The Hanover Park Mother-Infant Project: Methodological challenges and compromises in a South African context

Tomlinson, Mark; Swartz, Leslie; Landman, Mireille
November 2003
South African Journal of Psychology;Nov2003, Vol. 33 Issue 4, p205
Academic Journal
A series of randomised trials conducted in the USA examined the impact of intervention programmes for mothers and their infants. As a result, a number of guidelines were identified for implementing methodologically sound and efficacious interventions. While these guidelines are scientifically sound, they are difficult to implement in third-world contexts like South Africa where funding and professional resources are scarce. The project examined in this article is an example of a programme that falls short of these stringent guidelines and yet still has value in a context such as South Africa. While the project's design had limitations, it nevertheless raised social awareness about the target issue, so bringing it to the attention of policy makers and funding agencies. This enabled the establishment of a better-funded project that incorporated more methodologically sound design features.


Related Articles

  • Trial design in developing countries. Garner, Paul; Torres, Tessa Tan; Alonso, Pedro // BMJ: British Medical Journal (International Edition);10/1/94, Vol. 309 Issue 6958, p825 

    Focuses on the use of randomized trials with few relevant resources to improve local health services in developing countries. Necessity for intervention trials to be relevant with the needs and services of the area; Consideration on the methods to ensure the usefulness of trials; Impact of...

  • Southeastern Title V Program Staff Perceptions of State-Level Maternal and Child Health Assessment Skills. Farel, Anita M.; Peoples-Sheps, Mary D.; Schwarte, Elizabeth U.; Waller, Cheryl J. // Maternal & Child Health Journal;Dec1997, Vol. 1 Issue 4, p267 

    Objectives: Since the publication of the Future of Public Health, a high priority has been placed on the development of the assessment capacity in public health programs. Method: Key informant interviews were conducted by telephone with selected program personnel of state Maternal and Child...

  • The Pulse on Global Trials. Howes, Matthew // CenterWatch Weekly;4/7/2014, Vol. 18 Issue 14, p6 

    The article offers information on making recruitment and retention goals for clinical trials in developing markets realistic. Due to high literacy rates in developed countries, gathering informed consent using traditional, paper-based systems is not effective. Falguni Sen, director of the Global...

  • Evaluation of a family intervention programme for the treatment of overweight and obese children (Nereu Programme): a randomized clinical trial study protocol. Serra-Paya, Noemi; Ensenyat Solé, Assumpta; Real Gatius, Jordi; Castro Viñuales, Iván; Zapara Rojas, Amalia; Galindo Ortego, Gisela; Solé Mir, Eduard; Bosch Muñoz, Jordi; Mur Camón, Jose Maria; Teixidó Armengol, Concepció // BMC Public Health;2013, Vol. 13 Issue 1, p1 

    Background Obesity is mainly attributed to environmental factors. In developed countries, the time spent on physical activity tasks is decreasing, whereas sedentary behaviour patterns are increasing. The purpose of the intervention is to evaluate the effectiveness of an intensive family-based...

  • Assessing the efficacy of a modified assertive community-based treatment programme in a developing country. Botha, Ulla A.; Koen, Liezl; Joska, John A.; Hering, Linda M.; Oosthuizen, Piet P. // BMC Psychiatry;2010, Vol. 10, p73 

    Background: A number of recently published randomized controlled trials conducted in developed countries have reported no advantage for assertive interventions over standard care models. One possible explanation could be that so-called "standard care" has become more comprehensive in recent...

  • A complex breastfeeding promotion and support intervention in a developing country: study protocol for a randomized clinical trial. Nabulsi, Mona; Hamadeh, Haya; Tamim, Hani; Kabakian, Tamar; Charafeddine, Lama; Yehya, Nadine; Sinno, Durriyah; Sidani, Saadieh // BMC Public Health;2014, Vol. 14 Issue 1, p1 

    Background Breastfeeding has countless benefits to mothers, children and community at large, especially in developing countries. Studies from Lebanon report disappointingly low breastfeeding exclusivity and continuation rates. Evidence reveals that antenatal breastfeeding education, professional...

  • Is Evidence-Based Medicine Relevant to the Developing World? Chinnock, Paul; Siegfried, Nandi; Clarke, Mike // PLoS Medicine;May2005, Vol. 2 Issue 5, p367 

    Examines the relevance of evidence-based medicine in the developing world. Limitations of the relevance of systematic reviews to frontline health care workers in developing countries; Difficulties of conducting randomized controlled trials in resource-poor situations; Lack of research in...

  • Debating Moral Issues in Developing Countries. Shamoo, Adil E. // Applied Clinical Trials;Jun2005, Vol. 14 Issue 6, p86 

    The article addresses some of the fundamental moral issues faced by industry and organizations conducting research with human subjects, including clinical trials, in developing countries. Developing countries have very large and pervasive health care needs. This is in large part due to poverty,...

  • Ethical considerations of clinical trials in the developing world Fitchett, Joseph R. // Transactions of the Royal Society of Tropical Medicine & Hygiene;Aug2009, Vol. 103 Issue 8, p756 

    Summary: The developing world is entering new territory with rapid advancements in biomedical research and science. In order to ensure the protection of those most vulnerable, bioethics must experience a similar expansion and progression worldwide. Inequalities in healthcare remain an...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics