Deceased Organ Donation Registration and Familial Consent among Chinese and South Asians in Ontario, Canada

Li, Alvin Ho-ting; McArthur, Eric; Maclean, Janet; Isenor, Cynthia; Prakash, Versha; Kim, S. Joseph; Knoll, Greg; Shah, Baiju; Garg, Amit X.
July 2015
PLoS ONE;7/31/2015, Vol. 10 Issue 7, p1
Academic Journal
Objective: For various reasons, people of Chinese (China, Hong Kong or Taiwan) and South Asian (Indian subcontinent) ancestry (the two largest ethnic minority groups in Ontario, Canada) may be less likely to register for deceased organ donation than the general public, and their families may be less likely to consent for deceased organ donation at the time of death. Methods: We conducted two population-based studies: (1) a cross-sectional study of deceased organ donor registration as of May 2013, and (2) a cohort study of the steps in proceeding with deceased organ donation for patients who died in hospital from October 2008 to December 2012. Results: A total of 49 938 of 559 714 Chinese individuals (8.9%) and 47 774 of 374 291 South Asians (12.8%) were registered for deceased organ donation, proportions lower than the general public (2 676 260 of 10 548 249 (25.4%). Among the 168 703 Ontarians who died in a hospital, the families of 33 of 81 Chinese (40.1%; 95% CI: 30.7%-51.6%) and 39 of 72 South Asian individuals (54.2%; 95% CI: 42.7-65.2%) consented for deceased organ donation, proportions lower than the general public (68.3%; 95% CI: 66.4%-70.0%). Conclusions: In Ontario, Canada Chinese and South Asian individuals are less likely to register and their families are less likely to consent to deceased organ donation compared to the remaining general public. There is an opportunity to build support for organ and tissue donation in these two large ethnic communities in Canada.


Related Articles

  • The impact of checking the Australian Organ Donor Register on family consent rates. Stephens, Hugh D.; Pilcher, David V.; Opdam, Helen I., // Medical Journal of Australia;10/21/2013, Vol. 199 Issue 8, p536 

    A letter to the editor which discusses the consent rate of families involved in requesting organ donation registered in the Australian Organ Donor Register is presented.

  • Living Donation by Individuals with Life-Limiting Conditions. Ross, Lainie Friedman; Thistlethwaite, J. Richard; Cook-Deegan, Robert; Majumder, Mary A.; McGuire, Amy L. // Journal of Law, Medicine & Ethics;Spring2019, Vol. 47 Issue 1, p112 

    The traditional living donor was very healthy. However, as the supply-demand gap continues to expand, transplant programs have become more accepting of less healthy donors. This paper focuses on the other extreme, asking whether and when individuals who have life-limiting conditions (LLC) should...

  • Creating my personalized organ donation directive. Shaw, David // Intensive Care Medicine;Sep2014, Vol. 40 Issue 9, p1370 

    The author comments on making his personalized organ donation directive (PODD). He discusses his reason for his willingness to donate an organ, his way to assure that his family respects his decision to donate an organ upon his death, a procedure for making a PODD and the advantages of using a PODD.

  • Opt-out and consent. MacKay, Douglas // Journal of Medical Ethics;Oct2015, Vol. 41 Issue 10, p832 

    A chief objection to opt-out organ donor registration policies is that they do not secure people's actual consent to donation, and so fail to respect their autonomy rights to decide what happens to their organs after they die. However, scholars have recently offered two powerful responses to...

  • New Liver Allocation Policy: Flawed Moral and Empirical Foundations.  // Journal of Law, Medicine & Ethics;Summer2019, Vol. 47 Issue 2, p320 

    The article discusses the ethical aspects of the liver allocation policy that was adopted by the Board of Directors of the Organ Procurement and Transplantation Network (OPTN) on December 3, 2018, and it mentions the claim that the geographic boundaries of OPTN-designated Donor Specific Areas...

  • Solid Organ Donation Between Strangers. Ross, Lainie Friedman // Journal of Law, Medicine & Ethics;Fall2002, Vol. 30 Issue 3, p440 

    Describes a protocol of organ donation between strangers at hospitals in the U.S. Ethical and policy critique of the nondirected donation protocol; Details on the ethical guidelines for organ donations; Principle of nonmaleficence.

  • Illinois Department of Motor Vehicle Customers' Reasons for (Not) Registering as an Organ Donor. Reynolds-Tylus, Tobias; Quick, Brian L.; King, Andy J.; Moore, Miriam // Progress in Transplantation;Jun2019, Vol. 29 Issue 2, p157 

    Context: Organ donation campaigns are maximized when promotional messages address salient issues among the intended audience. A diverse sample (N = 1573) was recruited to identify the reasons for (not) registering as an organ donor. Objective: Relying on an established coding scheme, an updated...

  • Medical Mailbox. SerVaas, Cory; Braun, Wendy // Saturday Evening Post;Jan/Feb2012, Vol. 284 Issue 1, p72 

    The article presents questions and answers related to the effectiveness of light therapy in treating seasonal depression, the implications of organ donor designation on one's driver's license in the event of injury, and the frequency of gout in middle-aged men.

  • 'In plain language': uniform criteria for organ donor recognition. Kompanje, Erwin; Jansen, Nichon; Groot, Yorick // Intensive Care Medicine;Aug2013, Vol. 39 Issue 8, p1492 

    An introduction to the journal is presented in which the guest editors discuss the number of potential organ donors to organ procurement organizations in Canada.


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics