Corporatisation and the Emergence of (Under-Managered) Managed Organisations: The Case of English Public Hospitals

Kirkpatrick, Ian; Altanlar, Ali; Veronesi, Gianluca
December 2017
Organization Studies (01708406);Dec2017, Vol. 38 Issue 12, p1687
Academic Journal
An enduring feature of New Public Management in many countries has been the move to create more autonomous, ‘complete’ organisations such as universities, hospitals and social service agencies. Often referred to as ‘corporatisation’, this process is assumed to be leading to the emergence of new organisational forms with dedicated management functions and a greater focus on strategy. However, these assumptions remain largely untested and rely heavily on ‘technical’ accounts of organisational re-structuring, ignoring the potential influence of institutional pressures and internal political dynamics. In this paper, we address this concern focusing on the case of acute care public hospitals that have undergone corporatisation (to become Foundation Trusts) in the English National Health Service. Using administrative data spanning six years (2007–2012), the analysis shows that corporatisation is having mixed effects. While it is associated with a shift in the focus of managers to strategic concerns, it has not led to an expansion of management functions overall. Both tendencies are found to be mediated by institutional pressures, in the form of media scrutiny, and, indirectly, by the involvement of clinical professions in management. These results advance ongoing debates about the emergence of new organisational forms in the public sector, highlighting the limitations of technical accounts of change and raising the possibility that corporatisation is leading to organisations that are both more managed and under-managered at the same time.


Related Articles

  • More Similar Than You Might Think. Kamensky, John // PA Times;Aug2007, Vol. 30 Issue 8, p8 

    The article presents views and insights of the author concerning his observations to corporate executives that have special relevance to the public sector. He notes that companies collect and report measures for a variety of purposes. He added that a lack of concentrated measurement leadership...

  • New public management. Marchewka-Bartkowiak, Kamilla // Infos;10/9/2014, Vol. 178 Issue 18, p1 

    The article presents brief information on the new public management (NPM) which defines methods of management aimed to modernise and render the public sector more efficient, and highlights characteristics and development of the new public management.

  • Effects of Privatization on Economic Performance in Pakistan. Mehmood, Khawaja Asif; Faridi, Muhammad Zahir // Middle East Journal of Scientific Research;10/17/2013, Vol. 16 Issue 5, p729 

    Privatization is an initiative that is finalized upon the selling- off of the State Owned Enterprises (SOEs). It is also felt when the Government of a certain country is to contract out the State Services. Pakistan as a developing country of the world, enjoys a pride of its geographical...

  • Advances and Challenges for Adoption of Activity Based Costing (ABC) by Public Sector: A Comparative Study of Brazil, Colombia, Uruguay and United States. Carmo, Luís Paulo F.; Padovani, Fernando // International Business Research;Feb2012, Vol. 5 Issue 2, p150 

    This article aims to evaluate the advances and challenges to the adoption of the activity based costing system (ABC) by the public sector of countries like Colombia, Uruguay and Brazil, always keeping a comparative perspective with the historical experience of the United States. Considering the...

  • STORYTELLING FOR THE MASSES: A RHETORICAL APPROACH TO PUBLIC SECTOR TRANSFORMATIONS IN LITHUANIA. ZIDONIS, Zilvinas; JASKUNAITE, Neringa // Scientific Annals of the 'Alexandru Ioan Cuza' University of Ias;2013, Vol. 60 Issue 2, p399 

    This paper aims to shed new light on the "old-fashioned" concept of New Public Management from the perspective of rhetorical managerial activities. The role of rhetoric and narratives in governance, management and philosophy of science is discussed. Second, it is showed how and why post-modern...

  • Knowledge Management Implementation in UK Public Sector. Moffet, Sandra // Proceedings of the European Conference on Knowledge Management;2014, Vol. 2, p676 

    History shows that most management philosophies were first practiced in the large company (McAdam and Reid 2000) and once they gained acceptance were adopted in other sectors, including government. Programs such as those associated with New Public Management (NPM) suggest that public...

  • CONSIDERACIONES SOBRE LA NUEVA GESTIÓN PÚBLICA EN MÉXICO DURANTE EL SEXENIO FOXISTA. Moreno, María Guadalupe Huerta; Diez, María Teresa Magallón // Gestión y Estrategia;ene-jun2009, Issue 35, p63 

    A central part of the structural reforms is linked, in one hand, to State role redefinition in economy, reducing Public business activities and its role in distribution sphere, and in the other hand, the application of negotiating forms that they seek to be rational, in terms of resources...

  • Old and New Organizational Cages. What about Autonomy and Freedom? Bifulco, Lavinia // Public Organization Review;Sep2011, Vol. 11 Issue 3, p283 

    The discourses on the so-called 'post-bureaucracy' emphasizes the importance of autonomy and freedom in present-day organizations. Yet, differently to the discourses, the practices are not univocal and there is a mix of continuity and transformation to be investigated. The article addresses...

  • La décentralisation des négociations dans le secteur de la santé et des services sociaux québécois : qu'en disent les gestionnaires locaux ? Bolduc, François // Relations Industrielles / Industrial Relations;Winter2015, Vol. 70 Issue 1, p110 

    This article focuses on local bargaining that took place in the Quebec health and social services network between 2005 and 2008 following implementation of the Act respecting bargaining units in the social affairs sector and amending the Act respecting the process of negotiation of the...

  • Accountability and value for money: a theoretical framework for the relationship in public-private partnerships. Demirag, Istemi; Khadaroo, Iqbal // Journal of Management & Governance;May2011, Vol. 15 Issue 2, p271 

    There is an implicit assumption in the UK Treasury's publications on public-private partnerships (PPP)-also more commonly known in the United Kingdom as private finance initiative (PFI)-that accountability and value for money (VFM) are related concepts. While recent academic studies on PPP/PFI...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics