Facts, Principles, and (Real) Politics

Rossi, Enzo
April 2016
Ethical Theory & Moral Practice;Apr2016, Vol. 19 Issue 2, p505
Academic Journal
Should our factual understanding of the world influence our normative theorising about it? G.A. Cohen has argued that our ultimate normative principles should not be constrained by facts (e.g. about feasibility, human nature, and so on). Many others have defended or are committed to various versions or subsets of that claim. In this paper I dispute those positions by arguing that, in order to resist the conclusion that ultimate normative principles rest on facts about possibility or conceivability, one has to embrace an unsatisfactory account of how principles generate normative political judgments. So political theorists have to choose between principles ostensibly unbiased by our current understanding of human motivation and political reality, or principles capable of reliably generating political judgments. I conclude with wider methodological observations in defence of the latter option, and so of a return to political philosophy's traditional blend of normative and descriptive elements.


Related Articles

  • Ideology, Between the Concept and the Political Reality. Șandru, Daniel // Sphere of Politics / Sfera Politicii;2012, Vol. 20 Issue 3, p93 

    This paper begins with the premise that the issue of the relationship between the concept and the political reality in the case of ideology can be explained by using the analysis of two important terms pertaining to contemporary political theory. On the one hand, we take into consideration the...

  • Distributive Justice, Feasibility Gridlocks, and the Harmfulness of Economic Ideology. Herzog, Lisa // Ethical Theory & Moral Practice;Nov2015, Vol. 18 Issue 5, p957 

    Many political theorists think about how to make societies more just. In recent years, with interests shifting from principles to their institutional realization, there has been much debate about feasibility and the role it should play in theorizing. What has been underexplored, however, is how...

  • Imagining Interest. Engelmann, Stephen G. // Utilitas;Nov2001, Vol. 13 Issue 3, p289 

    Analyzes product of imagination. Role of political science; Analysis on theory of motivation; Interest of pain and pleasure.

  • Retribution, Forgiveness, and the Character Creation Theory of Punishment. Rogers, Katherin A. // Social Theory & Practice;Jan2007, Vol. 33 Issue 1, p75 

    In this article, the author defends a version of moral retributivism that can most successfully ground the intuition that forgiveness is sometimes appropriate. The author argues that her theory explains a number of common, contemporary intuitions and practices related to punishment at least as...

  • AN ANALYSIS OF KRIPKE'S ARGUMENT AGAINST THE IDENTITY THESIS. TYNDAL, Jason // Romanian Journal of Analytic Philosophy / Revista Romana de Filo;Jul-Dec2012, Vol. 6 Issue 2, p7 

    In this paper, I provide a critical analysis of kripke's claim that „pain = c-fiber firings“ is not necessary. Kripke's claim depends on accepting the plausibility of a possible world in which either pain or c-fiber firings can occur without the other. against kripke, I argue that we...

  • De weg van Vlaamse 'daders' naar de Gestapo. VAN EETVELDE, ROBBY // Bijdragen en Mededelingen betreffende de Geschiedenis der Nederl;2009, Vol. 124 Issue 3, p349 

    The article discusses Nazi collaborators in Belgium who served as translators for the Geheime Staatspolizei, also known as the Gestapo, during the German occupation of Belgium in World War II. The author discusses the role of the Gestapo in maintaining order in Nazi territories. Criminal records...

  • Democracia y pluralismo en el ocaso de la soberanía. Alejandro Rossi, Luis // Araucaria;2014, Vol. 16 Issue 31, p3 

    The article deals with the problematic perspectives of contemporary democracy diagnosed by Carlo Galli in a series of short works in the last five years. I will make a systematic exposition of his approach, focusing on the relationship between State, democracy and rights. Galli builds his...

  • Resurrection as Insurrection: Potential Space and the Subversion of Political Totalities. LaMothe, Ryan // Pastoral Psychology;Oct2013, Vol. 62 Issue 5, p709 

    In this article, I depict the shared belief in resurrection as subversive vis-à-vis political totalities. More particularly, I argue that the idea of resurrection as insurrection emerges against the background of the political realities of the Roman Empire and its diverse tools for...

  • Single-Party Autocracies, Ideology, and Repression. Moiler, Jorgen; Skaaning, Svend-Erik // Statsvetenskaplig Tidskrift;2013, Issue 4, p345 

    Previous studies have argued that single-party autocracies are less repressive than other kinds of autocracies. Challenging this notion, we emphasize that ideological motivations and strategic use of the party apparatus counterbalance the moderating mechanisms associated with single-party...

  • Comment on Ashcraft's 'Political Theory and the Problem of Ideology' Germino, Dante // Journal of Politics;Aug80, Vol. 42 Issue 3, p706 

    Comments on an article about the development of political theory and the problem of ideology. Discussion on the evolution of ideas and ideologies; Comparison of political theories; Implication of culture and history to the interpretation of theories.


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics