Cuttlefish perform multiple agonistic displays to communicate a hierarchy of threats

Schnell, Alexandra; Smith, Carolynn; Hanlon, Roger; Hall, Karina; Harcourt, Robert
October 2016
Behavioral Ecology & Sociobiology;Oct2016, Vol. 70 Issue 10, p1643
Academic Journal
Many animals produce multiple displays during agonistic interactions, but the roles of these displays often remain ambiguous. The hierarchical signaling hypothesis has been proposed to explain their occurrence and posits that different displays convey different levels of aggressive intent, allowing signalers to communicate graded series of threats. This hypothesis suggests that low-risk signals, typically performed at the beginning stages of an interaction, are strong predictors of high-risk signals but weak predictors of physical aggression. High-risk signals, typically produced at later stages of an interaction, are strong predictors of physical aggression. We used giant Australian cuttlefish, Sepia apama, to test these predictions. We combined field observations and laboratory video playback experiments to determine whether (i) male cuttlefish produce specific sequences of displays, (ii) displays in early stages of an interaction predict displays in later stages of an interaction, and (iii) displays produced in later stages of an interaction provide reliable predictors of physical aggression. Field observations suggested that males progressed from low-risk to high-risk signals (i.e., visual signaling to physical aggression). Video playback results zrevealed that the low-risk frontal display, produced during early stages of an interaction, conveys reliable information about the cuttlefish's intent to escalate to later stages of visual signaling. Both the shovel and lateral displays were produced during the later stages of signaling and were reliable predictors of subsequent physical aggression. Our study supports the hierarchical signaling hypothesis and provides new empirical insights into how cuttlefish use progressive visual signaling to convey increasing levels of threat. Significance statement: Many animals perform multiple displays during fights, but the roles of these displays often remain ambiguous. The hierarchical signaling hypothesis posits that animals produce multiple displays to convey different levels of aggressive intent, allowing signalers to communicate graded series of threats. We tested this hypothesis in giant Australian cuttlefish, Sepia apama. Specifically, we tested whether (i) displays in early stages of a fight predict displays in later stages of a fight and (ii) displays produced in later stages of a fight provide reliable predictors of physical aggression. Our results support these predictions and reveal that fighting cuttlefish progress from low-risk signals to high-risk signals to convey a hierarchy of threats. This study highlights the generality of hierarchical signaling during animal contests, as cuttlefish are evolutionary far removed from many of the species that have been reported to use this type of signaling.


Related Articles

  • Sex Differences in Agonistic Behavior of Merriam's Kangaroo Rats (Dipodomys merriami). Newmark, Jennifer E.; Jenkins, Stephen H. // American Midland Naturalist;Apr2000, Vol. 143 Issue 2, p377 

    ABSTRACT.--Agonistic behavior of heteromyid rodents has been studied using staged encounters in the laboratory, but there have been no previous attempts to test for a linear dominance hierarchy among individuals of the same species. Dominance hierarchies are important in learning about...

  • Serengeti scaredy-cats keep to the rear. Goss, Helen // New Scientist;12/10/94, Vol. 144 Issue 1955, p9 

    Focuses on the hunting and territorial behavior of lionesses. Research conducted at the Australian University in Canberra; Suspicion that some lionesses might be cowards; Group behavior.

  • Seasonal changes in and effects of familiarity on agonistic behaviors of rat-like hamsters (Cricetulus triton). Zhang, Jian-Xu; Zhang, Zhi-Bin; Wang, Zu-Wang // Ecological Research;Jun2001, Vol. 16 Issue 2, p309 

    The seasonal changes in agonistic behaviors and effects of familiarity on agonistic behaviors in wild-caught adult rat-like hamsters (Cricetulus triton) were observed in dyadic encounters in a neutral arena. The aggression of opposite- and same-sex encounters became higher or remained the same...

  • Maintenance of Multifemale Social Organization in a Group of Nomascus concolor at Wuliang Mountain, Yunnan, China. Peng-Fei Fan; Xue-Long Jiang // International Journal of Primatology;Feb2010, Vol. 31 Issue 1, p1 

    Many short-term studies have reported groups of black crested gibbons containing ≥2 adult females ( Nomascus concolor). We report the stability of multifemale groups in this species over a period of 6 yr. Our focal group and 2 neighboring groups included 2 breeding females between March...

  • Aerial Defense Tactics of Flying Insects. May, Mike // American Scientist;Jul/Aug91, Vol. 79 Issue 4, p316 

    Deals with the aerial defense tactics of night-flying insects to evade capture by bats. Precise and effective method by which bats navigate and identify objects in the dark; Details on the phonotactic behavior of insects to evade captors; Frequency of the cricket's wingbeats.

  • Parallel changes in agonistic and non-agonistic behaviors during dominance hierarchy formation in crayfish. Herberholz, J.; Sen, M. M.; Edwards, D. H. // Journal of Comparative Physiology A: Neuroethology, Sensory, Neu;Apr2003, Vol. 189 Issue 4, p321 

    Agonistic and non-agonistic behaviors were studied before, during, and after the formation of social status in crayfish. Differences in the expression of a non-agonistic behavior by dominant and subordinate crayfish developed in parallel with the differences in agonistic behaviors that indicate...

  • Territorial male color predicts agonistic behavior of conspecifics in a color polymorphic species. Wayne J. Korzan; Russell D. Fernald // Behavioral Ecology;Mar2007, Vol. 18 Issue 2, p318 

    Male cichlid fish, Astatotilapia burtoni, live in a lek-like social system in shore pools of Lake Tanganyika, Africa, as one of two distinct social phenotypes: territorial (T) males that comprise approximately 10–30% of the population and nonterritorial (NT) males that make up the rest. T...

  • One Hundred Million Years of Chemical Warfare by Insects. G. Poinar; C. Marshall; R. Buckley // Journal of Chemical Ecology;Sep2007, Vol. 33 Issue 9, p1663 

    Abstract  An important defensive strategy among animals is the use of chemical compounds with toxic or irritating properties. In this paper, we report the discovery of an Early Cretaceous soldier beetle (Coleoptera: Cantharidae) in Burmese amber that seemingly employed a chemical...

  • Geophysical variables and behavior: LXXXIV. Quantitative increases in group aggression in male... St. Pierre, L.S.; Persinger, M.A. // Perceptual & Motor Skills;Jun98 Part 1, Vol. 86 Issue 3, p1392 

    Presents a study which was conducted to perceive which of the two agonistic behaviors, boxing or biting, was most correlated with geomagnetic activity, in relation to group aggression in male epileptic rats. Methodology used to conduct the study; Results of the study.

  • Defense. Farndon, John // Wild Animals;2003, p38 

    Animals have different ways of escaping predators, most mammals run away, while birds take to the air. Turtles and tortoises hide inside their hard shells. Armadillos curl up inside their flexible body armor. Hedgehogs, porcupines, and other echidnas are protected by sharp quills (spines).


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics