Surgical research revisited: clinical trials in the cardiothoracic surgical literature

Anyanwu, Ani C.; Treasure, Tom
March 2004
European Journal of Cardio-Thoracic Surgery;Mar2004, Vol. 25 Issue 3, p299
Academic Journal
Objective: Surgeons have been criticised for not undertaking high-quality research. This study examines the quality of randomised controlled trials (RCTs) in the cardiothoracic surgical literature with a view to revisiting the role of RCTs in surgical research. Methods: All RCTs published in 1998 and 1999 in three major international cardiothoracic journals were analysed for basic components of trial design and presentation. Results: We found 119 papers presented as RCTs. The median size of treatment arms per RCT was 20 (interquartile range 14–40). Of 20 dimensions of trial quality examined, 12 or more were deficient (not described or performed inadequately) in half of the studies. Key information was frequently missing. Additionally, most trials relied on ‘soft’ endpoints, using surrogate (72, 61%) rather than clinical, and numerical (102, 86%) rather than categorical outcomes suggesting lack of power to detect clinically relevant differences. Although most trials reported positive results (73, 63%), only in 18 (15%) did authors make recommendations for practice change. Conclusions: Many RCTs in surgery by virtue of their design, sample size, and insufficient power are incapable of answering the questions researchers seek to address. Surgical trials often may not exclude bias because of lack of blinding and variations in surgical technique and performance. It is arguable that for most study questions in clinical surgery, comparative analysis of large case series and databases will provide more robust evidence.


Related Articles

  • The new CONSORT statement. Antes, Gerd // BMJ: British Medical Journal (Overseas & Retired Doctors Edition;3/27/2010, Vol. 340 Issue 7748, p666 

    The author supports the 2010 update of the CONSORT statement. The statement, issued in 1996, offered suggestions for the publication of randomized controlled clinical trials, the standard to assess healthcare interventions. The findings of a comparative study by S. Hopewell and colleagues are...

  • Poster 15: A Successful Short- and Long-Term Recruiting Strategy for Huntington Clinical Trials: A Community Effort Goodman, L.; Carnes, R.; Giuliano, J.; Vetter, L. // Neurotherapeutics;Jan2010, Vol. 7 Issue 1, p142 

    Objective: To determine short- and long-term effects on recruitment rates following community-delivered education sessions within a cohort of Huntington disease (HD) support group members in the Pacific Northwest. Background: There has been no systematic measure or comparison of methods utilized...

  • Victoria simplifies clinical trial approval process.  // Australian Life Scientist;10/28/2009, p1 

    Ethical reviews for multi-site trials will only require a single approval.

  • Evidence supporting platform-switching to preserve marginal bone levels not definitive. Stafford, Gary L // Evidence-Based Dentistry;Jun2012, Vol. 13 Issue 2, p56 

    Data sourcesMEDLINE, EMBASE, The Cochrane Oral Health Group's Trials Register, The Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials (CENTRAL), UK National Research Register, Australian New Zealand Clinical Trials Registry (ANZCTR), Database of Abstracts of Reviews of Effectiveness (DARE), ISI...

  • How to Deal with Cost Differences at Baseline. van Asselt, Antoinette D. I.; van Mastrigt, Ghislaine A. P. G.; Carmen D. Dirksen; Arntz, Arnoud; Severens, Johan L.; Kessels, Alfons G. H. // PharmacoEconomics;2009, Vol. 27 Issue 6, p519 

    Background: To our knowledge, adjustment for baseline imbalances in costs has never been performed in trial-based cost-effectiveness analyses. Methods: We used data from a clinical trial performed in the Netherlands comparing two outpatient psychotherapies: schema-focused therapy (SFT) versus...

  • Editorial on hypothesis and objectives in clinical trials: superiority, equivalence and non-inferiority. Gonzalez, Claudio D.; Bolaños, Ricardo; de Sereday, Martha // Thrombosis Journal;2009, Vol. 7, p1 

    The article focuses on various issues related to hypothesis and objectives in clinical trials. It states that the majority of clinical trials are aimed to establish the superiority of an intervention regarding to an active control or placebo. Usually, the aim of a clinical trial is to show that...

  • The effect of platelet derived growth factor-AB on periodontal ligament fibroblasts: An in vitro study. Manoranjan, S. J.; Faizuddin, Mohamed; Hemalatha, M.; Ranganath, V. // Journal of Indian Society of Periodontology;Jan-Mar2012, Vol. 16 Issue 1, p49 

    Background and Objectives: Traditional methods of periodontal therapy produce results in healing of tissues by repair; however, what we require is regeneration of the lost tissues. The periodontal ligament (PDL) cells appear to be important in periodontal wound healing. Platelet derived growth...

  • Assessment of methodological quality of primary studies by systematic reviews: results of the metaquality study cross sectional study. Moja, Lorenzo P.; Telaro, Elena; D'Amico, Roberto; Moschetti, Ivan; Coe, Laura; Liberati, Alessandro // BMJ: British Medical Journal (International Edition);5/7/2005, Vol. 330 Issue 7499, p1053 

    Objectives To describe how the methodological quality of primary studies is assessed in systematic reviews and whether the quality assessment is taken into account in the interpretation of results. Data sources Cochrane systematic reviews and systematic reviews in paper based journals. Study...

  • Malaria: Joint attack on malaria. Ellis, Clare // Nature Reviews Microbiology;Sep2004, Vol. 2 Issue 9, p689 

    The article reports on the success of the study conducted by a group of international scientists that to develop a new antimalarial drug. The team, that is consists of researchers from universities and medical-related institutions worldwide, aims to identify a new synthetic peroxide antimalarial...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics