Fighting over food unites the birds of North America in a continental dominance hierarchy

Miller, Eliot T.; Bonter, David N.; Eldermire, Charles; Freeman, Benjamin G.; Greig, Emma I.; Harmon, Luke J.; Lisle, Curtis; Hochachka, Wesley M.
November 2017
Behavioral Ecology;Nov/Dec2017, Vol. 28 Issue 6, p1454
Academic Journal
Members of different species often engage in aggressive contests over resources. This series of aggressive contests between species may result in an interspecific dominance hierarchy. Such hierarchies are of interest because they could be used to address a variety of research questions, for example, do similarly ranked species tend to avoid each other in time or space, and what will happen when such species come into contact as climates change? Here, we propose a method for creating a continental-scale hierarchy, and we make initial analyses based on this hierarchy. Leveraging the existing network of citizen scientists from Project FeederWatch, we collected the data with which to create a continent-spanning interspecific dominance hierarchy that included species that do not currently have overlapping geographic distributions. We quantified the extent of intransitivities (rock-paper-scissors relationships) in the hierarchy, as intransitivities can promote local species' coexistence. Overall, the hierarchy was nearly linear, and largely predicted by body mass, although there were clade-specific deviations from the average mass-dominance relationship. Warblers and orioles, for instance, were more dominant than expected based on their body mass, while buntings, grosbeaks, and doves were less dominant than expected. Intransitive relationships were rare. Few interactions were reported between close relatives and ecological competitors like Mountain and Black-capped Chickadees, as such species often have only marginally overlapping geographic distributions, restricting opportunity for observation. Yet, these species' ranks--emergent properties of the network--were often in agreement with targeted studies of dominance relationships between them.


Related Articles

  • FRINGILLIDS.  // Handbook of California Birds;1986, p195 

    The article describes various kinds of cardinal, grosbeaks and lazuli bunting in California. These belong to the family Fringillidae and have short conical stout bills for breaking seeds and nuts. These include the cardinal, black-headed grosbeak, evening grosbeak, blue grosbeak, and lazuli...

  • No Matter Where You Live. Thauberger, Randy // Gardens West;Jul/Aug2008, Vol. 22 Issue 6, p34 

    The article focuses on the lazuli bunting, a bird specie that can be seen in Okanagan Valley, British Columbia. Descriptions of the physical characteristics of both male and female lazuli buntings, the song of the male, the feeding habits of lazuli buntings, and their nesting practices are...

  • Northern cardinal.  // Encyclopedia of Animals;8/1/2017, p1 

    One of the more familiar garden and songbirds of North America is the cardinal. Its name comes from the males' bright-red plumage which is similar to the red robes worn by cardinals in the Roman Catholic Church. The female cardinals have yellowish-brown plumage with red on their crests, tails,...

  • Bunting and tanager.  // Encyclopedia of Animals;8/1/2017, p1 

    This family includes many brightly-colored and familiar species, as well as some about which very little is known. They eat a variety of fruits, insects, and seeds. Species in this family divide into five different groups called subfamilies. Member species occupy diverse habitats worldwide.

  • PRESQUE ISLE COUNTY, MICHIGAN. MCCORMAC, JIM // Bird Watcher's Digest;Jan/Feb2011, Vol. 33 Issue 3, p84 

    The article features the birds at the Presque Isle County in Michigan. It recalls the author's experience of traveling to NettieBay Lodge to head a bird-watching workshop where he saw a lake and birds like osprey, pine warblers, purple finches, rose-breasted grosbeaks, and yellow-bellied...

  • Gallery.  // Birder's World;Apr2002, Vol. 16 Issue 2, p78 

    Presents pictures of different species of birds. Black-chinned Hummingbird; Rose-breasted Grosbeak; Baltimore Oriole; Killdeer; American Kestrel.

  • Memoirs of a Trucker. Thauberger, Randy // Gardens West;Oct2010, Vol. 24 Issue 8, p60 

    The article shares the author's encounters with grosbeaks while travelling as a trucker with his mythical travelling buddy, the Animal. These birds are described as chunky, short-tailed and heavy-billed. It adds that they have yellow wing-linings with white patches, have a "roller coaster" style...

  • Chapter 6: Nectar Feeders. Spaulding, Dean T. // Feeding Our Feathered Friends;1997, p42 

    Nectar is sweet liquid from fruits and flowers. There are various nectar feeders that will have birds coming back for more. Orioles love nectars especially from oranges. Materials like plastic six-pack soda, pop rings, small orange are used to make the Six-Pack Oriole Feeder. Hummingbirds are...

  • Isolation of Salmonella Typhimurium from pigeons ( Columba livia) in Greater Guwahati, its histopathological impact and antibiogram. Dutta, Pankaj; Borah, Manoj; Sarmah, Ratul; Gangil, Rakhi // Comparative Clinical Pathology;Feb2013, Vol. 22 Issue 1, p147 

    No abstract available.

  • Wood Warblers. Armstrong, Robert H. // Guide to the Birds of Alaska;1995, p258 

    The article presents information on Wood Warblers. They are small, active birds that feed mostly on insects. They have small, thin bills. In Alaska, most of them have varying degrees of yellow plumage. In spring and summer, the male has bright, flashy breeding plumage, while the female plumage...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics