Comparison of Conversation, Freeplay, and Story Generation as Methods of Language Sample Elicitation

Southwood, Frenette; Russell, Ann F.
April 2004
Journal of Speech, Language & Hearing Research;Apr2004, Vol. 47 Issue 2, p366
Academic Journal
The spontaneous language sample forms an important part of the language evaluation protocol (M. Dunn, J. Flax, M. Sliwinski, & D. Aram, 1996; J. L. Evans & H. K. Craig, 1992; L. E. Evans & J. Miller, 1999) because of the limitations of standardized language tests and their unavailability in certain languages, such as Afrikaans. This study examined 3 methods of language elicitation, namely conversation (CV), freeplay (FP), and story generation (SG), on the following 5 measures to determine which method is best for clinical practice: number of utterances, variety of syntactic structures, mean length of the utterance (MLU), number of syntactic errors, and proportion of complex syntactic utterances as elicited from ten 5-year-old, Afrikaans-speaking boys. FP elicited significantly more utterances than did SG but elicited a smaller proportion of complex syntactic structures than did CV and SG. Furthermore, SG elicited longer utterances than did CV or FP. It is recommended that SG be used in clinical practice with 5-year-olds if the clinician wishes to observe maximum behavior. Where typical behavior is to be evaluated, the clinician can select a language elicitation method that best suits the client's personality and communication style, bearing in mind that FP does elicit a larger language sample.


Related Articles

  • Der Einsatz von standardisierten Tests in der Logopädie. Beushausen, Ulla // Forum Logopadie;jan2008, Vol. 22 Issue 1, p6 

    The use of standardized tests in speech and language therapy and pathology. The diagnosis of communication disorders is based on a range of standardized and norm-referenced tests. Criteria for quality in tests are defined (objectivity, reliability, validity) and selection criteria for an...

  • Task Variability Effects on the Language Test Performance of Southern Lower Socioeconomic Class African American and Caucasian Five-Year-Olds. Fagundes, Deana D.; Haynes, William O.; Haak, Nancy J.; Moran, Michael J. // Language, Speech & Hearing Services in Schools;Jul98, Vol. 29 Issue 3, p148 

    Discusses the clinical implications of considering task effects and dynamic assessment in multicultural assessment. Disadvantages of standardized testing; Identification of the typical types of bias on standardized tests; Benefits of statistical models; Focus of the preschool language assessment...

  • Thirty Thousand Take Spanish Exam.  // Language Magazine;Jun2009, Vol. 8 Issue 10, p15 

    The article reports on the exams to receive the Diploma de Español como Lengua Extranjera (DELE) supervised by the Instituto Cervantes on May 15 and 16, 2009. It states that approximately 30,000 candidates worldwide took the exams in over 600 centers in 108 countries. It notes that tests for...

  • It's How You Ask That Counts. Greene, Amy H.; Melton, Glennon Doyle // Language Magazine;Sep2007, Vol. 7 Issue 1, p24 

    The article discusses on the significance of language testing instruction to improve the proficiency of students in the English language. It was stressed that by identifying and attacking particular challenges in standardized sets, one particular group was able to develop an innovative and...

  • Semantic connection or visual connection: Investigating the true source of confusion. Ishii, Tomoko // Language Teaching Research;Nov2015, Vol. 19 Issue 6, p712 

    It has been repeatedly argued among vocabulary researchers that semantically related words should not be taught simultaneously because they can interfere with each other. However, the question of what types of relatedness cause interference has rarely been examined carefully. In addition, there...

  • Testing Leaders, Publishers Offer 'Best Practices' Guide. Gewertz, Catherine // Education Week;8/11/2010, Vol. 29 Issue 37, p14 

    The article discusses a best practices manual about statewide educational testing that was created by the Council of Chief State School Officers and the Association of Test Publishers.

  • THE SPEECH OF FIVE HUNDRED FRESHMAN COLLEGE WOMEN. Stinchfield, Sara M. // Journal of Applied Psychology;Apr25, Vol. 9 Issue 2, p109 

    The article discusses the issue on standardized tests in voice and speech given to all entering students in college. The tests aims to classify students for training. Students with speech handicap and personality difficulties may be selected for training in small groups or individually. Students...

  • Are teachers teaching to the test? A case study of the College English Test (CET) in China. Hongli Li // International Journal of Pedagogies & Learning;Jul2009, Vol. 5 Issue 1, p25 

    The College English Test (CET) in China is a high-stakes standardized test to assess college students' English ability. One frequent claim against this test is that teachers may teach to the test, which could narrow the curriculum and turn regular English classes into CET coaching. This study...

  • The Ups and Downs of 3rd Grade. Felton, Kelsey Augst; Akos, Patrick // Educational Leadership;Apr2011, Vol. 68 Issue 7, p28 

    The article addresses the anxieties felt by many third graders in U.S. education. It focuses on increased academic demands in the third grade, emphasizing anxiety caused by end-of-grade (EOG) exams. Other aspects of third grade curricula are addressed including independent reading, core content...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics