TITLE

Reconciling Just Causes for Armed Humanitarian Intervention

AUTHOR(S)
Aloyo, Eamon
PUB. DATE
April 2016
SOURCE
Ethical Theory & Moral Practice;Apr2016, Vol. 19 Issue 2, p313
SOURCE TYPE
Academic Journal
DOC. TYPE
Article
ABSTRACT
Michael Walzer argues that the just cause for humanitarian intervention is not met if there are only 'ordinary' levels of human rights abuses within a state because he believes that respecting the right to collective self-determination is more morally important than protecting other individual rights. Several prominent critics of Walzer advocate for a more permissive account of a just cause. They argue that protecting individuals' human rights is more morally important than respecting a right to collective self-determination. I argue that these two accounts are far more similar than either Walzer or his critics realize because collective self-determination requires the protection of some human rights in order to allow each person the opportunity to participate in collective choices. Consequently, the just cause for intervention is met whenever at least some important human rights of one person are violated and others are being credibly threatened. The counter intuitive conclusion of my argument is that justified interventions can actually promote rather than undermine collective self-determination because just interventions allow innocents, who otherwise would have excluded from this process, the opportunity to contribute to collective choices. Of course, a just cause is insufficient in itself for intervention to be permissible because other just war precepts must also be met.
ACCESSION #
114309013

 

Related Articles

  • The Ethos of Sovereignty: A Critical Appraisal. Minkkinen, Panu // Human Rights Review;Jan2007, Vol. 8 Issue 2, p33 

    Taking as its starting point the commonly held claim about the obscurity of the concept of sovereignty, the article first identifies a fundamental paradox between the classical Westphalian notion of state sovereignty and human rights. In the rhetoric of international politics, attempts to...

  • The Crisis of Humanitarian Intervention. Bello, Walden // Foreign Policy in Focus;8/9/2011, p3 

    The article considers whether there is justification in national sovereignty being circumscribed by armed international humanitarian intervention. According to the author, the expanding doctrine of human rights has put a limit on national sovereignty which started in the 1990s when events in...

  • HUMANITARNI INTERVENCIONIZAM: ETIÄŒKA, PRAVNA I SIGURNOSNA PITANJA U 21. STOUEĆU.  // Polemos;Jan-Jun2010, Vol. 13 Issue 25, p51 

    No abstract available.

  • Rethinking Humanitarian Intervention After Kosovo: Legal Reality and Political Pragmatism. Terry, James P. // Army Lawyer;Aug2004, Issue 375, p36 

    Discusses an argument for acceptance of a legal structure capable of addressing international human rights violations and genocide, focusing on the specific context of Kosovo. Threat to frustrate United Nations Security Council Chapter VII authorization; Humanitarian intervention; Respect for...

  • Review Essay Legality, Morality and the Dilemma of Humanitarian Intervention after Kosovo. Krisch, Nico // European Journal of International Law;Feb2002, Vol. 13 Issue 1, p323 

    The essay reviews five recent works on humanitarian intervention which shed new light on central questions of the debate. The authors, mainly international lawyers but also scholars of international relations, philosophy and sociology, mainly agree that in positive international law, even after...

  • WHO SHOULD DETERMINE THE JUST CAUSE OF HUMANITARIAN INTERVENTION? Aguilar, Manuela // Social Alternatives;2005 Third Quarter, Vol. 24 Issue 3, p17 

    The article reports that the concept of humanitarian intervention constitutes an armed intervention in another state, without the agreement of that state, to address the threat of a humanitarian disaster, in particular caused by grave and large-scale violations of fundamental human rights. The...

  • BETWEEN NON-INTERVENTION AND THE PROTECTION OF HUMAN RIGHTS: A MORAL ARGUMENT IN DEFENSE OF HUMANITARIAN INTERVENTION. Pop, Oana Florina // CEU Political Science Journal;Feb2012, Vol. 7 Issue 1, p68 

    Although humanitarian intervention has been a recurrent issue in moral and political philosophy for some years, much disagreement over its moral justifiability persists among scholars. The common denominator of previous views is their reliance on the assumption that solving the moral problem of...

  • MUTLAK GÜÇ YA DA SINIRSIZ SORUMLULUK: DEVLET EGEMENLİĞİ VE ULUSLARARASI TOPLUMUN KORUMA SORUMLULUÄžU. İren, Adem Ali; Gürkaynak, Muharrem // Journal of Suleyman Demirel University Institute of Social Scien;2016, Vol. 24 Issue 2, p134 

    Applying sovereignty in an absolute form in modern international relations has resulted in states are estranged of legitimacy. Sovereignty supposed to guarantee welfare and security of individuals has become a threat for them. Perception of self-legitimated state sovereignty has turned into an...

  • Waging War in the Name of Human Rights? Barša, Pavel // Perspectives: Central European Review of International Affairs;Summer2005, Vol. 24, p5 

    The genocide in Rwanda in 1994 and the case of the Bosnian town Srebrenica one year later reminded some observers of the infamous "abandonment of the Jews" in the forties. These events helped strengthen a belief that the western states have the right, or even the obligation, to infringe the...

  • Humanitarian interventions: a critical approach. Ludwig, Fernando José // Universitas: Relações Internacionais;2010, Vol. 8 Issue 1, p27 

    This paper aims to confront the manifold aspects of "humanitarian" intervention along with the conceptualization of national sovereignty. It is argued that, among the many forms of humanitarian interventions (such as sanctions, material assistance, aid, etc.), military intervention should always...

Share

Read the Article

Courtesy of THE LIBRARY OF VIRGINIA

Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics