Response to Orr and Siegler--collective intentionality and procreative desires: the permissible view on consent to posthumous conception

Parker, M.
August 2004
Journal of Medical Ethics;Aug2004, Vol. 30 Issue 4, p389
Academic Journal
Orr and Siegler have recently defended a restrictive view concerning posthumous sperm retrieval and conception, which would limit insemination to those cases where the deceased man has provided explicit consent for such a procedure. The restrictive view dominates current law and practice. A permissible view, in contrast, would allow insemination and conception in all but those cases where the posthumous procedure has been explicitly refused, or where there is no reasonable evidence that the deceased person desired children. I describe a phenomenology of procreative desires which supports the permissible view, and which is compatible with requirements concerning the interests of the decedent, concepts of medical infertility, and the welfare of the future child. The account illustrates how our current obsession with individual rights and autonomy can be self-defeating and repressive.


Related Articles

  • Zona Pellucida Induced Acrosome Reaction, Sperm Morphology, and Sperm-Zona Binding Assessments Among Subfertile Men. Bastiaan, H.S.; Menkveld, R.; Oehninger, S.; Franken, D.R. // Journal of Assisted Reproduction & Genetics;Jul2002, Vol. 19 Issue 7, p329 

    Examines the relationship between the zona pellucida induced acrosome reaction (ZIAR) and normal spermatozoa percentage. Information on the sperm-zona pellucida binding potential among men; Details on the intracytoplasmic sperm injections; Importance of ZIAR testing in fertility investigations.

  • Effects of Male Factors on Outcomes of Intrauterine Insemination. SU Ning; XIA Wei; WANG Wei; HE Yan; ZENG Yon -hua; HUANG Ting-ting; PENG Ya-ya // Journal of International Reproductive Health/Family Planning;Mar2014, Vol. 33 Issue 2, p110 

    Objective: To assess the effects of male factors on the clinical pregnancy rate of intrauterine insemination (IUI). Methods: The data of 472 IUI cycles from January 2012 to April 2013 in our center were retrospectively analyzed. These cycles were divided into three groups according to male age...

  • Effects of Main Semen Parameters on Intrauterian Insemination (IUI) Outcome. Aboutorabi, Roshanak; Dayani, Mahbobeh; Dastgerdi, Mehdi Nikbakht // Journal of Isfahan Medical School;Dec2010, Vol. 28 Issue 112, p1 

    Background: There are several techniques to manage sub fertility through which, Intrauterian Insemination (IUI) is on first step treatment strategy due to its simplicity and low costing and also being non invasive. The outcome of IUI is dependent on main semen parameters such as, sperm...

  • Sperm gene expression profile is related to pregnancy rate after insemination and is predictive of low fecundity in normozoospermic men. Bonache, Sandra; Mata, Ana; Ramos, María Dolores; Bassas, Lluís; Larriba, Sara // Human Reproduction;Jun2012, Vol. 27 Issue 6, p1556 

    BACKGROUND Assessment of male fertility is traditionally based on microscopic evaluation of semen. However, the classical semen parameters do not adequately reflect sperm function, and their clinical value in predicting fertility is limited. We hypothesize that the sperm expression profile could...

  • Other options for male infertility.  // GP: General Practitioner;4/8/2002, p64 

    Examines the role of intracytoplasmic sperm injection in the management of male infertility in Great Britain. Effectiveness of donor insemination on men with inherited disorder; Aim of the treatment to achieve the production of oocytes in conjunction with intrauterine insemination of prepared...

  • Successful pregnancy after intracytoplasmic sperm injection with testicular spermatozoa transported only under refrigeration. Inoue, Taketo; Sugimoto, Hironobu; Okubo, Kazutoshi; Emi, Nobuyuki; Matsushita, Yukiko; Kojima, Kenji; Nakamura, Mitsuaki; Ono, Yoshiyuki // Reproductive Medicine & Biology;Sep2010, Vol. 9 Issue 3, p173 

    Purpose: This case report describes two successful pregnancies after intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI) with testicular spermatozoa that were transported under refrigeration. Methods: Two first-time couples consulted our clinic concerned about their primary infertility. No sperm were...

  • Impct of Semen Characteristics on the Success of Intrauterine Insemination. Zhao, Yulian; Vlahos, Nikos; Wyncott, David; Petrella, Carolina; Garcia, Jairo; Zacur, Howard; Wallach, Edward E. // Journal of Assisted Reproduction & Genetics;May2004, Vol. 21 Issue 5, p143 

    Purpose: To evaluate the influence of sperm characteristics on the outcome of infertility treatment using intrauterine insemination (IUI). Methods: Retrospective study of 431 infertility couples who underwent 1007 IUI treatment cycles from June 1999 to October 2002. Sperm parameters before and...

  • Comparison of intrafollicular sperm injection and intrauterine insemination in the treatment of subfertility. Lucchini, Caterina; Volpe, Emanuele; Tocci, Angelo // Journal of Assisted Reproduction & Genetics;Oct2012, Vol. 29 Issue 10, p1103 

    Purpose: To compare the efficacy of intrafollicular sperm injection (IFI) versus intrauterine insemination (IUI) in the treatment of subfertility. Methods: 38 couples suffering primary or secondary subfertility contributed a total of 47 IUI or IFI cycles, 26 by IUI and 21 by IFI....

  • Double-Donor Cycles Offer No Benefit over Single IUI Cycles.  // Fertility Weekly;12/1/2014, p3 

    The article reports on a study by U.S. researchers, which found that double-donor sperm intrauterine insemination (IUI) does not increase clinical pregnancy rates compared with single-donor IUI. The study, which was carried out by researchers S.M. Zarek and colleagues, was aimed to compare...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics