Narrative as Argument in Indian Philosophy: The Astāvakra Gītā as Multivalent Narrative

Stroud, Scott R.
February 2004
Philosophy & Rhetoric;2004, Vol. 37 Issue 1, p42
Academic Journal
This study explores the ways in which the text of Indian narrative "Astāvakra Gītā" argues its philosophical positions to its audience of potential pupils. This audience can be a Western or non-Indian one, or even a non-Vedantic Indian audience. The point of Vedantic texts in the narrative is to convert or enlighten whoever is reading it. This conversion must be done, in many cases, through recourse to experiential multivariate narrative (EMN) texts and their use of experiential measures. Prevalent Western notions of argument as logically rigorous and as consisting of clearly labeled conclusions and premises must be transcended if the argumentative tactics of Eastern narratives, such as the Astāvakra Gītā, are to be appreciated. They simply cannot rely on discursive thought and argumentative use of language to convey a truth that is beyond truth and falsity, beyond reality and unreality, and beyond duality and non-duality. Of course, many treatises and texts in Indian philosophy are quite analytical and discursive in their argument, but a significant portion takes the form of dialogue and story, using narrative in an interesting but argumentative fashion. These texts can and do argue. The Astāvakra Gītā , an excellent example of an EMN, is not arguing for an explicit conclusion. Instead, it is useful to see it as arguing for the experience of a certain type of transcendental disposition. While the mere reading of this text may not transform one into a fully enlightened individual, the microstructure of enlightenment can be felt by the process of truly interacting with this text.


Related Articles

  • Historicizing Unreliable Narration: Unreliability and Cultural Discourse in Narrative Fiction. Zerweck, Bruno // Style;Spring2001, Vol. 35 Issue 1, p151 

    Focuses on a study which argued the cultural-narratological theory of unreliable narration in literary studies. Discussion of the cognitive turn in the theory of unreliable narration; Minimal conditions and the cultural-historical dependencies of unreliable narration.

  • Recent Studies in Narratology. Mosher Jr., Harold F. // Papers on Language & Literature;Winter81, Vol. 17 Issue 1, p88 

    Focuses on the proliferation of general structuralist theories of narrative from the 1970s to the 1980s. Concept of narratology; Primary division into first-person and third-person narration; Distinction between narration and quoted monologue.

  • The Disnarrated. Prince, Gerald // Style;Spring88, Vol. 22 Issue 1, p1 

    This article focuses on those passages in a narrative that consider what did not or does not take place. It can fulfill a number of functions, the most important of which is a rhetorical/interpretive one. When it pertains to the narrating rather than the narrated, it emphasizes the realities of...

  • ProstÅ™edky autentizace v současném českém románu. Šanda, Zdenēk // Rijec (Word);2008, Vol. 14 Issue 1, p215 

    The paper deals with the category of authenticity in a literary work from two points of view: 1) It offers its theoretical delimitation as a characteristic of a fiction world. This is based on "possible worlds theory" in logical semantics presented by Lubomír Doležel's conception; 2) It...

  • 'The profound poverty of knowledge.'. Duncan, Isla // Canadian Literature;Summer2001, Issue 169, p85 

    Comments on the book `The Two Headed Calf,' a collection of narratives written by Sandra Birdsell. Structure of the narratives; Theme of the novel; Choice of words used in the novel.

  • La Colección Pineda: acopiar gacetas, conservar el pasado y divulgar sus glorias. CARDONA ZULUAGA, ALBA PATRICIA // Historia Caribe;ene-jun2013, Vol. 8 Issue 22, p105 

    This paper analyzes a material dimension of Modern History, i. e. collections and their importance in conservation and divulgation of the pieces upon which the narration of the national past should rest. The “Colección Pineda” allows us to inquire into issues related to the...

  • Resistance written and imaged: The distancing visual narrative of Ornela Vorpsi. Alù, Giorgia // Journal of Romance Studies;Spring2014, Vol. 14 Issue 1, p1 

    This article explores the visual narrative of the Albanian Italophone writer Ornela Vorpsi. By drawing evidence from her short novels, Il paese dove non si muore mai and La mano che non mordi, and from her collection of short stories entitled Vetri rosa, this article intends to cast light on how...

  • Discourse management. Azar, Zeynep; Özyürek, Aslı // Dutch Journal of Applied Linguistics;2015, Vol. 4 Issue 2, p222 

    Speakers achieve coherence in discourse by alternating between differential lexical forms e.g. noun phrase, pronoun, and null form in accordance with the accessibility of the entities they refer to, i.e. whether they introduce an entity into discourse for the first time or continue referring to...

  • Fuzzy Memories: Why Narrators forget they translate for Animals. Hague, Daryl R. // Translation & Literature;Autumn2007, Vol. 16 Issue 2, p178 

    The author focuses on the role of the narrator as translator in a work of literature. According to the author, narrators in some texts provide translations of animal language without acknowledging their status as translations, which can lead to "amnesia" on the part of the narrator, who has...

  • DERIVATION.  // Columbia Dictionary of Modern Literary & Cultural Criticism;1995, p77 

    A definition of the term "derivation" is presented. Under the theory of textual production of Michael Riffaterre, texts are derivations from givens or hypograms. Thus, a word or phrase my be used to generate the whole texts. Any number of narratives may be produced through changing the variable...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics