HUMANITY'S SUBTENSIONS: Culture Theory in US Death Penalty Mitigation

Cheng, Jesse
September 2017
Social Analysis;Autumn2017, Vol. 61 Issue 3, p73
Academic Journal
Criminal law in the United States values conceptual definitiveness in its quest for resolution. But the work of open-ended humanization required of sentencing mitigation advocates in American death penalty cases defies this call for definitiveness. Even as formal legal processes seek to limit the knowledge that can be brought into the courtroom, new theoretical approaches that justify more understanding and fact-finding can help attain tangible goals of defense advocacy. This article provides an ethnographic account of how capital defense practitioners in the United States engage with anthropological theories of culture as a behind-the-scenes advocacy strategy that succeeds by exploiting the anti-definitiveness inherent in culture. I develop the concept of 'subtension' as an analytical trope to help elucidate these processes.


Related Articles

  • PROVOKING CHANGE: COMPARATIVE INSIGHTS ON FEMINIST HOMICIDE LAW REFORM. RAMSEY, CAROLYN B. // Journal of Criminal Law & Criminology;Winter2010, Vol. 100 Issue 1, p33 

    The provocation defense, which mitigates murder to manslaughter for killings perpetrated in the heat of passion, is one of the most controversial doctrines in the criminal law because of its perceived gender bias; yet most American scholars and lawmakers have not recommended that it be...

  • THE PSYCHOLOGY OF CAPITAL PUNISHMENT. Murphy, Sheila M. // Indiana Law Journal;Winter2005, Vol. 80 Issue 1, p41 

    Presents views on the planned enactment of death penalty in Massachusetts. Reason for disfavoring the proposal; Classes of persons who are sentenced to death in areas outside the state; Disagreement to the essentiality of mitigation specialists.

  • CAUZELE MODIFICATOARE DE PEDEAPSA. CONTROVERSE. Mihaila, Diana // Romanian Penal Law Review;ian-mar2012, Vol. 19 Issue 1, p130 

    The author analyzes the modifying causes of the sentence, namely the states of aggravation and mitigation, also aggravating and mitigating circumstances, stressing their role in individualizing the penalty.

  • Epilepsy and homicide: Issac Ray on mitigation. Weiss, Kenneth J. // Journal of Psychiatry & Law;Summer2008, Vol. 36 Issue 2, p171 

    In 1867, a gruesome murder stunned Philadelphia. The suspect, George Winnemore, a spiritualist with epilepsy and depression, knew the victim, a 63-year-old woman. With little time to prepare, his counsel claimed Winnemore did not commit the act; but if he did, he was insane, the product of...

  • Mitigating Circumstances in the Current and the New Criminal Code. Comparative Examination. TUTUNARU, Mircea // Acta Universitatis Danubius: Juridica;2013, Vol. 9 Issue 3, p81 

    By using the word "public", the Criminal Law refers to all public authorities and institutions and also to all legal entities of public law. Particular attention is paid to the public function and to its holder- the civil servant. It also provides the conditions that a person has to meet in...

  • The capital punishment in the United States: the trend towards abolition. Lepyoshkina, O. I. // Russian Juridical Journal / Rossijskij Juridiceskij Zurnal;2015, Vol. 100 Issue 1, p251 

    The author considers the history of the capital punishment in the USA and its present state. Since 2000, in the United States both enforcement and execution of the capital punishment have been reducing. For instance, in 2005, the US Supreme Court has enacted a ban on enforcement of the capital...

  • The Cycle of Death. Beiser, Vince // Pacific Standard;May/Jun2012, Vol. 5 Issue 3, p18 

    The article discusses the outlook for death penalty in the U.S. According to the article, over the years the debates for and against the death penalty ranged from the immorality and unconstitutionality of executions, increasing criminality and the fallibility of the system imposing it. However,...

  • Point: Crime or Punishment? The Argument Against Capital Punishment. Witherbee, Amy // Points of View: Death Penalty;6/30/2019, p5 

    This article presents an argument against capital punishment. The development of DNA evidence has brought about a deluge of cases throughout the country in which people convicted of crimes are later proven innocent. Among these are 111 death row inmates who, since 1973, were released from prison...

  • Bill would give Carlsbad piece of mitigation fees.  // San Diego Business Journal;4/22/96, Vol. 17 Issue 17, p30 

    Reports that in California, under Assembly Bill-2659, the city of Carlsbad would earn interest on mitigation fees collected for development of agricultural property. Who wrote the bill; Bill to be considered by the Appropriations Committee; Provisions of the bill; Total amount of Carlsbad's...

  • MITIGATION AND THE AMERICANS WITH DISABILITIES ACT. Hasday, Jill Elaine // Michigan Law Review;Nov2004, Vol. 103 Issue 2, p217 

    Explores issues concerning mitigation and the Title I of the Americans With Disabilities Act (ADA). Definition of disability in the ADA; Explanation on the duty of reasonable mitigation; Information on the legal rights of mitigators in light of the proposed duty of reasonable mitigation.


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics