Prostitution and the Ideal State. A Defense of a Policy of Vigilance

Vicente, Agustin
April 2016
Ethical Theory & Moral Practice;Apr2016, Vol. 19 Issue 2, p475
Academic Journal
The debate concerning prostitution is centered around two main views: the liberal view and the radical feminist view. The typical liberal view is associated with decriminalization and normalization of prostitution; radical feminism stands in favor of prohibition or abolition. Here, I argue that neither of the views is right. My argument does not depend on the plausible (or actual) side effects of prohibition, abolition, or normalization; rather, I am concerned with the ideals involved. I will concede to liberals their claim that prostitution is not harmful in itself. Yet, I will argue that prostitution cannot be thought of as 'just another job'. Even if prostitution is not harmful in itself, it can do much harm. I will argue that a policy of vigilance is the most adequate one to adopt with regard of prostitution, given the risk of harm associated with prostitution. A policy of vigilance tries to discriminate between those who take a certain course of action willingly and those who do not. It puts no restraints on those who exercise their genuine will, but protects those who are openly or subtly coerced.


Related Articles

  • Belgium: government proposes legalizing prostitution.  // Off Our Backs;Sep/Oct2003, Vol. 33 Issue 9/10, p6 

    Cites plans by the Socialist and Liberal members of Belgium's parliament to propose legalizing prostitution. Debate over whether legalization combats trafficking.

  • Commercial Sex and the Law: A Case for Decriminalisation. Sullivan, Barbara // Social Alternatives;Jul95, Vol. 14 Issue 3, p23 

    Argues on the need for the decriminalization of prostitution in Australia. Conceptual history of decriminalization; Decriminalization as a two-step process; Instigation of new methods of self-surveillance and control; Need to direct the focus away from questions about morality; Reasons for...

  • Prostitution Humanism and a Woman's Choice. Klinger, Kimberly // Humanist;Jan/Feb2003, Vol. 63 Issue 1, p16 

    Discusses prostitution and feminism. Views of feminists on prostitution; Information on the decriminalization of prostitution; Details on the demands of the World Charter for Prostitutes Rights.

  • WOMEN'S WORLDS COLLIDE. CHIU, JOANNA // Herizons;Fall2011, Vol. 25 Issue 2, p5 

    The article presents the author's opinion on a subject pertaining to the abolition of prostitution in Canada as discussed during the Women's Worlds conference held July 3-7, 2011 in Ottawa, Ontario. She mentions that delegates during the conference who favored the abolition outnumbered those who...

  • New Zealand: legalizes prostitution; U.N. panel protests.  // Off Our Backs;Sep/Oct2003, Vol. 33 Issue 9/10, p5 

    Reports on the decriminalization of prostitution, pimping, and brothel keeping in New Zealand. Country's commitment to the Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination Against Women.

  • Not their concern. Baker, Ken // IPA Review;1992, Vol. 45 Issue 1, p25 

    Reports that Queensland's Criminal Justice Commission on prostitution received numerous submissions supporting decriminalization. Reason why the Catholic Church did not make a submission; The connection to the question of the distribution of wealth in Australia.

  • Introduction. Joseph, Galen; Porter, Dorothy // Western Humanities Review;Fall2012, Vol. 66 Issue 3, p3 

    The article introduces various reports published within the issue, including one about women's empowerment, one about the connection between sex work and local politics and another about the decriminalization of prostitution.

  • The Public Life of Sex Work. KNIGHT, KELLY RAY // Western Humanities Review;Fall2012, Vol. 66 Issue 3, p55 

    The article analyzes the political discourses surrounding Proposition K which aims to decriminalize prostitution in San Francisco, California. According to the author, she voted in favor of the proposition because she believes that consensual sex, whether sold or given for free, should not be...

  • United States: Berkeley voters to decide or decriminalizing prostitution.  // Off Our Backs;Sep/Oct2004, Vol. 34 Issue 9/10, p9 

    Reports that Berkeley, California voters will decide on an initiative to decriminalize prostitution on November 2, 2004. Fear of feminists working against prostitution; Support from the advocates of prostitutes' rights.

  • Ambivalent Regulation: The Sexual Services Industries in NSW and Victoria -- Sex Work as Work, or as Special Category? Crofts, Penny; Maher, JaneMaree; Pickering, Sharon; Prior, Jason // Current Issues in Criminal Justice;Mar2012, Vol. 23 Issue 3, p393 

    Despite continuing contests in Australian states over the validity of sex work as work, Victoria and New South Wales (NSW) have been part of a global trend for states to decriminalise and/or legalise the sex industry. This article argues that although Victoria and NSW are united by their...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics