contribute to the formation of stable policy initiatives. Using the subsystem framework to understand the political...

  • Analysis on the major obstacles of public participation in public policy-making. Fu-feng GAO // Journal of US-China Public Administration;Aug2009, Vol. 6 Issue 4, p56 

    Participation in public policy-making is one of the important approaches for citizens to affect public policy, and also the guarantee of the scientific and democratic paths of the public policy. To enhance the cognitive level and ability of the citizen who participate in public policy-making,...

  • Who Governs in God's City? Dunn, Joshua // Society;Jan2012, Vol. 49 Issue 1, p24 

    After clearing away some misconceptions about the power of the religious right in Colorado Springs, this article will examine three areas, education, medical marijuana, and gay rights, where the city's religious conservatives have tried to influence public policy. With each area their efforts...

  • Estimation of Effectiveness of Public Policy Institutions in Russia. NIKOVSKAYA, L. I.; YAKIMETZ, V. N. // Polis: Journal of Political Studies;2013, Issue 5, p77 

    Problems of Russian regions' public policy are discussed in the article. Evaluation of the said public policy is based on comparing the results of empirical studies conducted in 2009-2011. The "antirating" for the public policy institutions is analyzed, which illustrates failures in significant...

  • Democracia y derechos indios en México: la ciudadanía multicultural como modelo de paz. De La Cruz, Laura Raquel Valladares // Revista Mexicana de Ciencias Politicas y Sociales;may-dic2003, Vol. 45 Issue 188/189, p121 

    The Indian fights by the recognition of its collective rights and by the restoration of a political model that we could frame in the "multicultural citizenship" have several decades already, and although advance in terms of constitutional recognitions have been registered, these do not yet...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics