TITLE

On the consistency of choice

AUTHOR(S)
Mahmoud, Ola
PUB. DATE
December 2017
SOURCE
Theory & Decision;Dec2017, Vol. 83 Issue 4, p547
SOURCE TYPE
Academic Journal
DOC. TYPE
Article
ABSTRACT
Consistency of choice is a fundamental and recurring theme in decision theory, social choice theory, behavioral economics, and psychological sciences. The purpose of this paper is to study the consistency of choice independent of the particular decision model at hand. Consistency is viewed as an inherently logical concept that is fundamentally void of connotation and is thus disentangled from traditional rationality or consistency conditions imposed on decision models. The proposed formalization of consistency takes two forms: internal consistency, which refers to the property that a choice model does not generate contradictory statements; and semantic consistency, which refers to the idea that a theory's predictions are valid with respect to some observed data. In addressing semantic consistency, the relationship between theory and data is analyzed in terms of so-called duality mappings, which allow a passage between the two universes in a way that consistency is preserved. The formalization of consistency concepts relies on adapting the revealed preference theory to the context-dependent setting. The paper concludes by discussing the implications of the proposed framework and how it relates to classical revealed preference theory and other formalizations of the relationship between the theory and reality of choice.
ACCESSION #
126260805

 

Related Articles

  • Applying the Strategic Choice Model to Motivational Appeals: A Theoretical Approach. Shelby, Annette N. // Journal of Business Communication;Summer91, Vol. 28 Issue 3, p187 

    The strategic choice model, which suggests that choice is dependent on communication goal and probable recover response, is applied to motivational options useful in constructing persuasive messages. Specific options are identified according to power-based, nonpower-based, and shared power-based...

  • On preference imprecision. Cubitt, Robin; Navarro-Martinez, Daniel; Starmer, Chris // Journal of Risk & Uncertainty;Feb2015, Vol. 50 Issue 1, p1 

    Recent research invokes preference imprecision to explain violations of individual decision theory. While these inquiries are suggestive, the nature and significance of such imprecision remain poorly understood. We explore three questions using a new measurement tool in an experimental...

  • Disquotation and Consistency: a Reply to Frances. Moore, Joseph G. // Mind;Jul2000, Vol. 109 Issue 435, p527 

    Comments on the Millian's position about the semantic role of proper names. Violation of Consistency in the Millian view; Attribution of contradictory beliefs and propositional attitudes; 'Cartesian' conception of belief and belief reporting practice.

  • Learning at any rate: action-effect learning for stimulus-based actions. Pfister, Roland; Kiesel, Andrea; Hoffmann, Joachim // Psychological Research;Jan2011, Vol. 75 Issue 1, p61 

    Recent studies reported converging evidence for action-effect associations if participants adopted an intention-based action control mode in free choice conditions, whereas no evidence for action-effect associations was found when participants adopted a stimulus-based mode in forced choice...

  • Variety really is the spice of life. Buchanan, Mark // New Scientist;8/21/2004, Vol. 183 Issue 2461, p16 

    According to the philosopher Ralph Waldo Emerson, "a foolish consistency is the hobgoblin of little minds." Now, mathematicians have proved him right by showing that inconsistency has its benefits—for example, in making people more knowledgeable or leading to a more balanced diet....

  • A New Solution to Moore's Paradox. Gillies, Anthony S. // Philosophical Studies;Sep2001, Vol. 105 Issue 3, p237 

    Moore's paradox pits our intuitions about semantic oddness against the concept of truth-functional consistency. Most solutions to the problem proceed by explaining away our intuitions. But ``consistency'' is a theory-laden concept, having different contours in different semantic theories....

  • A New Solution to Moore's Paradox. Gillies, Anthony S. // Philosophical Studies;Sep2001, Vol. 105 Issue 3, p237 

    Moore's paradox pits our intuitions about semantic oddness against the concept of truth-functional consistency. Most solutions to the problem proceed by explaining away our intuitions. But ``consistency'' is a theory-laden concept, having different contours in different semantic theories....

  • THE X OF X. Churchman, C. West // Management Science;Apr1963, Vol. 9 Issue 3, p351 

    The article examines the philosophy and the factors that influence decision-making in management. The author presents the philosophical issues that accompany the concept of a "unified science of management" and the discipline of logic. The question of how any system can tell itself that it is...

  • Some implicatures reveal semantic differences. Banga, Arina; Heutinck, Ingeborg; Berends, Sanne M.; Hendriks, Petra // Linguistics in the Netherlands;2009, Vol. 26 Issue 1, p1 

    The article presents experiments which investigate the ability of adults and children to compute scalar implicatures in the Netherlands. It examines the influence of scalar terms' working memory capacity and semantic properties on scalar implicatures computation. Experiments reveal that children...

  • Stimulus-response compatibility as a function of stimulus code and response modality. Wang, Huifang; Proctor, Robert W. // Journal of Experimental Psychology. Human Perception & Performan;Oct96, Vol. 22 Issue 5, p1201 

    Examines differentiations of stimulus-response compatibility for set- and element-level compatibility. Relationship between set- and element-level compatibility effects; Evaluation of relationship between stimulus and response modality; Compatibility between spatial-manual and verbal-vocal...

Share

Read the Article

Courtesy of THE LIBRARY OF VIRGINIA

Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics