Test Re-Test Reliability and Validity of Different Visual Acuity and Stereoacuity Charts Used in Preschool Children

November 2015
Journal of Clinical & Diagnostic Research;Nov2015, Vol. 9 Issue 11, p1
Academic Journal
Background: Preschool vision screenings are cost effective ways to detect children with vision impairments. The use of any vision tests in children must be age appropriate, testable, repeatable and valid. Aim: To compare the test re-test reliability, sensitivity and specificity of different visual acuity and stereo acuity charts used in preschool children. Materials and Methods: Monocular visual acuity of 90 subjects (180 eyes) of age 36 to 71 months was assessed with HOTV, Lea and E-chart in a preschool located in a semi urban area, Manipal, Karnataka. After the vision assessment, stereo acuity was recorded using Frisby and Titmus stereo charts followed by comprehensive eye examination. Repeated measurements of visual acuity and stereo acuity were done one week after the initial assessment. Results: Mean age of children was 53± 10 months with equal gender distribution. Intra class correlation (ICC) of Lea, HOTV, E-chart, Frisby and Titmus charts were 0.96, 0.99, 0.92, 1.0 and 1.0 respectively. The area under receiver operating curve (ROC) for Lea and E-chart was 0.892 and 0.776. HOTV was considered as the gold standard as it showed the least difference on repeated measurements. The sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value (PPV) and negative predictive value (NPV) of E-chart was 99, 15, 45, 94 and 21.8 percent, and Lea was 93, 56, 59 and 92 percent. The sensitivity, specificity, PPV and NPV of Frisby was 75, 27, 9, 92 percent were as of Titmus was 75, 13, 8 and 85 percent respectively. Conclusion: HOTV chart can be used as the gold standard for measuring visual acuity of pre-schoolers in a semi urban area. Lea chart can be used in the absence of HOTV chart. Frisby and Titmus charts are good screening tools, but with poor diagnostic criteria.


Related Articles

  • A consideration of binocular parameters in the spectacle correction of anisometropic amblyopia: A Case Report. Shaw, Peter J.; Bobier, William R. // Optometry & Vision Development;2012, Vol. 43 Issue 2, p67 

    Background: Recent evidence points to the use of spectacles alone in the treatment of anisometropic amblyopia. However, the impact of this treatment on the restoration of binocular vision is often not considered. Case Report: Patient M.Z., aged 7 years, showed 3.5D of anisometropia which was...

  • Avian vision. GREU, ELDON // Birder's World;Feb2011, Vol. 25 Issue 1, p44 

    The article presents information on bird's eyes. It mentions that bird's eyes are proportionately much larger than human eyes, that enables birds to see in much dimmer light than humans require. It provides information on anatomy of eyes of various species of birds such as hawks, robins, and...

  • Binocular Function in Pseudophakic Children. Ing, Malcolm R. // Journal of Pediatric Ophthalmology & Strabismus;Jan/Feb2011, Vol. 48 Issue 1, p13 

    Purpose: The author reports the results of visual and binocular tests performed on patients who had primary insertion of intraocular lenses following the removal of cataracts in their childhood. Methods: Monocular and binocular tests were performed on 21 patients using the same equipment for...

  • Prevalence and reporting of near-point binocular convergence and acuity vision deficits in potential research participants. Ament, Patrick A.; Robbins, Darcy K.; Brockman, Callie J.; Hawkins, Raeanna; Lake, Susan; Bazin, M. Beth // Behavior Research Methods;Feb2008, Vol. 40 Issue 1, p309 

    Visual abilities at near-point distances of 200 self-reported normal vision college students were assessed. Results show that normal visual functioning with no deficits is the exception. The most common visual deficits observed involved binocular lateral posture and fusion convergence deficits....

  • Binocular coordination, acuity, and locomotion: Interacting with objects in the environment. Knowlton, Marie; Lee, Inkyung // Re:View;Fall95, Vol. 27 Issue 3, p133 

    Addresses issues relating to the perception of motion, the visual mechanisms of binocular coordination, perception of impending collision, and body movement to avoid collision. Examination of the role of the mechanisms as children interact with a moving object; Empirical findings on visual...

  • Intracorneal Asymmetrical Rings for Keratoconus: Where Should the Thicker Segment Be Implanted? Alió, Jorge L.; Shabayek, Mohamed H. // Journal of Refractive Surgery;Mar2006, Vol. 22 Issue 3, p307 

    PURPOSE: To report a 20-year-old man who presented with monocular diplopia in the right eye with uncorrected visual acuity (UCVA) of 0.3 and best spectacle-corrected visual acuity (BSCVA) of 1.0 with -0.50 -3.00 x 45°. METHODS: Clinical examination and corneal topography revealed cone more...

  • Posterior scleritis mimicking indirect carotid-cavernous fistula. Kah, Tan Aik; Premsenthil, Mallika; Salowi, Mohamad Aziz; Thanaraj, Asokumaran; Gudom, Intan ak // Internet Journal of Ophthalmology & Visual Science;2009, Vol. 7 Issue 1, p7 

    Purpose: To report a case of posterior scleritis that mimicked indirect carotid-cavernous fistula. Case Report: A 53 year old lady presented with two weeks' history of right eye redness and blurring of vision associated with right sided headache and ocular pain. The episcleral vessels were...

  • Tests of Fixation Preference for Amblyopia. Wallace, David K. // American Orthoptic Journal;2005, Vol. 55, p76 

    In preverbal children with strabismus, binocular fixation pattern is often assessed to detect amblyopia. In those children without strabismus or with small angle deviations, the induced tropia test is frequently used instead. There are many variations in the techniques used to perform these...

  • Unilateral Cataracts: Is Successful Amblyopia Therapy Compatible with Binocular Vision? Sketchley, Mara; Cline, Roy A. // American Orthoptic Journal;2005, Vol. 55, p82 

    Background and Purpose: Two case studies are used to illustrate the importance of balancing the postsurgical achievement of high-level visual acuity with the acquisition of stereopsis in cases of unilateral cataract. Traditional management will be reviewed and limited occlusion therapy will he...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics