Comparison of Performance of Conventional and ThinPrep Gynecologic Preparations in the College of American Pathologists Gynecologic Cytology Program

Renshaw, Andrew A.; Young, Nancy A.; Birdsong, George G.; Styer, Patricia E.; Davey, Diane D.; Mody, Dina R.; Colgan, Terence J.
January 2004
Archives of Pathology & Laboratory Medicine;Jan2004, Vol. 128 Issue 1, p17
Academic Journal
Context.--Results of clinical trials suggest that interpretation of liquid-based cytology preparations is more accurate and is associated with less screening error than interpretation of conventional preparations. Objective.--In this study, the performance of participants in interpreting ThinPrep (TP) preparations was compared with participants' performance on conventional Papanicolaou tests in the College of American Pathologists Interlaboratory Comparison Program in Cervicovaginal Cytology (PAP). Design.--The results of the PAP from the year 2002 were reviewed, and the discordancies to series and exact-match error rates for the 2 cytologic methods were compared. Results.--For this study, a total of 89 815 interpretations from conventional smears and 20 886 interpretations from TP samples were analyzed. Overall, interpretations of TP preparations had both significantly fewer false-positive (1.6%) and false-negative (1.3%) rates than those of conventional smears (P = .001 and P = .02, respectively) for validated or validated-equivalent slides, as assessed by concordance with the correct diagnostic series. In this assessment of concordance to series, interpretations of educational TP and conventional preparations were similar, except for high-grade squamous intraepithelial lesion, in which the performance was significantly worse for educational TP preparations (false-negative rate of 8.1% vs 4.1% for conventional smears, P < .001). When interpretations were matched to the exact diagnosis, validated-equivalent TP preparations were generally more accurate for diagnoses in the 100 series and 200 series than were conventional smears. Notably, for the reference diagnosis of squamous cell carcinoma, the exact-match error rate on validated equivalent TP slides was significantly greater than that of conventional slides (44.5% vs 23.1%, P < .001). Interpretations of educational TP preparations also had a significantly higher error rate in matching to the exact...


Related Articles

  • ThinPrep Pap test offers best detection of cervical cancer.  // Contemporary OB/GYN;Jun2003, Vol. 48 Issue 6, p16 

    Discusses research being done on the comparison between ThinPrep Pap test and conventional Papanicolaou smear. Reference to a study by A. Limaye et al published in the 2003 issue of the "Archives of Pathology and Laboratory Medicine"; Increase in the detection of high-grade squamous...

  • Accuracy of Patients' Recall of Pap and Cholesterol Screening. Newell, Sallie; Girgis, Afaf; Sanson-Fisher, Rob; Ireland, Malcolm // American Journal of Public Health;Sep2000, Vol. 90 Issue 9, p1431 

    Objectives. This study was undertaken in mid- 1994 and assessed how accurately patients recall the recency and result of their most recent cholesterol and Papanicolaou (Pap) tests. Methods. A cross-sectional, door-to-door community survey was used to gather self-report and, subsequently,...

  • Pap Smear.  // Encyclopedic Reference of Cancer;2001, p684 

    A definition of the term "pap or Papanicolaou smear," which refers to a test where cells shed from the cervix, vagina and endometrium are collected as smears, prepared by special staining and then microscopically examined is presented.

  • Increasing Adherence to Pap Screening Guidelines. Miller, Karl E. // American Family Physician;1/15/2004, Vol. 69 Issue 2, p409 

    Discuses the positive impact of Papanicolaou (Pap) smears on the morbidity and mortality of cervical cancer based on the study "Effectiveness of Interventions to Increase Papanicolaou Use," by K. R. Yabroff et al, published in the May-June 2003 issue of the "Journal of the American Board Family...

  • Is liquid-based cytology better than Pap tests for CIN 2?  // Journal of Family Practice;Apr2008, Vol. 57 Issue 4, p218 

    The article outlines the significance of liquid-based cytology in treating cervical intraepithelial enoplasia grade 2 (CIN 2) in the U.S. Studies show that liquid-based cervical cytology is not superior to conventional Papanicolaou (Pap) testing in the detection of CIN 2 or worse because it is...

  • WOMEN WITH "SQUAMOUS ATYPIA". Barry, Henry C.; Keller, Kathy // Journal of Family Practice;Sep1996, Vol. 43 Issue 3, p229 

    The article discusses management choices for patients with squamous atypia on Papanicolaou smear. It references a study by J. Melnikow et al published in the 1996 issue of "Medical Care." The percentage of women in the U.S. who have had a Pap smear in the last 3 years is approximately 75%....

  • Report finds LBC technique no better than Pap test.  // Practice Nurse;1/27/2006, Vol. 31 Issue 2, p10 

    This article reports that liquid-based cytology (LBC) is no better than the conventional smear test, according to a report published in "The Lancet" as of January 2006. In a review of 56 studies, Elizabeth Davey, of the University of Sydney in Australia, and her colleagues concluded that there...

  • Q: When I reach a certain age, can I stop having Pap tests?  // Mayo Clinic Guide to Women's Cancers;2005, p435 

    This article addresses the question of when to stop having Pap tests. The American Cancer Society recommends that screening can stop at age 70, provided three or more of your recent Pap test results have been normal and you have not had any abnormal results in the last 10 years. Keep in mind,...

  • Screening for Cervical Cancer and Initial Treatment of Patients With Abnormal Results From Papanicolaou Testing. Bundrick, John B.; Cook, David A.; Gostout, Bobbie S. // Mayo Clinic Proceedings;Aug2005, Vol. 80 Issue 8, p1063 

    New techniques for cervical cancer screening and a better understanding of the natural history of human papillomavirus (HPV) and cervical neoplasia have inspired a quest for more rational screening strategies for cervical cancer. Often, screening intervals for women older than 30 years can be...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics