Consent for clinical research in the neonatal intensive care unit: a retrospective survey and a prospective study

Burgess, E.; Singhal, N.; Amin, H.; McMillan, D.D.; Devrome, H.
July 2003
Archives of Disease in Childhood -- Fetal & Neonatal Edition;Jul2003, Vol. 88 Issue 4, pF280
Academic Journal
Background: Recruitment into research studies in the neonatal intensive care unit has been problematic. Therefore suggestions have been made to take decision making about enrolment out of the hands of the parents. Objective: To understand parental perceptions of the process of recruitment and enrolment for research in the neonatal intensive care unit. Method: A questionnaire was developed and used in both a retrospective survey and a prospective study of parents whose newborns were enrolled in trials in a neonatal intensive care unit. Closed ended and open ended questions were included, as well as demographic questions. Results: The retrospective survey had a 79% response rate (29 of 38). Overall, 90% of parents felt that they had made informed decisions, and 93% were against the option that a doctor decide if the newborn should be enrolled into a study, rather than the parent. Although some parents (38%) found that recruitment did add "stress to an already stressful situation", 90% felt that they had made informed decisions and understood the elements of the study. Most parents had been requested to enrol their newborn into more than one trial, and, on average, they thought that they would be comfortable with enrolment into two studies (range 0-6). When asked how the process could be improved, parents suggested that information be made available before delivery. The responses of parents in the prospective study were mostly consistent with those from the retrospective survey. Conclusions: Overall the parents did not support the suggestion that decision making about enrolment be taken away from parents and put into the hands of doctors. The healthcare team should support parents in their role of decision maker, enhance availability of the research staff, and provide more information about the research.


Related Articles

  • Preterm erken membran r�pt�r� olan gebelerin perinatal sonu�larinin degerlendirilmesi. �etin, Orkun; �etin, Ipek Dokurel; Sen, Cihat; Uludag, Seyfettin; Aydogan, Beg�m; T�ten, Abdullah // Perinatal Journal / Perinatoloji Dergisi;Aug2012, Vol. 20 Issue 2, p49 

    Objective: Evaluation of perinatal outcomes of pregnant with preterm premature rupture of membrane (PPROM) who applied to our clinic. Methods: The study was designed as a cross- sectional study and performed at the Perinatology Department, Medical Faculty of Istanbul University Cerrahpasa...

  • Adli karar yetkililerinin yenidoÄŸan yoÄŸun bakım ünitesinde hasta izlemindeki rolü: Bir vaka takdimi. Çalışıcı, Erhan; Oğuz, Şerife Suna; Öncel, Mehmet Yekta; Erdeve, Ömer; Dilmen, Uğur // Cocuk Sagligi ve Hastaliklari Dergisi;oca-mar2012, Vol. 55 Issue 1, p35 

    Invasive procedures are frequently performed in neonatal intensive care units. Unlike in adult patients, consent of the parents or conservators is sought for decisions pertaining to the medical procedure in neonates. However, physicians encounter some important problems when making critical and...

  • Effect of antenatal depression on maternal dietary intake and neonatal outcome: a prospective cohort. Saeed, Ayesha; Raana, Tahira; Muhammad Saeed, Amina; Humayun, Ayesha; Saeed, Amina Muhammad // Nutrition Journal;7/11/2016, Vol. 15, p1 

    Background: In Pakistan, incidence of antenatal depression ranges from 18 to 80 %, which goes undiagnosed, resulting in maternal and neonatal implications. The current study aimed to examine the association of antenatal depression with maternal dietary intake and neonatal...

  • In Their Own Voices: Families Discuss End-of-Life Decision Making -- Part 1. Dokken, Deborah L. // Pediatric Nursing;Mar/Apr2006, Vol. 32 Issue 2, p173 

    One parent's experience with her daughter in a neonatal intensive care unit (NICU) and pediatric intensive care unit (PICU) setting sheds light on parental involvement in end-of-life decision making. For this parent, collaborative decision making was facilitated in an environment where the...

  • Determining the best interests of a critically ill baby. Griffith, Richard // British Journal of Midwifery;Jan2012, Vol. 20 Issue 1, p70 

    The article discusses the legal issues associated with the care and treatment of critically ill neonates. An overview of cases in Great Britain, involving parents in conflict with those of the midwife and medical team to determine whether continued treatment is in the baby's best interests, is...

  • Beyond autonomy: Coercion and morality in clinical relationships. Bloche, M. Gregg // Health Matrix: Journal of Law-Medicine;Summer96, Vol. 6 Issue 2, p229 

    Examines the conception of autonomy undergirding the jurisprudence of informed consent, and sheds light on what drives disputes about whether one or another influence method is compatible with autonomous choice. Bioethics treatment of autonomy; Alternative accounts of autonomy-negating...

  • Commentary. Jones, Michael A. // BMJ: British Medical Journal (International Edition);1/7/95, Vol. 310 Issue 6971, p46 

    Opinion. Discusses the legal aspect of informed consent in Great Britain. Context of the law on consent to medical treatment; Distinction from the law on negligence; Implications of a doctor's genuine belief that a patient was consenting; Ruling in the case of `Davis v. Barking, Havering and...

  • Advanced medical directive.  // Consumer Reports on Health;Sep93, Vol. 5 Issue 9, p95 

    Presents a sample form of an advanced medical directive. Treatments; Situations; Cardiopulmonary resuscitation; Mechanical respiration; Artificial feeding; Kidney dialysis; Major surgery; More.

  • Disclosure and use of personal health information. Woodward, Beverly // BMJ: British Medical Journal (International Edition);3/16/96, Vol. 312 Issue 7032, p653 

    Comments on the proposed Disclosure and Use of Personal Health Information Bill in Great Britain. Difficulty of legislating in the subject of medical confidentiality; Permission of personal health information disclosure without patient consent; Focus of bill on individuals and bodies providing...


Read the Article


Sign out of this library

Other Topics