Deep evolutionary experience explains mammalian responses to predators

Atkins, Rosemary; Blumstein, Daniel; Moseby, Katherine; West, Rebecca; Hyatt, Matthew; Letnic, Mike
October 2016
Behavioral Ecology & Sociobiology;Oct2016, Vol. 70 Issue 10, p1755
Academic Journal
Prey may have ontogenetic experience, evolutionary experience, or both types of experiences with their predators and how such experiences influences their ability to identify their predators is of great theoretical and applied interest. We capitalized on predator-free exclosures containing populations of native burrowing bettongs ( Bettongia lesueur) and introduced rabbits ( Oryctolagus cuniculus) that ensured we had knowledge of our subjects' ontogenetic experiences with predators and asked whether evolutionary experience influenced their visual predator discrimination abilities. Rabbits evolved with red foxes ( Vulpes vulpes) and wolves ( Canis lupus) but had less than 200 years of prior exposure to dingoes. The rabbit population we studied had been exposed to dingoes ( Canis dingo) and foxes 8 months prior to our study and had heightened responses to red fox models, but not dingo/dog ( Canis dingo/ Canis familiaris) models. The insular burrowing bettong population had no ontogenetic exposure to mammalian predators, brief evolutionary exposure to domestic dogs and possibly dingoes, and a deeper evolutionary history of exposure to thylacines ( Thylacinus cynocephalus)-another large mammalian predator with convergent body morphology to dingoes/dogs but no evolutionary or ontogenetic exposure to foxes. Bettongs showed a modest response to the dingo/dog model and no response to the fox model. These results are consistent with the hypothesis that deep evolutionary history plays an essential role in predator discrimination and provides support for the multipredator hypothesis that predicts the presence of any predators can maintain antipredator behavior for other absent predators. Significance statement: Prey may have ontogenetic experience and or evolutionary experience with their predators. How such experiences influence prey species' ability to identify their predators is of significance to theory on the evolution of antipredator response and to improve the success of translocations and reintroductions for conservation purposes which often fail because of predation on predator naïve prey. Here, we show that prey recognition for two prey species with limited or no ontogenetic exposure to predators, rabbits, and burrowing bettongs was greatest toward the predator to which they had the longest period of coevolution. The results are consistent with the hypothesis that evolutionary history plays an essential role in predator discrimination and provides support for the multipredator hypothesis that predicts the presence of any predators can maintain antipredator behavior for other absent predators.


Related Articles

  • Spatial positioning in the selfish herd. Morrell, Lesley J.; Ruxton, Graeme D.; James, Richard // Behavioral Ecology;Nov2010, Vol. 21 Issue 6, p1367 

    The antipredator benefits of grouping are relatively well understood; however, predation risk often differs for individuals that occupy different positions within a group. The selfish herd hypothesis describes how individuals can reduce risk of predation by moving to specific positions within...

  • The effect of familiarity on vigilance behaviour in grey squirrels. Shonfield, Julia // McGill Science Undergraduate Research Journal;2011, Vol. 6 Issue 1, p45 

    Introduction: Vigilance enables an animal to obtain information about the environment but often at a cost of reduced foraging rate. Some environmental information may not change rapidly, so vigilance might be safely reduced with familiarity with an area. Studies have noted this decline in...

  • ANTIPREDATORY DEFENSE OF NEONATAL PRONGHORN (ANTILOCAPRA AMERICANA) BY YEARLING MALE PRONGHORN IN SOUTHWESTERN SOUTH DAKOTA. Jacques, Christopher N.; Jenks, Jonathan A. // Western North American Naturalist;Dec2010, Vol. 70 Issue 4, p570 

    Antipredatory defense of pronghorn (Antilocapra americana) neonates (≤1 month old) by adult females (>18 months old) is well documented throughout the geographic range of this species. However, reports of male pronghorn defending neonates against predators are limited to a single study in...

  • Vigilance and fright behaviour in the insular Svalbard reindeer (). Reimers, Eigil; Lund, Steinar; Ergon, Torbjørn // Canadian Journal of Zoology;Aug2011, Vol. 89 Issue 8, p753 

    The insular Svalbard reindeer ( Vrolik, 1829) provide an opportunity to study vigilance behaviour in the absence of predators and parasitizing insects. We measured vigilance and fright and flight response during summer 2006 in the Svalbard archipelago; in four areas on Nordenskiöld Land on...

  • Where does a flock end from an information perspective? A comparative experiment with live and robotic birds. Fernández-Juricic, Esteban; Kowalski, Victor // Behavioral Ecology;Nov2011, Vol. 22 Issue 6, p1304 

    Predator detection is improved when individuals join groups. Theory assumes that the transfer of social information about predators among individuals is immediate and accurate. However, animals in groups space themselves at different distances. Little is known about the shape of the social...

  • Number of eyespots and their intimidating effect on naïve predators in the peacock butterfly. Merilaita, Sami; Vallin, Adrian; Kodandaramaiah, Ullasa; Dimitrova, Marina; Ruuskanen, Suvi; Laaksonen, Toni // Behavioral Ecology;Nov2011, Vol. 22 Issue 6, p1326 

    Predation experiments have shown that the large eyespots (concentric rings of contrasting colors) found on the wings of several lepidopteran species intimidate passerine predators. According to the eye mimicry hypotheses, the intimidation is caused by predators associating the eyespots with the...

  • Cues of intraguild predators affect the distribution of intraguild prey. Choh, Yasuyuki; Van der Hammen, Tessa; Sabelis, Maurice W.; Janssen, Arne // Oecologia;May2010, Vol. 163 Issue 2, p335 

    Theory on intraguild (IG) predation predicts that coexistence of IG-predators and IG-prey is only possible for a limited set of parameter values, suggesting that IG-predation would not be common in nature. This is in conflict with the observation that IG-predation occurs in many natural systems....

  • Melanic color-dependent antipredator behavior strategies in barn owl nestlings. van den Brink, Valentijn; Dolivo, Vassilissa; Falourd, Xavier; Dreiss, Amélie N.; Roulin, Alexandre // Behavioral Ecology;May2012, Vol. 23 Issue 3, p473 

    The arms race between predators and prey has led to morphological and behavioral adaptations. Different antipredator strategies can coexist within a population if each strategy is the result of a trade-off with competing demands. Antipredator behavior can be associated with morphological traits,...

  • Does predation risk, through moon phase and predator cues, modulate food intake, antipredatory and physiological responses in wood mice ( Apodemus sylvaticus)? Navarro-Castilla, Álvaro; Barja, Isabel // Behavioral Ecology & Sociobiology;Sep2014, Vol. 68 Issue 9, p1505 

    Predation influences the ecology and behaviour of prey species and it is well known that the risk of predation affects prey's decision making. We investigated whether predation risk through moon phase and exposure to the faecal odour of a natural predator, the red fox Vulpes vulpes, affect...

  • Does phylogenetic inertia explain the evolution of ineffective antipredator behavior in a sunfish-salamander system? Sih, A.; Kats, L. B.; Maurer, E. F. // Behavioral Ecology & Sociobiology;Dec2000, Vol. 49 Issue 1, p48 

    The streamside salamander, Ambystoma barbouri, exhibits ineffective antipredator behavior (high emergence rate from refuge, and high activity while out of refuge) and thus suffers heavy predation in stream pools with sunfish. A. barbouri evolved relatively recently from an ancestor that closely...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics