Resolution Requirements for the Simulation of Deep Moist Convection

Bryan, George H.; Wyngaard, John C.; Fritsch, J. Michael
October 2003
Monthly Weather Review;Oct2003, Vol. 131 Issue 10, p2394
Academic Journal
The spatial resolution appropriate for the simulation of deep moist convection is addressed from a turbulence perspective. To provide a clear theoretical framework for the problem, techniques for simulating turbulent flows are reviewed, and the source of the subgrid terms in the Navier–Stokes equation is clarified. For decades, cloud-resolving models have used large-eddy simulation (LES) techniques to parameterize the subgrid terms. A literature review suggests that the appropriateness of using traditional LES closures for this purpose has never been established. Furthermore, examination of the assumptions inherent in these closures suggests that grid spacing on the order of 100 m may be required for the performance of cloud models to be consistent with their design. Based on these arguments, numerical simulations of squall lines were conducted with grid spacings between 1 km and 125 m. The results reveal that simulations with 1-km grid spacing do not produce equivalent squall-line structure and evolution as compared to the higher-resolution simulations. Details of the simulated squall lines that change as resolution is increased include precipitation amount, system phase speed, cloud depth, static stability values, the size of thunderstorm cells, and the organizational mode of convective overturning (e.g., upright towers versus sloped plumes). It is argued that the ability of the higher-resolution runs to become turbulent leads directly to the differences in evolution. There appear to be no systematic trends in specific fields as resolution is increased. For example, mean vertical velocity and rainwater values increase in magnitude with increasing resolution in some environments, but decrease with increasing resolution in other environments. The statistical properties of the simulated squall lines are still not converged between the 250- and 125-m runs. Several possible explanations for the lack of convergence are offered. Nevertheless, it is clear that simulations with O(1 km) grid spacing should not be used as benchmark or control solutions for resolution sensitivity studies. The simulations also support the contention that a minimum grid spacing of O(100 m) is required for traditional LES closures to perform appropriately for their design. Specifically, only simulations with 250- and 125-m grid spacing resolve an inertial subrange. In contrast, the 1-km simulations do not even reproduce the correct magnitude or scale of the spectral kinetic energy maximum. Furthermore, the 1-km simulations contain an unacceptably large amount of subgrid turbulence kinetic energy, and do not adequately resolve turbulent fluxes of total water. A guide to resolution requirements for the operational and research communities is proposed. The proposal is based primarily on the intended use of the model output. Even though simulations with O(1 km) grid spacing display behavior that is unacceptable for the model design, it is argued that these simulations can still provide valuable information to operational forecasters. For the research community, O(100 m) grid spacing is recommended for most applications, because a modeling system that is well founded should be desired for most purposes.


Related Articles

  • A Modelling Study of Flux Imbalance and the Influence of Entrainment in the Convective Boundary Layer. Huang, Jianping; Lee, Xuhui; Patton, Edward // Boundary-Layer Meteorology;May2008, Vol. 127 Issue 2, p273 

    It is frequently observed in field experiments that the eddy covariance heat fluxes are systematically underestimated as compared to the available energy. The flux imbalance problem is investigated using the NCAR�s large-eddy simulation (LES) model imbedded with an online scheme to...

  • Convective Transport Theory for Surface Fluxes Tested over the Western Pacific Warm Pool. Greischar, Lawrence; Stull, Roland // Journal of the Atmospheric Sciences;7/1/99, Vol. 56 Issue 13, p2201 

    Presents a study which tested the convective transport theory (CCT) for a marine boundary layer using turbulent flux measurements during light to moderate winds. Discussion on the theory; Overview of related studies on the subject; Data from the National Center for Atmospheric Research's...

  • Mean meridional circulation driven by eddy forcings of different timescales. Chang, Edmund K. M. // Journal of the Atmospheric Sciences;1/1/96, Vol. 53 Issue 1, p113 

    Examines mean meridional circulation (MMC) forced by eddy fluxes of heat and momentum using a simple quasigeostrophic, two-level model of the zonal-mean atmosphere. Analysis of the eddy-induced MMC using Kuo-Eliassen equation; Author's finding that for steady-state or low-frequency...

  • Towards a Validation of Scintillometer Measurements: The LITFASS-2009 Experiment. Beyrich, Frank; Bange, Jens; Hartogensis, Oscar; Raasch, Siegfried; Braam, Miranda; Dinther, Daniëlle; Gräf, Doreen; Kesteren, Bram; Kroonenberg, Aline; Maronga, Björn; Martin, Sabrina; Moene, Arnold // Boundary-Layer Meteorology;Jul2012, Vol. 144 Issue 1, p83 

    Scintillometry has been increasingly used over the last decade for the experimental determination of area-averaged turbulent fluxes at a horizontal scale of a few kilometres. Nevertheless, a number of assumptions in the scintillometer data processing and interpretation still call for a thorough...

  • A Combined Eddy-Diffusivity Mass-Flux Approach for the Convective Boundary Layer. Siebesma, A. Pier; Soares, Pedro M. M.; Teixeira, João // Journal of the Atmospheric Sciences;Apr2007, Vol. 64 Issue 4, p1230 

    A better conceptual understanding and more realistic parameterizations of convective boundary layers in climate and weather prediction models have been major challenges in meteorological research. In particular, parameterizations of the dry convective boundary layer, in spite of the absence of...

  • A Simple Model for Pollution Dispersion in a Convective Boundary Layer. Stull, Roland; Ainslie, Bruce // Journal of Applied Meteorology & Climatology;Dec2006, Vol. 45 Issue 12, p1727 

    A simplified model for dispersion in a convective boundary layer is presented and is used to diagnose crosswind-integrated concentrations, ground-level concentrations, and vertical plume spread over flat terrain for various release heights. The model parameterizes the long-wavelength oscillation...

  • Large Eddy Simulation of Shallow Cumulus Convection during BOMEX: Sensitivity to Microphysics and Radiation. Hongli Jiang; Cotton, William R. // Journal of the Atmospheric Sciences;2/15/2000, Vol. 57 Issue 4, p582 

    Presents information on a study which investigated the sensitivity of shallow marine cumulus convection to drizzle and radiation effects and how drizzle and radiation modify turbulent fluxes using large eddy simulation (LES). Overview of LES model; Description of the large-scale conditions;...

  • A Solution for Flux Contamination by Mesoscale Motions With Very Weak Turbulence. Vickers, Dean; Mahrt, L. // Boundary-Layer Meteorology;Mar2006, Vol. 118 Issue 3, p431 

    In weak wind stable conditions, eddy-correlation fluxes calculated using conventional averaging times of 5 min or longer to define the perturbations are severely contaminated by poorly sampled mesoscale motions. A method is developed to identify the averaging time for each individual data record...

  • Understanding Hector: The Dynamics of Island Thunderstorms. Crook, N. Andrew // Monthly Weather Review;Jun2001, Vol. 129 Issue 6, p1550 

    Examines the development of island thunderstorms, particularly the Hector convective system that forms over the Tiwi Islands near Australia. Influence of the lifting on flow speed and direction and heating rate; Numerical simulations; Comparison between island and continental convection.


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics