Meninės reprezentacijos kritika šv. Augustino Išpažinimuose

Tamošaitis, Mantas
July 2019
Literature / Literatura;2019, Vol. 61 Issue 3, p75
Academic Journal
This article is concerned with the critique of representation in art found in Augustine’s Confessions. The aim of the author is not only to reveal the fundamental influence of Plato and Aristotle on Augustine’s criticism, but to show the unique aspects of Augustine’s thought. The article considers Augustine’s critique of art in the Confessions to be three-fold: the ontological critique, the ethical (psychological) critique of intention and the critique of pagan ethos in art. The article considers the ontological critique as based on the neoplatonic dualism of body and soul as well as the platonic concept of image. Therefore Augustine considers artistic representation to be three-times removed from reality and sees the experience of God as the perfect aesthetical experience. Author states that the ethical critique considers art as a form of idolatry, which projects the innermost desires of the soul (the desire of God) onto the material pleasures of the outer world. Even though Augustine’s thinking is based on the Aristotelian concept of catharsis, the conclusions are entirely different – in Augustine’s opinion the aesthetical experience does not free the audience of its corporal appetites. Quite the contrary, the appetites get more intense. It should also be brought to the attention of the reader, that Augustine holds a certain hostility towards theatre and pagan literature as a pagan social practices. Augustine develops the thought of these Greek philosophers from the Christian point of view and bases his ethical critique of the aesthetic experience along with the critique of aesthetic practices on it. Moreover, he is more open to the concept of art as a fiction than Plato.


Related Articles

  • AESTHETIC DISTANCE. C.P.S. // New Princeton Encyclopedia of Poetry & Poetics;1993, p10 

    The article presents a definition of the term AESTHETIC DISTANCE, which describes the proper psychological relation of the viewer to the artwork, isolating what is unique to aesthetic, rather than cognitive or affective, experience. The meaning of the term shifts historically and according to...

  • Virtue, praise and success: Stoic reponses to Aristotle. Irwin, T.H. // Monist;Jan90, Vol. 73 Issue 1, p59 

    Discusses the attitudes and beliefs of ancient critics who have often argued that the Stoic moralists really have no substantive agreement with Aristotle concerning virtue, praise and success. How the sceptic Carneades viewed the Stoics; Stoic beliefs about virtue, happiness, good and evil;...

  • SOME SOURCES OF POLARIZED THINKING. Brooks, Allan Laurence // ETC: A Review of General Semantics;Fall94, Vol. 51 Issue 3, p261 

    Suggests that more direct, immediate and practical psychological factors contribute more to polar thinking than the intellectually-based influence of Aristotle. Non-polar thinking as offered prescriptively; Influence of the Aristotelian system on modes of teaching throughout history; Syndrome of...

  • Aristotle on God as thought thinking itself. De Koninck, Thomas // Review of Metaphysics;Mar94, Vol. 47 Issue 3, p471 

    Discusses Aristotle's concept on God's knowledge. Three types of virtual knowledge of many realities in one indivisible form; Aristotle's search for the absolute simplicity or indivisibility in God; God's immediate actual knowledge of all things; Imperfect as variably known through the perfect;...

  • On Aristotle's Notion of Existence. Hintikka, Jaakko // Review of Metaphysics;Jun99, Vol. 52 Issue 4, p779 

    Discusses the factors to consider in studying Aristotle's concept of existence. Inner tensions of his notions; His treatment of existence; Explanations and examples of syllogisms.

  • The articulation and hiearchy of knowledge in Aristotle's thought. Labarriere, Jean-Louis // Diogenes;1997, Vol. 45 Issue 178, p23 

    Examines Aristotle's endeavor, as it seems to embrace and order all of the elements of knowledge. Role of Aristotle in the classification of sciences; Function of various editions of Aristotle.

  • Why is virtue naturally pleasing? Jacobs, Jonathan // Review of Metaphysics;Sep95, Vol. 49 Issue 1, p21 

    Examines why virtues are naturally pleasing. Virtues as enactments or actualizations of what is good for us; Aristotle's Nicomachean Ethics and the De Anima; Manner of well-ordered activity of change; Natural and unnatural laws of causality; Pleasure for its own sake; Cognitive state of...

  • The Greek Menagerie. Lloyd, G.E.R. // Sciences;Jan82, Vol. 22 Issue 1, p10 

    Examines the zoological classifications of Aristotle. Aspects of animal behavior; Use of differences in human character, moral disposition and behavior in mapping differences between animals; Works of Aristotole on animal taxonomy.

  • Beyond friendship: Aristotle on conflict, deliberation, and attention. Bickford, Susan // Journal of Politics;May96, Vol. 58 Issue 2, p398 

    Presents a critique of Aristotle's political concept. Role of community and friendship in politics; Significance of deliberation; Conflict; Rhetoric and reason.


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics