'Formal' Versus 'Empirical' Approaches to Quantum-Classical Reduction

Rosaler, Joshua
October 2015
Topoi;Oct2015, Vol. 34 Issue 2, p325
Academic Journal
I distinguish two types of reduction within the context of quantum-classical relations, which I designate 'formal' and 'empirical'. Formal reduction holds or fails to hold solely by virtue of the mathematical relationship between two theories; it is therefore a two-place, a priori relation between theories. Empirical reduction requires one theory to encompass the range of physical behaviors that are well-modeled in another theory; in a certain sense, it is a three-place, a posteriori relation connecting the theories and the domain of physical reality that both serve to describe. Focusing on the relationship between classical and quantum mechanics, I argue that while certain formal results concerning singular $$\hbar \rightarrow 0$$ limits have been taken to preclude the possibility of reduction between these theories, such results at most provide support for the claim that singular limits block reduction in the formal sense; little if any reason has been given for thinking that they block reduction in the empirical sense. I then briefly outline a strategy for empirical reduction that is suggested by work on decoherence theory, arguing that this sort of account remains a fully viable route to the empirical reduction of classical to quantum mechanics and is unaffected by such singular limits.


Related Articles

  • Quantum Structures of a Model-Universe: An Inconsistency with Everett Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics. Jeknić-Dugić, J.; Dugić, M.; Francom, A. // International Journal of Theoretical Physics;Jan2014, Vol. 53 Issue 1, p169 

    We observe a Quantum Brownian Motion (QBM) Model Universe in conjunction with recently established Entanglement Relativity and Parallel Occurrence of Decoherence. The Parallel Occurrence of Decoherence establishes the simultaneous occurrence of decoherence for two mutually irreducible structures...

  • Surface hopping, transition state theory and decoherence. I. Scattering theory and time-reversibility. Jain, Amber; Herman, Michael F.; Wenjun Ouyang; Subotnik, Joseph E. // Journal of Chemical Physics;2015, Vol. 143 Issue 13, p1 

    We provide an in-depth investigation of transmission coefficients as computed using the augmentedfewest switches surface hopping algorithm in the low energy regime. Empirically, microscopic reversibility is shown to hold approximately. Furthermore, we show that, in some circumstances, including...

  • Dissipative quantum systems: from two to many atoms. Polett, Dario; George, Antoine; Georges, Antoine; Bernier, Jean-Sébastien; Kollath, Corinna // Annual International Conference on Optoelectronics, Photonics & ;02/04/2013, p37 

    We study the dynamics of bosonic atoms in a double well potential under the influence of dissipation. The main effect of dissipation is to destroy quantum co-herence and to drive the system towards a unique steady state. We study how the atom-atom interaction affects the decoherence process. We...

  • Behavior of Quantum Fisher Information of Bell Pairs under Decoherence Channels. OZAYDIN, F.; ALTINTAS, A. A.; BUGU, S.; YESILYURT, C. // Acta Physica Polonica, A.;Feb2014, Vol. 125 Issue 2, p601 

    Quantum Fisher information has recently been an essential tool for analyzing the phase sensitivity of the quantum states in various quantum tasks, requiring high precision, such as quantum clock synchronization, positioning and many applications which include quantum interferometers. Due to the...

  • A Comparison Between Models of Gravity Induced Decoherence. Donadi, Sandro; Bera, Sayantani; Singh, Tejinder; Lochan, Kinjalk // Foundations of Physics;Dec2015, Vol. 45 Issue 12, p1537 

    It has been suggested in the literature that spatial coherence of the wave function can be dynamically suppressed by fluctuations in the spacetime geometry. These fluctuations represent the minimal uncertainty that is present when one probes spacetime geometry with a quantum probe. Two similar...

  • Fundamental physical ontologies and the constraint of empirical coherence: a defense of wave function realism. Ney, Alyssa // Synthese;Oct2015, Vol. 192 Issue 10, p3105 

    This paper defends wave function realism against the charge that the view is empirically incoherent because our evidence for quantum theory involves facts about objects in three-dimensional space or space-time (local beables). It also criticizes previous attempts to defend wave function realism...

  • Relating quantum discord with the quantum dense coding capacity. Wang, Xin; Qiu, Liang; Li, Song; Zhang, Chi; Ye, Bin // Journal of Experimental & Theoretical Physics;Jan2015, Vol. 120 Issue 1, p9 

    We establish the relations between quantum discord and the quantum dense coding capacity in ( n + 1)-particle quantum states. A necessary condition for the vanishing discord monogamy score is given. We also find that the loss of quantum dense coding capacity due to decoherence is bounded below...

  • Quantum walk coherences on a dynamical percolation graph. Elster, Fabian; Barkhofen, Sonja; Nitsche, Thomas; Novotný, Jaroslav; Gábris, Aurél; Jex, Igor; Silberhorn, Christine // Scientific Reports;8/28/2015, p13495 

    Coherent evolution governs the behaviour of all quantum systems, but in nature it is often subjected to influence of a classical environment. For analysing quantum transport phenomena quantum walks emerge as suitable model systems. In particular, quantum walks on percolation structures...

  • The consistent histories approach to loop quantum cosmology. Craig, David A. // International Journal of Modern Physics D: Gravitation, Astrophy;Jul2016, Vol. 25 Issue 8, p-1 

    We review the application of the consistent (or decoherent) histories formulation of quantum theory to canonical loop quantum cosmology. Conventional quantum theory relies crucially on 'measurements' to convert unrealized quantum potentialities into physical outcomes that can be assigned...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics