Caller ID -- Whose Privacy Is It, Anyway?

Ferguson, Kenneth G.
February 2001
Journal of Business Ethics;Feb2001 Part 1, Vol. 29 Issue 3, p227
Academic Journal
Caller ID or CND (Calling Number Display) is an internationally-available telecommunication service first introduced into the United States about ten years ago. Caller ID utilizes a new form of technology which enables telephone subscribers to identify the numbers (and/or names) of callers before picking up their telephones. This service has been widely assailed as an invasion of the caller's right to anonymity, a right which allegedly subsists as an important component of the caller's right to privacy. However, if privacy is defined from the perspective of the British philosopher John Stuart Mill, it can be argued that, even though anonymity is in fact an implication of genuine privacy, placing an unsolicited telephone call does not constitute a private act. Indeed, many callers who routinely block their numbers from Caller ID display units (such as telemarketers and telecharities) falsely assert a right to place anonymous calls in order to expedite their own intrusion into the privacy of others. This conclusion will be strengthened by contrasting anonymous telephone calls with the much more legitimate appeals to anonymity made by Usenet bulletin boards in cyberspace.


Related Articles

  • Caller ID on Hold. Cherskow, Myk // ABA Journal;Sep90, Vol. 76 Issue 9, p28 

    Reports on the decision of the Pennsylvania Commonwealth Court that 'Caller ID' services are an invasion of privacy under the state's constitution. Violation of the state's wiretap law; Reversal of the decision of the Pennsylvania Public Utility Commission; Case 'Barasch v. Pennsylvania Public...

  • NIGHT CALLERS BEWARE. Anderson, Charles-Edward // ABA Journal;May89, Vol. 75 Issue 5, p30 

    Reports on the controversy of the proposed use caller ID system, a computerized telephone attachment that traces and displays origin in incoming calls, in the United States. Privacy rights of telephone company customers; Impact on law enforcement; Opinions of the proponents and opponents of the...

  • briefs. Martinez, Jose // Caribbean Business;7/13/2000, Vol. 28 Issue 27, p47 

    Reports developments in telecommunications in Puerto Rico as of July 2000. Client Service awarded to telephone company AT&T for developing the Image Letter of Authorization computer system; Other awards given to AT&T from different award giving bodies; Launch of caller ID service by Puerto Rico...

  • Another wrong number. Hecht, Jeff // New Scientist;10/20/90, Vol. 128 Issue 1739, p55 

    Discusses the concept of caller identification (ID) in the United States. State agencies' regulation of the services the telephone companies offer; Negative reactions to caller ID; Telephone companies that are doing research into caller ID; Need for telephone companies to start considering what...

  • Businesses want Caller ID; others raise privacy issue.  // Marketing News;1/20/1992, Vol. 26 Issue 2, p10 

    The article discusses the requests by businesses for caller ID services and the advantages and disadvantages of its implementation. Several companies in Georgia want the service to allow them in tracking the location of their callers and deter computer hackers and bomb threats. Consumer...

  • Telemarketers say they like caller ID.  // Marketing News;08/04/97, Vol. 31 Issue 16, p8 

    This article focuses on the Caller ID telephone service. Doreen Totaro of Denver says she gets a "azillion" telemarketing calls every day, so she signed up for Caller ID service to screen them out. And the American Telemarketing Association actually likes that. There is no way to measure how...

  • Caller ID gets wires crossed in court. Schlossberg, Howard // Marketing News;9/3/1990, Vol. 24 Issue 18, p1 

    This article deals with the increasing popularity of Caller ID, a service that allows users to view and record the number of a caller. The technology used in this new service is already being marketed in six Eastern states. Permission to start marketing Caller ID and related services are being...

  • Mom's calling.  // Long Island Business News (7/1993 to 5/2009);11/16/2007, Vol. 54 Issue 59, p12A 

    The article reports that Cablevision roll out caller identification (ID) on the television (TV) for its customers in Long Island, New York. This program features a little iO logo which pops up on the left-hand side with the caller's name and phone number. It enables the customers see who is...

  • Windsor launches call centre stats package.  // Data Strategy;Oct2008, Vol. 3 Issue 12, p7 

    The article announces the online call statistics package for non-geographic numbers launched by Windsor called Vision. Aside from the volume of calls received, Vision will also identify callers by Great Britain town. Windsor's clients range from sole traders and small businesses through large...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics