Utility of MELD and Child-Turcotte-Pugh scores and the Canadian waitlisting algorithm in predicting short-term survival after liver transplant

Bazarah, Salem M.; Peltekian, Kevork M.; Mealister, Vivian C.; Bitter-Suermann, Heinrich; MacDonald, Alan S.
August 2004
Clinical & Investigative Medicine;Aug2004, Vol. 27 Issue 4, p162
Academic Journal
Background: The Model for End-Stage Liver Disease (MELD) and Child-Turcotte-Pugh (CTP) scores are import ant predictors for survival after liver transplantation (LT). The objective of this study was to compare the utility of MELD and CTP scores with Canadian waitlisting algorithm in transplantation (CanWAIT) status for predicting 90-day survival after LT. Methods: Retro- spectively, we analyzed all 228 liver transplants performed in adults by the Atlantic Liver Transplant Program since 1985. These cases included combined transplants, retransplants and those after fulminant liver failure. MELD and CTP scores were calculated, and CanWAIT status and waiting time on the day of LT determined. We used c-statistic for 90-day outcome as the endpoint (survival), comparing areas under the receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curves for MELD and CTP scores and CanWAIT status. Results: Mean (and standard deviation [SD]) MELD score was 18 (SD 12); CTP score, 10 (SD 3); and waiting time, 97 (SD 132) days. At the time of LT, 54% were in CanWAIT status 1;4% in 1T; 14% in 2; 11% in 3;6 % in 3F; 4% in 4; and 7% in status 4F. Overall 90-day survival was 80% (95% confidence interval [CI] 75%-85%), exceeding the predicted survival by MELD scale with transplant of only 51% (CI 47%-55%). By c-statistic, CanWAIT is a clinically relevant predictor of 90-day outcomes in LT. By multivariate regression analysis, only CanWAIT status and age were found to have independent associations for short-term outcomes after LT. Interpretation: CanWAIT status stratifies LT patients better and predicts short-term outcome more accurately than MELD or CTP scores, and so should not be replaced by MELD or CTP scores. This observation should be confirmed by a prospective and multicentre study in Canada.


Related Articles

  • A Nonparametric Test for Comparing Any Number of Variances. Nelson, Lloyd S. // Journal of Quality Technology;Jan2002, Vol. 34 Issue 1, p130 

    Focuses on a nonparametric test for comparing any number of variances. Absolute deviations from the sample medians; One-way analysis of variance of the values.

  • INTERCEPTING FUNDS WITH A STOP NOTICE. Lento, Gary N.; Coe, Deborah A. // Business Journal Serving Fresno & the Central San Joaquin Valley;8/27/2010, Issue 324223, Special section p2 

    The article explores the Mechanic's Lien and the Stop Notice, two approaches that provide security interest in a real property on which a work was performed. It mentions that the Stop Notice is designed to put a hold on unexpected construction funds, and provides payment more quickly than the...

  • List-Strength Effect: II. Theoretical Mechanisms. Shiffrin, Richard M.; Ratcliff, Roger; Clark, Steven E. // Journal of Experimental Psychology. Learning, Memory & Cognition;Mar1990, Vol. 16 Issue 2, p179 

    Examines the list-strength predictions for several current models and consider the various modifications might bring the predictions in line with the data. Description of the general terms that are most crucial to the list-strength predictions; Provision of list-strength effect; Standard...

  • Technique of calculating the deviations of the shape of cylindrical constructions relative to a circle of least deviation. Minimal annular zone. B. Novikov // Measurement Techniques;May2007, Vol. 50 Issue 5, p516 

    Abstract  A technique of determining the deviations of shape relative to a circle of least deviations and an example illustrating its practical implementation are presented.

  • More Lenders Adding 2nd Liens.  // National Mortgage News;9/13/2004, Vol. 28 Issue 50, p3 

    This article reports on the home equity fund in the U.S. It doesn't look as though homeowners are quite done tapping into their home equity to fund various expenses, going by the rise in second lien lending for the second quarter. Heading up the list is Bank of America, Charlotte, with $ I6,9...

  • Security Agreement for Borrowing Money.  // Security Agreement for Borrowing Money;1/1/2008, p1 

    Lenders often feel more confident about a loan if they are given a security interest in the assets of a business. Use this form when some or all of a business's tangible personal property is going to be used for security.

  • Certain security contractors taxable.  // Sales & Use Tax Alert;4/15/2011, Vol. 21 Issue 7, p7 

    The article talks about the enactment of legislation, under which any person or entity primarily involved in the business of furnishing and installing tangible personal property that provides electronic or physical security on real property for the use of a financial institution is treated as a...

  • Is it time to reconsider semivariance again? A note. Kochman, Ladd // American Business Review;Jan2000, Vol. 18 Issue 1, p19 

    Examines the efficiency of using semivariance (SV) in demonstrating average stock returns. Comparison between standard deviation (SD) and SV; Correlation between average returns and semivariances; Relationship between risk measures and means; Superiority of SV over SD.

  • Stochastic modeling of basins microtopography: analysis of spatial variability and model testing. Bai, Mejian; Xu, Di; Li, Yinong; Pereira, Luis // Irrigation Science;Jan2010, Vol. 28 Issue 2, p157 

    Microtopography is among the most important factors affecting the performance of basin irrigation system due to its influence on the advance and recession processes. This study is based on field-measured surface elevation of 116 basins in North China. The spatial variability of basins...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics