Self-monitoring of lower leg skin temperature: accuracy of self-reported data and adherence to a cooling protocol for the prevention of venous leg ulcers

Kelechi, Teresa J.; Madisetti, Mohan; Mueller, Martina; Dooley, Mary; Prentice, Margaret
December 2015
Patient Preference & Adherence;2015, Vol. 9, p1751
Academic Journal
Background: For intervention studies that require the use of participant self-reports, the quality and accuracy of recorded data and variability in participant adherence rates to the treatment can cause significant outcome bias. Purpose: To assess the quality and accuracy of participant documentation of daily self-monitoring of leg skin temperature, adherence to a graduated cooling treatment protocol to prevent venous leg ulcers, and the potential for bias in treatment effect in a randomized controlled trial that included a population with chronic venous disease. Methods: Individuals were randomized to a leg cooling intervention or placebo treatment group to daily self-monitor and record lower leg skin temperature over a 9-month period on monthly paper study logs. Returned study logs for the first 100 completed participants (n=54 cooling intervention, n=46 control) were reviewed for quality and accuracy. Adherence was determined from evaluating the accuracy of participant documentation. To examine potential outcome bias in treatment effect, mean between group and within group comparisons of the before and after treatment differences were conducted using an intention-to-treat (ITT) versus a modified intention-to-treat (mITT) analysis approach with an 85% accuracy cut-off rate. Data were collected in 2011-2014. Results: Of the expected 900 study logs, 91.8% (826/900) were returned and 8.2% (74/900) were not. Non-mutually exclusive main error types in returned documentation included: 59.2% (489/826) white-outs, cross-off and/or overwrites, 34.9% (288/826) entries omitted, 29.4% (243/826) no performance of daily self-monitoring, 28.7% (237/826) no performance of the treatment intervention per the prescribed protocol regime, 26.8% (221/826) extraneous data, 8.6% (71/826) suspected fabrication, and 7.6% (63/826) questionable validity. Under ITT analysis, 38.4% (346/900) of all returned logs were, 85% accurate, 25.0% (225/900) were 85%-99% accurate, and 36.6% (329/900) were 100% accurate. Mean overall participant adherence rates were: 22.0% at, 85% accuracy, 53.0% at 85%-99% accuracy, and 25.0% at 100% accuracy. Under the mITT analysis, 54.0% (483/900) of returned logs were deemed adherent with ≥85% accuracy. Conclusion: This study found good rates of adherence. Under ITT analysis, 78.0% of participants were deemed adherent to the study protocol with ≥85% accuracy in documenting daily self-monitoring of skin temperatures in response to a topically applied experimental cooling cuff intervention for the prevention of venous leg ulcers.


Related Articles

  • Leg ulcers. Morris, Pat; Sander, Ruth // Nursing Older People;Jun2007, Vol. 19 Issue 5, p33 

    The article focuses on different kinds of leg ulcers including venous and arterial and the treatment for each one of them. It states that venous leg ulcers are a common experience for older people and nurses play the main part in their care and treatment. An ulcer is a defect in the skin as a...

  • On the defensive: Expert gives guidelines for prophylaxis with laser, surgery procedures. Schwanke, Jane // Dermatology Times;Oct2011, Vol. 32 Issue 10, p36 

    The article discusses the guidelines of doctor Dirk M. Elston on antiviral and antibacterial prophylaxis for surgical and laser procedures. Elston says that those with a history of herpetic infection must have an antiviral prophylaxis for the affected area. He states that a high-risk cardiac...

  • A history of useless remedies. Lilley, Roy // Primary Health Care;Jul2012, Vol. 22 Issue 6, p10 

    The author discusses some of the reasons as to why venous leg ulcers remain the cause of such pain and suffering as well as a major health cost worldwide. He mentions the urgent need for something to be done to tackle this problem owing to the fact that the recovery rate was under 10 percent...

  • Why don't patients adhere to compression therapy? Bainbridge, Paul // British Journal of Community Nursing;Dec2013, Vol. 18 Issue 12, pS35 

    This article explores the psychological influences on patients and their choices over adopting (or not) the advice of health-care professionals (HCPs) with regard to their own health. The article will examine some key theories by reviewing studies as well as examining how the patient-HCP...

  • MANY PEDIATRIC PRESCRIPTIONS GO UNFILLED. Burke, Michael // Contemporary Pediatrics;Dec2012, Vol. 29 Issue 12, p16 

    The article unfilled prescriptions in pediatric primary care. It mentions that according to the study, the number of prescriptions issued for children at 2 primary pediatric primary care sites during a period of 26 months, that went unfilled, amounted to more than 20 percent of the...

  • Pharmionics in Dermatology: A Review of Topical Medication Adherence. Lee, Ivy A.; Maibach, Howard I. // American Journal of Clinical Dermatology;2006, Vol. 7 Issue 4, p231 

    The objective of this article was to review patient adherence to topical medications and its relationship to health outcomes in dermatologic disease. To this end, MEDLINE searches from January 1966 through June 2006 and EMBASE searches from January 1974 through June 2006 were conducted. ...

  • Improving adherence in appointment-based model. Yap, Diana // Pharmacy Today;Nov2013, Vol. 19 Issue 11, p42 

    The article discusses the effectiveness of appointment-based model, a patient care model in improving medication adherence and developing efficiencies in pharmacy operations.

  • Nurse specialist tackles contact sensitivity. Guttman, Cheryl // Dermatology Times;Sep99, Vol. 20 Issue 9, p38 

    Reports on the need for home healthcare nurses to identify contact sensitivity that is common in patients with venous leg ulcers. Inability of nurses to differentiate between statis dermatitis and a reaction involving allergy to a topical medication; Recognition of nurse specialist Janice...

  • Living skin equivalent an advance in venous ulcer healing. Guttman, Cheryl // Dermatology Times;Jan1999, Vol. 20 Issue 1, p26 

    Focuses on the effectiveness of a bilayer skin construct in treating patients with venous leg ulcers unresponsive to high compression therapy combined with conventional wound care techniques according to Gary Sibbald, professor of medicine at the University of Toronto, Ontario. Use of an...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics