TITLE

Does "Bait and Switch" Really Benefit Consumers?

AUTHOR(S)
Wilkie, William L.; Mela, Carl F.; Gundlach, Gregory T.
PUB. DATE
September 1998
SOURCE
Marketing Science;1998, Vol. 17 Issue 3, p273
SOURCE TYPE
Academic Journal
DOC. TYPE
Article
ABSTRACT
AbstractWhile the field of marketing science has long been interested in the effects of promotional efforts, public policy issues involving illegal marketer fraud and deception have generally not been addressed in this body of work. One key exception to this generalization is a Marketing Science article suggesting that the practice of "bait and switch" may be beneficial to consumers and, furthermore, that the Federal Trade Commission should investigate revising its standards to legitimize this practice (Gerstner and Hess 1990). This finding and recommendation seemed so significant that it is surprising that the recommendation has not, to date, been explored in greater detail.In this paper we further explore the impact of the two components of bait and switch: out of stock and upselling. We do this by using Moorthy's (1993) theoretical modeling framework to systematically extend and assess the Gerstner and Hess model. We find that the previously reported increase in consumer welfare that arises from allowing out-of-stock conditions at retailers is actually due to the utility created by salespersons' explaining product features and benefits, not by the out of stock. Thus, the ramifications of both our legal and modeling analyses are that deceptive bait-and-switch practices result in harm to consumers and should not be legalized.Our paper concludes by proposing worthwhile modeling issues for further exploration. In addition, we suggest that our procedure for analyzing public policy issues (by exploring the confluence of law, consumer behavior, and marketing models) can serve as a useful exemplar for further contributions to public policy by marketing scientists.(Pricing; Promotion; Public Policy; Bait and Switch)
ACCESSION #
1426242

 

Related Articles

  • Yes, "Bait and Switch" Really Benefits Consumers. Hess, James D.; Gerstner, Eitan // Marketing Science;1998, Vol. 17 Issue 3, p283 

    AbstractIn our 1990 Marketing Science paper we demonstrated that a law prohibiting bait and switch may have the surprising consequence of hurting the consumers it was designed to protect. Wilkie, Mela, and Gundlach (1998) postulate that this may be false if upselling is equally effective when...

  • Does "Bait and Switch" Really Benefit Consumers? Advancing the Discussion�. Wilkie, William L.; Mela, Carl F.; Gundlach, Gregory T. // Marketing Science;1998, Vol. 17 Issue 3, p290 

    AbstractWe applaud the advances in this colloquy and the areas of convergence that are emerging. However, this reply points out that the purported benefits of "bait and switch" found in Hess and Gerstner (1998) are predicated upon (i) only a single component (availability) within the broader...

  • Comparison Advertising: Problems and Potential. Wilkie, William L.; Farris, Paul W. // Journal of Marketing;Oct75, Vol. 39 Issue 4, p7 

    The article reports on the problems and benefits associated with comparison advertising. The authors focus on identifying marketing techniques that can be defined as comparison advertisements. Popular opinions established in the 1960s, against the practice of comparison advertising, are...

  • Comparison Advertising: Problems and Potential. Wilkie, William L.; Farris, Paul W. // Journal of Marketing;19Oct75, Vol. 39 Issue 4, p7 

    The article reports on the problems and benefits associated with comparison advertising. The authors focus on identifying marketing techniques that can be defined as comparison advertisements. Popular opinions established in the 1960s, against the practice of comparison advertising, are...

  • RESOURCE DISPOSITION, THE NEXT LEGAL CHALLENGE TO MARKETERS. Stiffler, Charles; Buchanan, Dodds I. // AMA Winter Educators' Conference Proceedings;1988, p370 

    Reports on the three pivotal marketing laws on strategic sequence of generic consumer economic behaviors in the United States. Importance of marketing laws in anticipating the fourth pivotal era in marketplace law; Significance of resource disposition in marketing legislation; Pattern of the...

  • Viral & Free.  // NZ Marketing Magazine;Apr2006, Vol. 25 Issue 3, p10 

    The article presents questions and answers related to law in marketing. One reader inquires about potential legal issues with viral marketing in New Zealand. Another asks the risks involved in their free chair deal.

  • From the Editor. Currdiff, Edward W. // Journal of Marketing;Apr1976, Vol. 40 Issue 2, p1 

    The article presents the editor's opinions regarding news related to the field of marketing. He suggests that marketing professionals are ever concerned with the legal implications of the advertising industry. It is further suggested that members of the legal profession are becoming more and...

  • Place your bets, please. Hemsley, Steve // Marketing Week;7/1/2004, Vol. 27 Issue 27, p37 

    Talks about laws pertinent to advertising and marketing in Great Britain. Potential effect of laws overseen the Gambling Commission on prize promotions; Controversy surrounding the complimentary bet offered by Holsten Pils; Provisions of the Lotteries and Amusement Act 1976.

  • Open And Shut Case. Grierson, Simpson // NZ Marketing Magazine;Apr2005, Vol. 24 Issue 3, p39 

    Addresses several queries related to marketing law in New Zealand as of April 2005. Surcharge imposed on customers for establishments open during the holidays; Information received by advertising agencies from their clients; Use of the word "natural" in labeling and advertising.

Share

Read the Article

Courtesy of THE LIBRARY OF VIRGINIA

Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics