Dimensions That Make a Difference: Examining the Impact of In-Role and Extrarole Behaviors on Supervisory Ratings

Werner, Jon M.
February 1994
Journal of Applied Psychology;Feb94, Vol. 79 Issue 1, p98
Academic Journal
Levels of in-role and extrarole performance were experimentally manipulated in a 3 × 2 within-subjects design. Dimensions capturing both in-role and extrarole behaviors (i.e., citizenship behaviors directed toward other individuals) strongly influenced various measures of rater search strategies as well as the ratings given by 116 supervisors evaluating secretarial performance. Furthermore, as predicted by D. W. Organ (1990), dimension ratings assigned to ratees with high levels of extrarole behavior displayed significantly more halo than ratings given to ratees with neutral levels of extrarole behavior. Tests for the effects of level of extrarole behavior on 2 measures of rater accuracy produced contradictory results. Implications are discussed.


Related Articles

  • Supervision: from me to we. Leach, Rona // Supervision;Feb2000, Vol. 61 Issue 2, p8 

    Discusses the role and function of a supervisor. Importance of team work in achieving organizational success; Details in conducting meaningful meetings; Periodic evaluations on the success and progress of their program; Accessibility of supervisors to their employees.

  • Absenteeism Estimates by Employees and Managers: Divergent Perspectives and Self-Serving Perceptions. Johns, Gary // Journal of Applied Psychology;Apr94, Vol. 79 Issue 2, p229 

    The social cognition literature and a deviance model of absenteeism were used to generate a series of predictions about employees' and managers' estimates of levels of absenteeism. Employees revealed a clear self-serving pattern in comparing their own absenteeism with occupational norms and...

  • ROLE-PLAYING. Wieringa, C. F. // Management International Review;1968, Vol. 8 Issue 1, p101 

    This article focuses on the significance of role-playing in the field of management and interpersonal relationship. Role-playing has therefore become one of the most important methods of helping people to form a clearer picture of the effect their own behavior has on their fellow-workers and...

  • Role-Play Your Way to Learning. Swink, David F. // Training & Development;May93, Vol. 47 Issue 5, p91 

    Presents guidelines on the use of role play in training that helps integrate knowledge with on-the-job behaviors. Warm-up phase; Need to make employees understand that the activity is relevant and practical; Empowerment of the course participants as teachers.

  • Manipulation Revisited. VARE, LENARD // American Jails;Sep/Oct2015, Vol. 29 Issue 4, p31 

    The article discusses the use of positive manipulation to gain cooperation and decrease resistance to change. Topics discussed include manipulation of children by parents by limiting choices to healthy foods, manipulation of staff by shift supervisor for better performance, and manipulation of...

  • TEAM MEMBERS' AND SUPERVISORS' RATINGS OF TEAM PERFORMANCE: A CASE OF INCONSISTENCY. Kline, Theresa J.B. // Psychological Reports;Jun2001 Part 2, Vol. 88 Issue 3, p1015 

    Evaluates the consistency of team ratings by members and supervisors. Use of team performance, organizational support and supervisors judgment to examine the consistency; Employment of Pearson coefficients in the assessment of ratings; Need for further training of team members and supervisor.

  • A Recruiting and Hiring Role-Play: An Experiential Simulation. Newberry, Robert; Collins, Marianne K. // Marketing Education Review;Spring2012, Vol. 22 Issue 1, p67 

    Creating experiential learning opportunities that engage students, meet marketing curricula objectives, and fit the application in a traditional semester course is extremely challenging. This paper describes a role-playing simulation offered concurrently to the professional selling and sales...

  • 'Nice' Management Often Mistaken For 'Good' Management. Khleer, Bobbi // Credit Union Journal;2/21/2005, Vol. 9 Issue 7, p4 

    In this article the author confers some valuable tips in helping leaders build winning teams in sales and service. She presents nine things that one can do to truly maximize the potential of one's team. She said that one must be bold in setting the goals. Letting one's team know that the leader...

  • Member Variation, Recognition of Expertise, and Group Performance. Libby, Robert; Trotman, Ken T.; Zimmer, Ian // Journal of Applied Psychology;Feb87, Vol. 72 Issue 1, p81 

    The most effective method for aggregating the conflicting opinions of experts is a subject of active debate in the literature. Task differences are most often used to explain differing results among studies. Alternatively, we suggested that the characteristics of the interacting groups...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics