Effect of patient socioeconomic status on perceptions of first- and second-year medical students

Woo, James K. H.; Ghorayeb, Sahar H.; Cheong K. Lee; Sangha, Harpreet; Richter, Suzanne
June 2004
CMAJ: Canadian Medical Association Journal;6/22/2004, Vol. 170 Issue 13, p1915
Academic Journal
Background: Physician decision-making and perceptions of patients are affected by a patient's socioeconomic status (SES). We sought to determine if the perceptions of first- and second-year medical students are similarly affected. We also wanted to determine whether a student's own SES affects his or her perceptions of patients from a low or high SES background. Methods: Two similar videos of a physician-patient interview were created. One video featured a patient of apparently high SES and the other featured a patient of apparently low SES. Differences in SES were portrayed by means of clothing, accessories and dialogue. First- and second-year medical students at the University of Western Ontario were recruited to view 1 of the videos and to answer a questionnaire using a 5-point Likert scale. Results: Responses were obtained from 205 (89%) of the 231 medical students invited to participate. Respondents' perceptions of the low SES and high SES patients were significantly different in the following respects. The low SES patient was perceived to be less compliant in taking medications and less likely to return for follow-up visits; was perceived to have a lower level of social support, poorer overall health and a worse prognosis; and was perceived to be more adversely affected in his occupational duties by illness ( p< 0.05). Furthermore, second-year students who watched the video with the low SES patient were less inclined to want that patient in their practice than second-year students who watched the video with the high SES patient ( p=0.032). One hundred and six students (52%) were categorized as having high SES and 37 (18%) as having low SES (the remaining students were categorized as having mid-level SES). Among students who watched the video with the low SES patient, the level of agreement with the statement "This person is the kind of patient I would like to have in my practice" was greater among low SES students than among high SES students...


Related Articles

  • Medical Students Aware of Daily Challenges of Physician Work Life.  // American Family Physician;5/1/2012, Vol. 85 Issue 9, p855 

    The article deals with a study which examines the medical students' perception of the work life of physicians, particularly those in primary care and suggests that students who had completed a family medicine clerkship have less tendency to consider time pressures as the reason for the failure...

  • My only patient in general practice. Barrett, James // BMJ: British Medical Journal (International Edition);07/12/97, Vol. 315 Issue 7100, p97 

    Recalls the experience of the author with a patient as a medical student under general practice. Physiologic state of patient; Favorable patient response upon administration of Naloxone injection.

  • Not Done Yet: Searching for the Limits of Patient Ownership As a Medical Student. Szuflita, Nicholas S. // Military Medicine;May2015, Vol. 180 Issue 5, p490 

    A personal narrative is presented which explores the author's recollection of losing his first patient as a medical student.

  • Medicine and the Media.  // British Medical Journal (Clinical Research Edition);6/1/1985, Vol. 290 Issue 6482, p1658 

    Examines the significance of communication between doctor and patient with severe illness. Skills of physician in delivering bad information to patient; Importance of counselling for the ill and dying patient on medical schools; Provision of educational aid for medical student.

  • Patients’ Perceptions on Their Involvement in Medical Education: A Qualitative Pilot Study. Iqbal, Saima Perwaiz // Journal of Academic Ethics;Dec2013, Vol. 11 Issue 4, p257 

    Patients’ perception with regards to their use in medical teaching is an under-researched area in Pakistan. The objective of this qualitative, pilot study was to determine the perspectives of hospital admitted patients on their being used in the medical education of students in a private...

  • Loss of examination status. Shalet, Stephen M // BMJ: British Medical Journal (International Edition);11/25/2000, Vol. 321 Issue 7272, p1344 

    Presents an account of a medical patient who experienced happiness due to the attention he received from medical students. The different maladies with which the patient was afflicted; Interactions of patients with medical students and teachers; Belief of the author that the patient died due to...

  • A Covenant Between Physician and Patient. Clouser, K. Danner // Annals of Internal Medicine;Dec85 Part 1, Vol. 103 Issue 6, p941 

    Offers a look at the covenant written by a 1985 class of medical school seniors for their baccalaureate service that encompasses mutual understanding and agreement between physician and patient. Objectives of the seniors for the baccalaureate service; Reason for calling the service baccalaureate.

  • What came first and what seems worse. Tunstall-Pedoe, Hugh // BMJ: British Medical Journal (International Edition);1/12/2002, Vol. 324 Issue 7329, p102 

    Focuses on a medical error in which an exchange student in the United States used the wrong tuberculin test on a patient, and how the error was admired by fellow doctors. How the reaction of the patient was thought to be of great diagnostic significance; Thoughts on telling a patient who had...

  • The unwritten curriculum. Lauer, Charles S. // Modern Healthcare;3/10/2008, Vol. 38 Issue 10, p50 

    The author reflects on the tendency by medical students in the U.S. to imitate the cynicism exhibited by older doctors and teachers. He cites the observation by Michael Wilkes, a professor of medicine at the University of California at Davis, that young medical students become increasingly...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics